蓝色的风18 2023-07-09

Your speed is fast~ Why is our co-eic so slow?

亮云飞羽2 2023-07-08

I reached EIC.

蓝色的风18 2023-07-08

Should I send an email to ask? I'm confused.

heyhey 2023-07-08

Not yet, it's been over two weeks already.

亮云飞羽2 2023-07-08

Has your Co-eic status changed? I have also reached this status.

多目标进化优化 2023-07-07

2023.07.06 awaiting AE recommendation. - Translation: We are waiting for the recommendation of the Associate Editor.

2023.07.07 awaiting EIC decision. - Translation: We are waiting for the decision of the Editor-in-Chief.

蓝色的风18 2023-07-07

No, it's still co-eic. I've been here for almost two weeks too. I guess it's the same person.

亮云飞羽2 2023-07-06

Has your co-eic status changed?

多目标进化优化 2023-07-06

The time written above is all wrong, all are in 2023.
2023.07.02 Awaiting AE recommendation.
2023.07.03 Awaiting reviewer scores.

I thought I had reached AE, but within a day, I was sent back. I don't know what happened, but it doesn't feel good.

heyhey 2023-07-05

I have been AE for one week, and then co-EiC for two weeks.

亮云飞羽2 2023-07-05

It has been almost two weeks waiting for AE (Account Executive) recommendation. Could it be that all the AEs have been on vacation recently?

heyhey 2023-07-05

It has been two weeks and there is still no change.

蓝色的风18 2023-07-02

It has been a week already... Is the co-eic this slow? /(ㄒoㄒ)/~~

GREENY 2023-07-02

Is there any new reviewer added?

GREENY 2023-07-02

May I ask how long it takes to submit for review?

heyhey 2023-06-29

Just wait a little longer, hoping for a good outcome.

蓝色的风18 2023-06-28

I have been in this state for 5 days as well...

heyhey 2023-06-28

Still looking for reviewers, I've been looking for one month at this stage.

增厝安小学徒 2023-06-28

2023.06.08 submit
2023.06.28 still in review process
Is the editor still considering whether to submit it for review, or are they unable to find a reviewer?

heyhey 2023-06-28

It has been a week since my submission of "awaiting co-EIC recommendation." Is this normal?

金典喵 2023-06-27

Major revision 6 weeks
2023.06.13 Resubmit
2023.06.27 Awaiting SSGAE Recommendation

Translation:

A significant revision is required within a period of 6 weeks.
Resubmit by June 13th, 2023.
Awaiting SSGAE (Specific Subject General Academic Education) Recommendation by June 27th, 2023.

蓝色的风18 2023-06-25

Yes, generally it is 4 weeks.

杲阳 2023-06-21

2022.11.17 submission;
2023.02.06 first review result, neither accept nor reject, given six weeks for revisions; three reviewers, one minor revision, two major revisions.
2023.03.08 revised version submitted;
2023.04.15 second review result, conditionally accept with major mandatory changes, given four weeks for revisions; two reviewers have no comments, one reviewer requests major revisions. The reviewer who requests major revisions is surprisingly more severe in tone compared to the first round and raises some confusing questions, but still earnestly made changes for 20 days.
2023.05.05 revised version submitted;
2023.05.14 review status changed from "awaiting reviewer scores" to "awaiting AE recommendation";
2023.06.09 awaiting Co-EIC recommendation;
2023.06.10 awaiting EIC decision;
2023.06.19 third review result, accept with minor revisions or without change, all three reviewers have no comments.
Waiting for the results of the third round of review is really nerve-wracking, but fortunately, it turned out well.

唐老鸭呀1 2023-06-21

Very good, great!

SQY123 2023-06-21

What is the current status now?

亮云飞羽2 2023-06-09

May I ask everyone how long is the time to submit the revised TPE manuscript to the reviewer? Is it still 4 weeks?

Mr.E 2023-06-06

2023.04.05 Submitted
2023.04.07 In Review Process
2023.04.27 Awaiting Reviewer Scores
2023.05.20 Awaiting AE Recommendation
2023.05.30 Awaiting Co-EIC Decision, Awaiting EIC Decision
2023.06.03 Revision (6 weeks) Two reviewers provided major and minor revisions, additional experiments are required... No more explanation, let's work hard.

多目标进化优化 2023-06-04

Submission Experience:
2022.05.29 Submission
2022.06.02 in review process
2022.06.04 awaiting reviewer scores

Peter朱求PLE 2023-06-03

2022.8.28 Submission
2022.10.27 First round of revisions, rejection can be resubmitted, 3 reviewers, 15 questions, mainly regarding unclear contributions and logic.
2023.3.21 Major revision and resubmission (took a break to work on a project for the teacher).
2023.4.22 Second round of revisions, neither accepted nor rejected, 3 reviewers, 8 questions.
2023.5.24 Second round of revisions.
2023.6.2 Accepted.
Some points to note in between:
1. Maintain a calm mindset after rejection. This is a top journal in the industry with high requirements for theoretical innovation, expression, and review.
2. Write the revision comments carefully. I wrote 26 pages for the first review, and 13 pages for the second review, while my paper is only 13 pages long.
3. Clearly state the contributions made in the introduction and summarize at the end of each chapter.
4. It is preferable to include videos of practical testing. I uploaded 2 testing videos, which pleased the reviewers.
5. Avoid rushing others. One month for the first round and one month for the second round is a normal pace.

蓝色的风18 2023-06-02

Usually people search for it themselves, and reply to the comment below.