keyanzhazha 2022-09-14

This journal is now useless. Even after two months of minor repairs, there are still no results. The beard has turned white from waiting.

心之所往 2022-09-06

It is indeed very slow. It has been a month and a half in peer review, too sluggish.

fuceek 2022-08-30

Not very clear, I only started paying attention ten days ago, so I am not aware of any changes prior to that.

AGAL 2022-08-30

May I ask how long the Peer Review process takes on your end?

MrJiJie 2022-08-28

It's really too slow. I submitted it on June 10th, and it's still "awaiting recommendation" now. Regardless of whether the outcome is good or bad, I won't submit it again in the future. I have already prepared myself for not receiving feedback for three months. Based on the comments, it seems I should be prepared for four months. Sigh.

开拓者517 2022-08-24

I have also been waiting for four months, but no result yet. The process is extremely slow this year. Last year, the first instance result was given in a maximum of one and a half months.

keyanzhazha 2022-08-19

The processing speed of this journal is uneven, it feels like a matter of luck. Some editors are more responsible and work faster, while others who are not responsible work slower.

kuailexingqiu123 2022-08-19

Second review Awaiting Recommendation has been a month already. Should we remind them, can experienced brothers share some advice?

LK 2022-08-19

It has been almost four months, and the first trial has not come out yet. So slow!

keyanzhazha 2022-08-18

I'm still in the peer review process after a month of minor revisions. So frustrating.

w_sl 2022-08-18

4.25 - One submission
6.13 - Resubmission after modification
7.03 - Resubmission of revised manuscript
8.02 - Minor revision
8.07 - Feedback on minor revision
8.16 - Accepted

yyyccchhh 2022-08-08

Hello, I would like to ask if after your paper is accepted, does IEEE require you to provide simulation code?

yyyccchhh 2022-08-08

Hello, I would like to ask, after your paper is accepted, does IEEE require you to improve the simulation code?

心之所往 2022-08-04

May I ask how long does it usually take for the first round of review for this journal? And how long does the peer review process typically last?

RR w 2022-07-30

It is indeed slow, taking four months for the initial review. In early May, I sent an email to ADM for inquiry, but there was no response. I was considering withdrawing the submission. Overall, the submission experience has been mediocre.

2022.1.26 submitted
2022.1.27 in peer review
2022.5.24 awaiting recommendations
2022.6.06 rejected and invited to resubmit

2022.6.17 resubmitted
2022.6.20 in peer review
2022.7.22 awaiting recommendations
2022.7.25 awaiting decision
2022.7.30 accepted

心之所往 2022-07-20

Recent big shots who have submitted, please share your experiences. How long does it take for this journal to accept a submission from the time of submission? Approximately how long is the first review process for the journal? Recently, I submitted a paper on July 16, 2022, and it entered peer review on July 18, 2022.

爱你喔 2022-07-20

This journal seems unsuitable for submitting again. The speed has been extremely slow this year. The problem is that the majority of the Associate Editors (AEs) in this journal are Chinese. Some Chinese AEs have a biased mindset and do not give fair evaluations to Chinese researchers. Some people in China tend to engage in internal conflicts and do not want others to succeed.

AGAL 2022-07-20

Hello, may I ask which direction you have invested in? It has been quite a while since I heard any news as well, and I am worried that it might be rejected due to not meeting the theme. So, I wanted to ask.

keyanzhazha 2022-07-14

The first trial was quite fast, only taking 35 days, but the editing efficiency is a bit low.

爱你喔 2022-07-14

May I ask how long does it take for your first trial? I previously submitted one as well, and it has been in AE RE status for one month. Then I sent an email to urge it, and the editor replied to the email.

keyanzhazha 2022-07-13

The speed is indeed slow, it took me a long time to finish the first review, and it has been almost a month awaiting recommendation.

giggsht 2022-07-07

There are four reviewers, and after the revisions, there is still a second round of review, which usually takes about three weeks.

Ron wealsay1 2022-07-07

May I ask how many reviewers there are? Both of my reviewers recommended publication after minor revisions. After resubmission, it has been in the "in peer review" status for over 20 days. Is there a second round of review?

Ron wealsay1 2022-07-07

May I ask how many reviewers are there? Both of my reviewers recommended publication after minor revisions. After resubmitting, it has been in the "in peer review" status for over 20 days. Is there a second round of review?

giggsht 2022-07-07

Compared to last year, it is one month slower.

yyyccchhh 2022-06-30

Is this journal now always asking for revisions as long as the reviewers don't reject it? There are two reviewers, one of them has no issues, but the other one always asks some tricky questions. It's only a 5-page layout, but every time he wants to add a bunch of things. Then they added another reviewer, who only raised some minor issues. Another round of minor revisions, it's really giving me a headache.

Ron wealsey 2022-06-28

My June 16th minor revision has been resubmitted, and it is still under review. Is there a second review?

giggsht 2022-06-22

I submitted an article last year, and it was accepted within 5 days after minor revisions. Sigh.

爱你喔 2022-06-21

It takes Xiaoxiu two weeks to submit the manuscript to the editor for review, plus the time for the review process, which generally takes 14-20 days or more.

giggsht 2022-06-21

Xiao Xiu has been waiting for more than 10 days, and it is still "In Peer Review" until now. It has indeed been slow this year.