zhgong007 2023-08-09

The estimated quality of the article is in a borderline state, so it can be accepted or rejected. However, IEEE TED is still relatively strict and generally requires positive opinions. Three months is indeed a bit too long, usually around one and a half months, not exceeding two months.

龙里 2023-06-08

I have been waiting for under 3 months, I'm really fed up, waiting for everything and getting nothing. Fux.

hdidbfuf 2023-06-06

I am here to update my situation and provide a reference for everyone. After being under review for 3 months, my submission was rejected. One reviewer gave positive feedback, stating that they found the work meaningful but suggested adding more details. However, the other reviewer believed that the article lacked significance and novelty. As a result, the editor decided to reject it. It is possible that my skills are not sufficient yet. Keep up the good work, everyone!

功夫熊猫xsh 2023-05-18

How did it go for the brothers upstairs in the end? It has been almost 2 months for me and it is still under review, there is no movement at all.

rourou554 2023-04-05

I have also been waiting for over 3 months, and it is still under review. I wrote a reminder letter, and they replied saying they haven't received the review comments.

zjl... 2023-03-21

First round of review took two months, and the result was major revision/reject and resubmit. It's strange that there was only one reviewer for the initial review.

rourou554 2023-03-19

I submitted it on January 3rd, but there is still no news now.

zjl... 2023-03-15

I submitted it on January 16th. It has been two months now and it is still under review. I wrote a reminder letter but haven't received any response.

rourou554 2023-03-13

Mine too, I will never submit to this journal again. It's too unreliable.

rourou554 2023-03-13

2023/1/3 Submitted
2023/3/13 Under review
The review process is too slow. Urgently need the article to be carefully considered for graduation.

hdidbfuf 2023-02-04

May I ask about the current status of your article? How long does it usually take to receive the reviewer's comments? I have been under review for almost three months and I am considering whether to send a reminder letter. Thank you!

hdidbfuf 2023-02-04

It has been three months under review, and it is still under review. I would like to ask the experienced authors who have submitted manuscripts, is this situation common? Should I send a reminder letter to inquire about it? I wish all friends who see this message have many papers. Thank you!

古月長照今人哀 2023-02-03

The above is self-recorded.

zjl... 2023-01-20

Hello, OP. Where can I view the schedule for the manuscript review status? I can only see the current status.

古月長照今人哀 2022-12-13

2022-06-22 Submitted
2022-06-22 Under review
2022-09-21 Awaiting ED preliminary decision
2022-09-23 Major Revision/Reject and Resubmit
2022-10-05 Resubmitted
2022-10-06 Under review
2022-10-10 Awaiting decision approval
2022-10-12 Accepted as is (12-Oct-2022)

rourou554 2022-12-09

Excuse me, does transferring to TED require increasing the number of pages in the article and restoring the pages that were previously deleted due to EDL submission?

smw6201 2022-12-05

14-Aug-2022 Submitted
12-Sep-2022 Major Revision /Reject and Resubmit
12-Oct-2022 Submitted
27-Oct-2022 Major Revision /Reject and Resubmit
29-Oct-2022 Submitted
30-Nov-2022 Accept As Is

Translation:
14-Aug-2022 Submitted
12-Sep-2022 Major Revision /Reject and Resubmit
12-Oct-2022 Submitted
27-Oct-2022 Major Revision /Reject and Resubmit
29-Oct-2022 Submitted
30-Nov-2022 Accept As Is

scyuken 2022-11-23

2022-11-19 Una revisión ha sido enviada
2022-11-22 Aceptar tal cual

scyuken 2022-11-14

2022-11-5 Awaiting decision approval
2022-11-12 Accept with Minor Revisions

Translation:
2022-11-5 Esperando la aprobación de la decisión
2022-11-12 Aceptar con revisiones menores

scyuken 2022-10-19

May I ask the original poster, what will be the subsequent status after the initial submission is continuously "Under Review"? Thank you!

siva 2022-10-18

05-Aug-2022 SUBMITTED
01-Sep-2022 Major Revision /Reject and Resubmit
07-Sep-2022 a resubmission has been submitted
28-Sep-2022 Accept As Is

Translation:
05-Aug-2022 SUBMITTED
01-Sep-2022 Major Revision /Reject and Resubmit
07-Sep-2022 a resubmission has been submitted
28-Sep-2022 Accept As Is

scyuken 2022-10-14

2022-09-25 submitted
2022-09-29 under review

平平淡淡 2022-09-12

2022-06-06 SUBMITTED
2022-07-16 Accept Conditionally with Mandatory Revisions
2022-08-05 A revision has been resubmitted
2022-08-19 Accept with Minor Revisions
2022-08-20 A revision has been resubmitted
2022-08-21 Accept As Is

Translation:
2022-06-06 SUBMITTED
2022-07-16 Accept Conditionally with Mandatory Revisions
2022-08-05 A revision has been resubmitted
2022-08-19 Accept with Minor Revisions
2022-08-20 A revision has been resubmitted
2022-08-21 Accept As Is

南天一壶酒 2022-07-31

2022-04-29 Submitted
2022-05-01 Under Review
2022-05-30 Awaiting ED Preliminary Decision
2022-06-06 Awaiting Decision Approval
2022-06-07 Accept Conditionally with Mandatory Revisions
2022-06-26 Submitted/Under Review
2022-07-07 Awaiting ED Preliminary Decision
2022-07-13 Awaiting Decision Approval
2022-07-14 Accept Conditionally with Mandatory Revisions
2022-07-17 Submitted/Under Review
2022-07-20 Awaiting Decision Approval
2022-07-21 Accept As Is

chocolateabs 2022-07-22

It has been almost 7 months under review, and the editor has not replied to my email. Why is it taking so long?

syj20094870 2022-07-13

Congratulations, Ted can generally no longer modify the author unless it is forcibly modified, and you are close to getting it. The editor will give it back to you and ask you to provide a supplementary explanation.

syj20094870 2022-07-13

The editor will send it back to you, asking you to provide some additional explanations.
Congratulations, usually TED only prohibits author modifications after mandatory revisions, you are close to being accepted.

oceanss 2022-07-07

The second version that I submitted has been modified. I added an author in the article. When submitting to the journal, the author field is locked and cannot be modified. How can I handle this? I clicked on submit.

nothing 2022-07-01

Submit two weeks to return the review comments, directly accept after modification, fast speed, professional review comments, a very good submission experience!

peter.24 2022-06-16

Mine too, it has been three months and it is still under review, without any news at all! What's going on? Did any of your friends experience the same thing before?