lgxt 2021-09-09

August 12th, good submission.
August 13th, for review.
Currently, the outcome is unknown, anxiously waiting.

zfw 2021-08-25

I would like to ask, how long did it take for you to receive a rejection after your first submission?

wlz 2021-08-25

Hello! May I ask how long it takes to get the results of the preliminary screening?

pppeeeyyy 2021-08-24

CV field.
Quite fast, one reviewer's opinion is very nice, one is very stupid, and the AC is very nice. Good journals in the letters.

老鼠扛刀 2021-08-06

Why hasn't my manuscript been published as fast as expected? It has been almost two months, and I haven't received any feedback from the first review!

老鼠扛刀 2021-08-04

Why is it taking so long for my submission to be in your status? Isn't it a bit abnormal? Mine has been in Peer Review all along! Isn't it supposed to be fast? Why is it different from the comments?!!!!

Xiao-Dong BI 2021-07-26

Submitted nearly two months ago, consistently displaying "Awaiting AE Decision."

Xiao-Dong BI 2021-07-26

After submission, it has already been two months.

DLY_FF 2021-07-21

Second resubmission, explain the reasons for the second resubmission in the cover letter.

NLP_firer 2021-07-20

Hello, I have been rejected twice, but I also received a request to resubmit the second time. Does this count as encouragement to resubmit? Because the email also stated that in principle, submissions that have been rejected twice cannot be submitted again. Thank you.

duters 2021-07-08

This journal is very nice in terms of speed, and the reviewers are professional. The suggestions they made have greatly helped improve the quality of the manuscript. This journal has a good impact and has received unanimous praise from the industry. It is fortunate to have this journal accepted. We hope to continue to work hard and strive for further improvement.

Yeluo 2021-07-02

2021.4.8 Submission
2021.4.19 Direct rejection, the reason was absurd, but another editor encouraged resubmission with additional experiments.
2021.5.10 Resubmitted with additional experiments, assigned AE for review the next day.
2021.6.15 Two AEs and one R, AE gave Accept with Mandatory Revisions.
2021.6.28 Revised.
2021.7.1 Accept.

The process was still fast, but I still find the reason for the direct rejection by the first editor absurd. Although the second time was a minor revision, I still added experiments.

heltahu 2021-07-01

2021.2.5 Submission,
2021.3.12 Rejected, 3 reviewers, 2 AQs, 1 R from AE;
2021.4.21 Resubmitted revised manuscript,
2021.6.13, 3 reviewers, 1 A, 2 AQs, Accept with Mandatory Revisions from AE,
2021.6.24 Resubmitted minor revisions,
2021.6.30 Accepted by AE.

CV路上一名研究僧 2021-06-25

Posted on April 28, 2021
Received first review comments on May 31, 2021, affirming the innovation and writing of the paper, providing AQ.
Returned for revision on June 8, 2021.
Accepted on June 10, 2021.
The paper has a core idea, good experimental results, and a high probability of acceptance due to good writing.

Tju_Fluffy 2021-06-18

Post on April 26, 2021
Received first-round review results on May 31, very positive about the innovation of this article, given an AQ.
Returned for revision on June 12, 2021.
Accepted on June 17, 2021.
The process was very fast, the reviewer's comments were very professional, and I am very satisfied.

yayayayaya 2021-06-17

2021.6.16 Accept with Mandatory Revisions

Translated to English: On June 16, 2021, the acceptance is granted with obligatory revisions.

Wasen 2021-06-11

Hello, may I ask if you eventually resubmitted? The statements in the emails I recently received here are the same as yours - first rejection, then they mentioned the requirements for resubmission.

yayayayaya 2021-06-10

I haven't received the result yet, let's wait a little longer. I am also waiting for the AE decision on the 27th.

lyra 2021-06-05

Submitted in December last year, the first review was returned on February 23rd and rejected for resubmission. Resubmitted on April 3rd and assigned to the original Associate Editor. Minor revisions were due within two weeks on May 23rd, and after revisions were made, it was accepted on June 5th. The article requires high language proficiency, innovation, and a comprehensive description. The AE is very responsible, and the reviewers' opinions are professional, so a careful response is needed. The review process for both the first and second reviews took about two months, which is a little slow. Best wishes.

NULLE 2021-06-03

Hello classmate, may I ask how long it took for you to receive the decision from "Awaiting AE Decision" status to receiving the decision from AE?

NULLE 2021-06-03

Last month, around the 27th, the status changed to "Awaiting AE Decision", but there has been no result so far. May I ask if this process speed is normal? Should I send an email to AE for inquiry?

NULLE 2021-06-03

Classmate, my timeline is similar to yours. It also changed to "Awaiting AE Decision" around May 27th, but I still haven't received any results. Have you received the AE notification?

yayayayaya 2021-05-27

2021.5.27Awaiting AE Decision

Translation: Awaiting AE Decision on May 27, 2021.

stonelc 2021-05-25

2021.1.15 Submission
2021.2.17 Reject, but allowed to resubmit
2021.4.30 Resubmission
2021.5.12 Accept with Mandatory Revisions (AQ)
2021.5.21 Submission after modification
2021.5.24 Accept

The review efficiency is very high, with 2 reviews. There was a misunderstanding in between, and after the second resubmission, it was accepted within two days. However, two days later, the decision was rescinded, and the acceptance was revoked. Later, it was found out that it was a mistake made by the editor, as the second submission was not sent for review. After that, the status changed to peer review, and it was the same as mentioned above.

Overall, the speed is really fast, and the language requirements are quite high.

ds0529 2021-05-18

2021.3.22 submitted
2021.5.2 AQ
2021.5.16 received
It was accepted in less than two months, very efficient.

YANKE 2021-05-14

First submission at the end of November 2020, retraction and resubmission in January 2021. Re-submission on February 22, 2021, accepted with minor revisions on March 14. Accepted after modifications on April 3.
The review process was fast, and there were high language and innovation requirements.

Hellen99 2021-05-07

Have you received the reviewer's comments? I have been in peer review for over two months after submitting my manuscript.

yayayayaya 2021-05-03

Posted on April 27, 2021
Edited and pre-reviewed on May 3, 2021
Currently in Peer Review
Ah, I hope it gets accepted!!!

wangjiaoshou1990 2021-04-21

Resubmission of Previously Rejected Manuscripts:

FengYYJJ 2021-04-16

May I ask what is the description for encouraging resubmission? I only rejected it but I am not sure if a resubmission is needed.