陌路无悔 2022-09-17

The third paper TIE-ed, with approximately 7 months between the first and third papers, and nearly 4 months between the first and second papers. The third paper took less than 2 months, showing that TIE values speed. The process for the third paper is as follows:

2022.07.19: Submitted, and the next day it was already under review.
2022.08.15: First round of reviews with major revisions. There were four reviewers, and a total of seven comments, all aimed at improving the quality. The Associate Editor (AE) and Editor-in-Chief (EIC) took less than two hours to review the comments.
2022.08.17: Revised according to the comments and resubmitted, and on the same day, it was under review again.
2022.09.15: Accepted, a very fortunate submission, of course, the quality of the article was exceptional.

i6277 2022-09-14

The manuscript review came back in just one month. What's the situation? It's so fast!

i6277 2022-09-14

Has it been 2 weeks since the AE recommendation? Is it slow now?

THXWDN 2022-09-13

On September 13th, the status changed to "awaiting AE recommendation". I hope the reviewer will be gentle in their assessment.

abelard 2022-09-12

From submission until now, it has been three and a half months. It has been two weeks since awaiting AE recommendation. What's the situation?

一名研究僧 2022-09-09

Submission experience:
2022.04.15 submitted
2022.05.31 First review major revision, 4 reviewers with 26 comments
2022.07.08 First review response, nearly 30 pages
2022.08.10 Second review major revision, two reviewers with no issues, and two reviewers with 3 questions
2022.08.26 Second review response, 3 pages
2022.09.08 Accepted

THXWDN 2022-09-04

Finally today, September 4th, the status has changed to "under review"! Sigh, the wait has been heart-wrenching.

alpha_cr7 2022-09-04

On my side, it is also in the field of electrical and electronic engineering. I submitted it on July 31st, and on September 4th, it is awaiting AE (Associate Editor) recommendation. The speed is indeed quite fast!

THXWDN 2022-08-31

Update the dynamics. The latest news so far is that I received an email from the editor, which roughly states that the peer review process is very slow. We have already urged them on your behalf, and once they submit their review comments, we will handle it immediately.

The problem is that on my end, it only shows assigned to AE, and suddenly I received an email about peer review, which makes me suspect if the article has already been sent for external review, but the status was forgotten to be updated. I don't know if this situation exists or not.

yfzhang 2022-08-29

My assignment is also assigned to AE. In the past two months, it was changed to "under review." Currently, the review process has been ongoing for 4 months.

THXWDN 2022-08-23

I would like to ask everyone, I submitted on June 18th, and until now, August 23rd, it is still in the "assigned to AE" status (which has lasted for nearly two months). I am very anxious and don't know what to do. Can anyone please tell me if this situation means that my submission will likely be rejected?

在读博士，求PE 2022-08-19

Can someone help analyze what's going on with the repeated back-and-forth between AE recommendation and EIC Decision in the first trial? It has already occurred in the current situation where there is AE to EIC, EIC to AE, AE to EIC, and EIC to AE, and the time intervals are not fixed.

Gomendy 2022-08-16

2022.03 Submission, Under Review on the second day.
2022.07 After not receiving the first round of comments for 4 months, I contacted the EIC to inquire. After a few days, the EIC replied and urged the AE to handle it. Soon after, I received a Major Revision, with minor revisions from all three reviewers, and the EIC recommended major revisions.
2022.07 End of July, made revisions.
2022.08 Accepted.
Currently, the speed of Trans, except for the first round, is satisfactory. It is also related to the editor's interest in the article. Articles they are interested in should be reviewed and decided upon quickly.
The efficiency of Trans has improved a lot now.

墨素 2022-08-15

May I ask if the number of pages for resubmitting a rejected manuscript is less than 8 and a half pages or less than 9 and a half pages?

matl6514 2022-08-13

Submitted at the end of April, received reviewer comments in mid-June, and made major revisions. Surprisingly, there were six reviewers, but having many reviewers felt like a good thing. Given six weeks for revisions, I carefully addressed each point and submitted the first revision at the end of July. Two weeks later, received acceptance notification directly, completing the entire submission process in less than four months!

yfzhang 2022-08-06

May I ask what the current result is?

HIT涵 2022-07-29

The status changed to "awaiting AE Recommendation" on July 25th.

Gomendy 2022-07-27

Cover letter to the editor-in-chief, applying and explaining the reason for the addition. If reasonable, the editor will allow it.

唐牛才是食神 2022-07-26

Great submission experience. The first review took about three months, with waiting for the EIC's recommendation taking over a month. All five reviewers provided positive feedback and requested major revisions. After five weeks, the paper was resubmitted, and the second review took around two months, resulting in direct acceptance. By the way, I would like to mention that the EIC is very cautious. One of the reviewers suggested adding references, but the EIC directly deleted that comment in the review.

唐牛才是食神 2022-07-26

Don't be afraid. I stayed at EIC for 1 month and 12 days. At that time, EIC was called Shiyang. In the end, they gave me a major overhaul.

土豆的土豆 2022-07-25

The major revision added an author, does anyone know what to do?

zarathustr 2022-07-25

Laughing so hard, just a simple comment broke the defenses of so many people. Just to clarify, I was talking about the field of robotics, and it doesn't affect how you evaluate other areas. Thank you for your attention.

陌路无悔 2022-07-18

"Online within ten days."

陌路无悔 2022-07-18

"Online within ten days."

Zoomxxx 2022-07-18

How long until you can go online, big brother?

蜚声 2022-07-17

Can I use a first author's account to submit the manuscript, and then indicate that the corresponding author is the second author in the manuscript?

土豆的土豆 2022-07-14

Still waiting for EIC.

蜀山刀客 2022-07-12

What is the final result? I have been waiting for AE's recommendation for a week, and then waiting for EIC's decision for another week. Is it likely to be rejected?

蜀山刀客 2022-07-12

What is the final result? I have been waiting for a recommendation from AE for a week, and then waiting for EIC's decision for another week. I have no idea what's going on. Is it likely to be rejected?

Johnxuxu 2022-07-10

Robot direction, if you have the ability, just invest in TRO. No one is asking you to invest in TIE. One of the strongest publications in our instrument and meter direction is TIE.