zhang123abc 2021-04-11

Waiting for AE Decision, feeling a bit nervous.

zhang123abc 2021-04-01

Did you receive the comments on the manuscript review?

Duanzheng Guan 2021-03-25

Submitted on 3.18
Editing and preliminary review will be assigned on 3.21
The preliminary review did not pass on 3.25
The reason for rejection is that the experiment is too simple, lacks completeness, and has insufficient description of the experiment.

heltahu 2021-03-16

Similarly, received a decision, two aq, one r, AE finally gave r. This allows for a chance of resubmission.

朋澄Young 2021-03-16

Received the Decision in the early morning, two AQs, one R, and finally received an R.

May I ask you, experts, if this journal differentiates between RQ and R?

ulaaa 2021-03-16

Now there is a contact journal below, it should have found reviewers after 4 months, you can wait again, the editor's speed is still very fast.

飞天镜 2021-03-08

Can I ask if "contact journal" was displayed under "in peer review" at that time? It has been almost four months since I submitted my paper, and it has been in peer review all this time. A few days ago, a clickable "contact journal" appeared below. I clicked on it, thinking that I could send an email to the journal. However, after "Dear," it showed "(person not available)" twice. Could it be that they haven't found a reviewer yet? Have you ever encountered this before?

朋澄Young 2021-03-08

Excuse me, everyone. I would like to ask, is it considered slow for a manuscript to still be in peer review from mid-January until now?

I am unsure of the appropriate time to ask the Associate Editor about this.

ulaaa 2021-03-08

12.22 Submission
2.17 Accept minor revisions
3.1 Submit after minor revisions
3.8 Accept
Overall speed is relatively fast.

飞天镜 2021-03-04

After submitting in mid-November 2020, there has been no news. Yesterday, I received an email in the submission system:

Dear (Person not available) (Person not available):
The content is empty.
Has anyone encountered this before? Does it mean they couldn't find a reviewer? Do I need to respond afterwards?

zhongshaoyy 2021-01-27

The AE has not been changed. It is mentioned in the email that the manuscript has been rejected and can be resubmitted, but the AE will not be changed unless there are special circumstances. Whether or not the reviewers are changed depends on the AE. I cannot see who the reviewers are, but based on the review comments, one reviewer was changed for the second review, while the other one remained the same. Regardless of whether the reviewers are changed or not, it is important to respond seriously to their comments.

躺一会太阳花 2021-01-25

Will submitting articles on data mining and software engineering be rejected?

pepper-paper 2021-01-24

Did AE and reviewers change after you resubmitted?

pepper-paper 2021-01-23

Translate the following text into English: "Two minor revisions, one rejection, requesting resubmission. Will the AE and reviewers change after resubmission? Will the review process be faster than the first round?"

zhongshaoyy 2021-01-20

10.3 Submission
11.17 Rejection, AE encourages resubmission
12.07 Resubmission after revision
01.07 Minor revisions accepted (AQ)
01.19 Submitted after minor revisions
01.20 Accepted (A)
Overall, the difficulty level is moderate, and innovation is highly valued. Although the article is only four pages long, the reviewers still have certain requirements for experimental completeness, and the experiments were supplemented in both revisions.