yangJZ 2023-01-10

After resubmitting the rejection, it is now under review after 2 months.

雀巢咖啡 2023-01-03

The second review provided minor modifications. I wanted to ask if there will be an external review again.

snowspig 2022-12-20

I was rejected... 555.

wjdbcouwvc 2022-12-18

I finally received it.

snowspig 2022-12-17

The secretary said it was delayed. Then she went to urge them. But there was no change in status, still waiting for AE.

wjdbcouwvc 2022-12-15

I have been waiting for the second review for nearly two months. I sent a reminder to the ADM, and then he replied to my email, saying that it is now awaiting EIC decision. It has been 6 days since then, and I am feeling anxious.

snowspig 2022-12-15

I'm going to urge the secretary. Let's see if we can get a reply before Christmas. I don't know if it's a disaster or a major overhaul...
There probably won't be a one-time solution... hahaha

雀巢咖啡 2022-12-14

The first trial took 6 months, involving four experts, and the editor made extensive revisions. I would like to ask if the second trial will still take such a long time? Will there be an increase in the number of experts?

snowspig 2022-12-11

Still this... I reckon it will take two weeks.

运气王领了你的包 2022-12-10

Then how long did it take for the OP to get the results? Has the editor increased the reviewers?

运气王领了你的包 2022-12-09

What is the current status now?

snowspig 2022-12-07

On December 6th, awaiting AE recommendation.

蜗牛冒个泡 2022-12-06

I have accepted the paper now, and the proofreading information in the system will be marked according to the annotations in the article. My supervisor will fill in the information as the corresponding author, right? So, is my supervisor the corresponding author for the rest of the paper?

snowspig 2022-12-06

Today becomes: Awaiting AE Recommendation

pw 2022-12-06

2022.01.17: Submitted;
2022.04.03: Received first review, 5 reviewers, major revisions;
2022.05.25: Paper revisions completed, submitted;
2022.08.07: Received second review, 6 reviewers, major revisions;
2022.08.17: Paper revisions completed, submitted;
2022.10.07: Received acceptance notification, after 9 months of submission;
2022.10.27: Received Early Access notification.

蜗牛冒个泡 2022-12-06

Currently, I have submitted an article to TIE and it has been accepted. However, I submitted it using my own account and now when I am preparing to submit the final draft, I discovered that the communication author in the system is myself, but the actual communication author is my mentor. I have clearly stated in a footnote on the first page of the paper that the communication author is my mentor. I cannot find any option to modify the communication author in the system. I would like to ask for your help. How can I change the communication author in the system? Also, how is the communication author in TIE ultimately determined? I urgently need assistance.

rose inthe 2022-12-05

My submission was made on October 25th, displayed in the EIC office on November 2nd, under review on November 3rd, and is still under review now.

snowspig 2022-12-03

Ah. It's been 7 months already. What direction are you talking about? I saw an Iranian guy before, who received a review invitation and sent it out in just 3 months. Is it discrimination based on region? It's been a month and I'm wondering if I should ask about the review status. I don't know if it's good or not. Will it speed up the rejection process?

yangJZ 2022-12-03

Rejection and resubmission, it has been a month already, and it is still assigned to AE. Should I follow up on this situation?

这个注册过吗？ 2022-12-01

It has been three days, and it is still awaiting admin processing. Are there anyone in the same situation?

雀巢咖啡 2022-11-30

After waiting for more than six months, I received the first instance message, which called for major repairs.

xizeliu 2022-11-27

2022.2.31 submit.
2022.5.9 awaiting AE recommendation, awaiting EIC decision, major revision, 4 reviewers, not very critical issues, 1 reviewer gave negative feedback.
2022.6.19 resubmitted, and then under review.
2022.7.11 awaiting AE recommendation.
2022.7.27 awaiting EIC decision.
2022.7.28 major revision, 6 reviewers, 5 positive, 1 negative, 1 reviewer still gave negative feedback.
2022.8.18 resubmitted, and then under review.
2022.10.4 awaiting AE recommendation.
2022.10.27 awaiting EIC decision.
2022.10.28 Congratulations. This time there were no negative reviewers.
The overall review process was relatively fast. TIE emphasizes the completeness of the article, such as theoretical proofs, simulations, and experiments. The first review is important, as there is hope if major revisions are requested.

多中一点论文 2022-11-22

It took me a total of about seven months to be hired. The first round of review took about two to three months, and then it got faster. If it was fast, it would take a maximum of about four and a half months to be hired.

WHD-HIT 2022-11-20

May I ask if there are additional reviewers for the second review?

complex oos 2022-11-16

The reviewer of the tie journal is very professional and pointed out several professional issues in the paper, which greatly helped improve the quality of my paper. However, it was indeed difficult to make the changes. Fortunately, it was accepted. Attached is the review progress for everyone's reference:

2022.04.09 submit
2022.07.01 Editor-in-Chief evaluation, received review comments
2022.08.21 submit revised version (R1)
2022.08.29 under review
2022.09.05 awaiting Associate Editor recommendation
2022.10.10 sent email reminder
2022.10.11 under review
2022.10.21 assigned to Associate Editor
2022.10.23 under review
2022.10.25 minor revision
2022.10.27 submit revised version (R2)
2022.10.28 under review
2022.11.10 awaiting Associate Editor recommendation
2022.11.15 awaiting Editor-in-Chief decision
2022.11.16 accepted

snowspig 2022-11-14

CREATED 20-Oct-2022
SUBMITTED 31-Oct-2022
EIC:
ADM:
STATUS: Under Review

Has anyone passed? I haven't seen AE, is it still under review by EIC? I sent an email to ADM... Sigh, I'm an elderly doctoral student lacking a thesis to graduate... Anxious... When I just submitted it, ADM replied with an official email saying that the full peer review process in TIE may last anywhere from 3-4 months... 3-4 months for review... Looks like it's not looking good...

snowspig 2022-11-14

8. Only can say that everyone is very interested in your research direction... They are all willing to review for you.

snowspig 2022-11-14

Did you not have AE (Associate Editor) experience?
Mine also went under review on the day of submission. And I'm still waiting. I've only waited for two weeks...

snowspig 2022-11-14

Has "under review" already passed the EIC review? It went under review on the same day of submission... There is still no feedback information, I don't know which stage it is at...

snowspig 2022-11-14

No need, I submitted a little over 8 pages. I saw others submit a little over 8 pages with author information as well.