DaiZY 2023-05-23

Hello, I recently submitted my first article to TPEL. I would like to know if I need to manually check the historical status of the manuscript on the website, meaning do I need to keep track of the time points myself?

windleader 2023-05-20

During the major repair, the AE stopped for about a month. We can only wait patiently.

dian 2023-05-19

I also received the AE processing result on May 19th. It has been half a month since waiting for AE.

chenhhhh 2023-05-18

After 1 round of revisions, it took approximately 7 months to complete. Accepted on January 31, 2023.

windleader 2023-05-17

2023.5.16 Received. Another friend also received the notification at the same time, it should be that the editor-in-chief started working.

cuidingsong 2023-05-17

What is the final result?

windleader 2023-05-16

Major revisions
Submitted major revisions on March 13, 2023
Awaiting co-eic decision on May 3, 2023
Awaiting eic decision on May 7, 2023
Still awaiting eic decision on May 15, 2023. It's frustrating, last time my major revisions were rejected, and it also took too long in the hands of the EIC.

cuidingsong 2023-05-13

How long did AE last in the end?

蓝色的风18 2023-05-12

Normally, there should be a step called "awaiting reviewer scores". I feel a bit concerned about yours, it seems risky.

abelard 2023-05-11

Now it has become awaiting EIC decision, the time span is less than two days.

abelard 2023-05-10

Does changing from "in review process" to "Awaiting Co-EIC Recommendation" on the same day mean that it does not meet the scope of the journal and will be rejected?

wqee 2023-05-08

Why is your review so fast?

金典喵 2023-05-07

2023.05.04 major revision

蓝色的风18 2023-05-04

No page limit.

abelard 2023-05-03

May I ask how many pages need to be controlled for the initial submission of this journal? Thank you.

abelard 2023-05-03

May I ask how many pages need to be controlled for the initial submission of this journal?

蓝色的风18 2023-05-01

After being selected for this paper, I became a reviewer for this journal. Moreover, almost every once in a while, they ask me to review one or two papers. Does anyone have a similar situation?

蓝色的风18 2023-05-01

No need to control the number of pages.

金典喵 2023-04-24

2023.04.24 Esperando la Recomendación de SSGAE

2023.04.24 Waiting for SSGAE Recommendation

韭菜 2023-04-24

10-Dec-2022 Submit
23-Feb-2023 Revision (6 weeks, neither accept or reject)
15-Mar-2023 Resubmit
03-Apr-2023 Accept with minor revisions or without change
Generally, there are three reviewers, fewer than TIE's reviewers, and the process is also faster.

金典喵 2023-04-20

2023.04.10 Submit (Submitted on April 10, 2023)
2023.04.20 Awaiting Reviewer Scores (Waiting for reviewer scores on April 20, 2023)

jz_c 2023-04-17

Hello, do we need to control the number of pages after resubmitting the rejected manuscript? Should the revised version be limited to 8 pages?

jz_c 2023-04-17

Hello, may I ask if the resubmission of rejected articles needs to be limited to 8 pages?

嘎哥 2023-02-19

2022.10.17 Resubmit
2022.10.17 In review process
2022.10.24 Awaiting reviewer scores
2022.11.24 Awaiting AE recommendation
2022.11.30 Awaiting co-EIC decision, awaiting EIC decision
2022.12.14 Conditionally accept with major mandatory changes (4 weeks)
2023.1.8 Resubmit
2023.1.15 Awaiting reviewer scores
2023.2.12 Awaiting AE recommendation
2023.2.14 Awaiting co-EIC decision, awaiting EIC decision
2023.2.18 Accept

2022.10.17 Resubmit
2022.10.17 In review process
2022.10.24 Awaiting reviewer scores
2022.11.24 Awaiting Associate Editor recommendation
2022.11.30 Awaiting co-Editor-in-Chief decision, awaiting Editor-in-Chief decision
2022.12.14 Conditionally accept with major mandatory changes (4 weeks)
2023.1.8 Resubmit
2023.1.15 Awaiting reviewer scores
2023.2.12 Awaiting Associate Editor recommendation
2023.2.14 Awaiting co-Editor-in-Chief decision, awaiting Editor-in-Chief decision
2023.2.18 Accept

嘎哥 2023-02-19

Second TPEL, sharing a bit.

2022.7.4 Submit
2022.7.5 Awaiting admin processing
2022.7.6 Awaiting AE assignment
2022.7.9 Awaiting reviewer scores
2022.8.27 Awaiting AE recommendation
2022.9.2 Awaiting co-EIC decision, awaiting EIC decision
2022.9.8 Revision (6 weeks, neither accept nor reject)

alpha_cr7 2023-02-13

Re-submission after rejection requires: 1. Revised manuscript; 2. Detailed response to reviewers; 3. Cover letter.

alpha_cr7 2023-02-13

Did the editor assign a new reviewer to your manuscript after it was rejected and resubmitted?

alpha_cr7 2023-02-13

Have you added new reviewers after rejecting and resubmitting the manuscript?

Old Head Happy 2023-02-10

Forgot to mention, it's a long article.

Old Head Happy 2023-02-10

In the review process, send an email after two months and make major revisions one week later. Comrades, if it has been more than two months, continue to urge and don't be afraid!