暮然未语 2023-08-09

I have had my second review, waiting for the AE decision for a month now.

nature and science 2023-08-07

In the first review, it has been one month since "Awaiting AE Decision". May I ask if it is possible to follow up on this?

XWZRBY 2023-07-16

I have also been waiting for six and a half months, and the status remains the same, in peer review all this time. I also have no idea about the current situation.

kaixinguopaper 2023-07-14

Are you from China or overseas? What type of article are you writing? Why does it take so long to find a reviewer?

wuts31 2023-07-11

It has been 6 months, and it is still in Peer Review.
An Associate Editor (AE) has been assigned, but the Document Editor (DE) has not.
I have sent two reminders, but both times received a reply saying they are still looking for reviewers. I am speechless.

Jurgn 2023-06-23

September 22, 2022: Submission
October 5, 2022: Rescinded, reason being the need for more detailed contribution from each author
October 6, 2022: Supplementary explanation of authors' contributions, resubmission
March 25, 2023: Reviewer comments (AQ), a total of 20 comments. Although it is AQ, some questions are really difficult to answer.
April 12, 2023: Uploaded response letter (13 pages) and felt like I have done my best to address the reviewer's questions.
June 9, 2023: Received acceptance notification.

Jurgn 2023-06-23

June 9th was given the employment notice.

XWZRBY 2023-06-16

We haven't displayed the distribution, and we don't know what process it is now.

kaixinguopaper 2023-06-15

I am the same, has your "de" not been assigned yet? I was assigned "de" a month ago, but the information only showed "ae" yesterday. Does it mean that "ae" has been assigned now, and the review process will start? Does it mean that the reviewers have not been confirmed yet?

XWZRBY 2023-06-14

Before, there were 4 displayed: EIC, DE (Not Assigned), SAE, ADM. Yesterday, AE was added, so now there are 5 displayed.

kaixinguopaper 2023-06-14

Could you please tell me what your previous status was? Did the previous peer review show DE, SAE? Has AE now replaced the previous SAE?

XWZRBY 2023-06-13

It has been 5 and a half months since submission. It has been in peer review all this time. Today, an associate editor (AE) was assigned, but the status is still in peer review. So, which step are we at now?

Winnieq 2023-06-06

Hello, congratulations to you! You're awesome. I submitted my manuscript on November 22nd, and after it was assigned SAE, DE has been in the "not assigned" status without any changes. Could you please let me know how many more processes it needs to go through?

ssqu0 2023-06-06

A tug of war lasting nearly two years... Finally, I am able to graduate.
2021-9-29 submitted
2022-1-24 rejected
2022-5-12 submitted (revised and resubmitted)
2023-3-29 major
2023-5-9 submitted
2023-6-5 Accept with Mandatory Minor Revisions Including English Usage

Guowei Ling 2023-06-05

Update: Finally, in May, the 26th provided the result. The first trial was accepted directly, although it took me 7 months for the first trial (it took 3 months just to allocate AE), I am very happy that the first trial was accepted directly.

SBShen 2023-05-31

This journal is really stupid. There are no peer reviewers, and it was in the hands of the editor for half a year before they said it wasn't suitable and lacked innovation. I should have returned it and submitted to another journal. Maybe I would have received the first-round results by now.

XWZRBY 2023-05-23

Is this journal review process really so slow? It has been almost 5 months since the first review...

Jurgn 2023-05-12

Explanation of the author's contributions, if there are multiple authors, it is recommended to provide as much detail as possible regarding the contribution of each author. Insufficiently detailed contribution descriptions may result in the submission being returned, which could cause a delay of approximately one month.

nature and science 2023-05-12

Hello, may I ask if the detailed explanation of each author's contribution should be filled in the corresponding box in the submission system, or should a separate document be uploaded?

SuperStar001 2023-04-27

Has the moderator now changed from "in peer review" back to "submitted"?

TheShine 2023-04-26

So, do we have to wait for the allocation of AE after the allocation of SAE and DE? Is it so slow this year?

Jurgn 2023-04-26

I am participating in TIFS for the first time and I am not familiar with the specific process. I looked it up online and found out that SAE stands for Senior Area Editor, and DE stands for Deputy Editor. Can someone who has submitted to TIFS before share their experience?

TheShine 2023-04-26

May I ask what "DE" is? It seems that there is no "DE" or "SAE" in 2021. Only "AE" exists.

Jurgn 2023-04-26

On April 26th, DE was allocated.

暮然未语 2023-04-23

Who knows what the situation is?

暮然未语 2023-04-23

I was also assigned SAE yesterday.

Guowei Ling 2023-04-22

May I ask what is the situation with the owner of the post? I also noticed an additional SAE when I opened it today, but mine was assigned. What does this SAE mean?
EIC: Conti, Mauro
SAE: Venturi, Daniele
ADM: Langdon, Mikaela

Jurgn 2023-04-22

April 22nd: SAE: Not Assigned

TheShine 2023-04-21

Will the allocation editor still send email notifications in 2023, or will it directly change to "in peer review" without notifying the author for submission?

投投算了 2023-04-19

How long did the OP wait for the AE decision?