Geoffrey666 2023-08-03

My status has changed to "in peer review" today, so the review process should have started. I have to wait for at least another two months, it's agonizing!

Submitted on May 17, 2023, the status was: submitted.
Around June 21, 2023, the status changed to: in peer review.
Around July 2, 2023, the status changed to: submitted.
On August 3, 2023, the status changed to: in peer review.

yyyyyonex 2023-07-29

I submitted it in June, and during the process, a portion of the time was allocated to SAE. Afterwards, it went through peer review, and then it has been continuously submitted.

Geoffrey666 2023-07-28

Brother, when did you submit your work? My submission status has been for almost a month, and they still haven't started assigning reviewers to review it. Waiting for a response is really exhausting.

yyyyyonex 2023-07-25

May I ask how long it takes for the qualification review, also known as pre-screening, to enter the peer review process? I have already submitted quite a while ago.

Geoffrey666 2023-07-25

Okay, thank you! I would also like to ask further: Are tips not assigned to AE anymore? In my system, only SAEs are shown as assigned. So, should I approach SAEs or AEs to find reviewers?

Geoffrey666 2023-07-25

Has it appeared in peer review for the second time? It seems like the first time was a pre-review, and the second time is when the reviewers are assigned to review it.

汲 2023-07-19

I haven't received any reviews for about four to five months now. I should have contacted the editor earlier. Normally, if I haven't received any updates for two weeks, I would reach out to the editorial department. If it has been a month without any review and the editor hasn't responded, it's worth considering withdrawing.

ZKL123 2023-07-12

It should be all, equivalent to sending an email after the final decision of EIC.

binxingjingang 2023-07-12

Hello, thank you for your response. For major repairs or minor repairs, there is no need to await SAE decision approval. AE decision is sufficient. Only those that are rejected will have "awaiting SAE decision approval".

ZKL123 2023-07-10

It should be almost finalized, good luck!

zzz 2023-07-10

2023.5.23, Paper submitted
2023.7.10, In Peer Review

binxingjingang 2023-07-10

Have you ever encountered the status "awaiting sae decision approval"? Does it only appear when being rejected?

jinrushi 2023-07-05

Yes, other journals receive manuscripts and immediately have the editorial assistant check the formatting. Why is this journal different?

zhouzhen 2023-07-05

During this period, one month was spent in peer review, and then it changed to "submitted". Now, "submitted" has been ongoing for one month. Does this mean that it took one month to find reviewers?

zhouzhen 2023-07-05

"It has been two months since submission, and the status is still 'submitted.' Is this normal? Has anyone encountered a similar situation?"

RICARD 2023-07-05

The first time in peer review is more like a formatting review, not a formal review. After the formatting review is completed, it will go back to being "submitted," and then we will immediately find peer reviewers for the actual review process.

Geoffrey666 2023-07-04

Brother, hello! Is this journal first assigned to SAE and then to AE? I submitted it on May 17th, and it was assigned to SAE on June 20th, with the status "in peer review". Yesterday, the status changed back to "submitted", and I don't know what happened. I have previously submitted an article but didn't pay attention to tracking its status.

江枫晚 2023-07-03

Reviewed for 11 months and received a rejection, oh my, is this even a review process?

RICARD 2023-06-30

The road ahead is long and arduous, and I originally had no plans to pursue a Ph.D. I also have two backup papers that I can graduate with, so I can relax a bit.

清晨看露 2023-06-30

It's too difficult, brother...

RICARD 2023-06-29

2023.06.28 reject
Lasted a little over three months.

RICARD 2023-06-27

Additional Submission Experience:

Submitted on August 23, 2022
Rejected on May 10, 2023

RICARD 2023-06-27

Two submission experiences:

First submission:
March 3, 2022 - Submitted
November 28, 2022 - Rejected

Second submission:
March 20, 2023 - Submitted
March 23, 2023 - In peer review
April 20, 2023 - Submitted
April 25, 2023 - In peer review
June 26, 2023 - Awaiting AE decision
June 27, 2023 - Awaiting SAE decision

The first paper was not co-authored by an influential person, while the second paper had an influential co-author. The review process seemed much faster for the second submission. Even if it gets rejected, it's surprising how quickly it can be accepted. The first rejection after eight months was truly unexpected.

carl 2023-06-24

The text "2023-6-22 decision to accpet" is already in English. It indicates that a decision to accept something was made on June 22, 2023.

RICARD 2023-06-21

Last August, I applied and was rejected after a 10-month first trial. I'm fed up with it.

清晨看露 2023-06-20

2023.5.16 submit
2023.6.20 In Peer Review
2023.6.28 Submitted, waiting for AE assignment
2023.7.19 Urged for AE assignment, In Peer Review
2023.7.23 Immediate Reject - Presentation and Comprehension
They didn't like my writing and pointed out numerous grammar issues. I went through the process of polishing it, but they still didn't find it satisfactory. I can only say that TIP is not suitable for further submissions anymore. If they didn't like my writing, they should have told me right after the pre-review instead of making me wait so long. I won't be submitting to them again; their process is just too slow.

Exquisitee 2023-06-15

I have been waiting for a decision for over a month. I was busy with my graduation defense, so I didn't follow up. The decision came right after I finished the defense.

xiumian 2023-06-13

Pure novice, without a mentor, it seemed to have taken over a month to submit to peer review, and I don't know why it went back afterwards.

Geoffrey666 2023-06-04

Hello, brother. Can I ask if you have become a fellow already? That was quick.

清晨看露 2023-06-02

Okay, brother, how long did it take for your submission to pass peer review? I submitted mine almost 20 days ago and it is still in the "submit" stage.