Elzhach 2023-04-26

2023-04-19 Submission
2023-04-22 Assign Senior Area Editor
2023-05-19 Reminder (for submission)
2023-05-31 Second Reminder (for submission)
2023-05-31 Assign Associate Editor

Jurgn 2023-04-24

April 24th, submission.

ningx 2023-04-11

Hello, boss. How come this journal only requires 4 pages? Is it an OA (open access) journal? I see it's written as non-OA, and it belongs to the second tier. It's strange that the page requirement is only 4 pages. Could it be a low-quality journal?

小超超~ 2023-04-06

I submitted it on March 30th, and on April 5th, I received a Manuscript schedule for pre-screening. It seems to be indicating a preliminary screening process, and if it gets approved after a week, an AE will be assigned.

Joie 2023-04-02

Posted on March 29th, until now still not assigned AE, sob sob sob, hope it will be assigned soon.

朋澄Young 2023-03-28

Waiting for good news from you, wishing you success!

chx. 2023-03-28

I am similar to you in basic terms, but I also have a third reviewer who suggested that I resubmit. So, I resubmitted, but now the outcome is unknown, and it's possible that it will still be rejected. The first reviewer also started criticizing me right from the beginning...

yurii 2023-03-27

2023.3.27 Awaiting AE Decision

This text translates to: "2023.3.27 Awaiting AE Decision"

朋澄Young 2023-03-27

2022.11.03 Under Review
2023.03.26 Reject (1 AQ, 1R) It took nearly 5 months...

The first reviewer said it was done well and had only 2 comments, but the second reviewer said the language was poor and there was no innovation in the model or algorithm.

I would like to ask for advice from all the experts, what should I do in this situation? Is it necessary to revise and resubmit?

yurii 2023-03-20

2023.2.17 Submission
2023.3.20 In peer review

redmery 2023-03-17

It shouldn't happen, but if necessary, the editor should notify you for revisions.

kksiz 2023-03-15

I made a few errors in the reference format when submitting. There is also a punctuation mistake. Will the editor reject it directly, or should I resubmit it?

hhhhhhhhhge 2023-03-03

Why do you have two editors?

Whatsyourname 2023-02-24

Please share the process and insights after Reject-Resubmission, bosses.

hrbeuer 2023-02-19

January 31st, ACCEPT WITH MANDATORY MINOR REVISIONS. After making minor revisions, it has been 12 days and I'm eagerly waiting for the AE's decision. What's going on? I'm anxious. ?

chengyan 2023-02-17

Can it be resubmitted after an EIC Immediate Reject?

chengyan 2023-02-17

Can it be resubmitted after EIC Immediate Reject?

chengyan 2023-02-17

Can it be resubmitted after an EIC Immediate Reject?

heltahu 2023-02-15

Q: Hello, may I ask if I need to write a reply letter after making revisions based on your second round of review? Can I just submit the modified paper, or do I need to attach a response to the reviewer letter like in the previous first round?

A: You still need to follow the same process as the first round and attach a response to the reviewer letter. Although the response may not be shown to the reviewer again, it is still necessary to answer the reviewer's questions seriously, as the Associate Editor will determine the final outcome based on this.

nanshouaxiongdi 2023-02-13

Hello, may I ask if I need to write a response letter after making revisions based on your second round of review and giving AQ? Should I simply submit the modified paper, or do I need to attach a response letter to the reviewer like in the previous first round?

heltahu 2023-02-07

22-10-7, submitted,
22-11-18, rejected (1 aq, 1 r),
22-12-16, re-submitted,
23-1-23, accepted with mandatory revisions,
23-1-27, submit the revision,
23-2-6, accepted.

Translation:

22nd October 7th, submitted,
22nd November 18th, rejected (1 aq, 1 r),
22nd December 16th, re-submitted,
23rd January 23rd, accepted with mandatory revisions,
23rd January 27th, submit the revision,
23rd February 6th, accepted.

nomore 2023-01-18

2023-1-18 Submission

chen 2023-01-02

Submission experience:
2022.11.29 Submission
2022.12.01 Notification for format modification
2022.12.07 Assigned to The Senior Area Editor
2022.12.19 Assigned AE
2023.01.29 Awaiting AE Decision
2023.02.03 Reject, two reviewers, one R, one AQ
2023.03.20 Resubmission
2023.03.21 In Peer Review

heltahu 2022-12-16

22-11-18, rejected (1 aq, 1 r)
22-12-16, re-submitted, unknown outcome

fsdfgrszf 2022-12-14

It seems like my results were stuck until I received comments on the article I submitted, which eventually led to the results of my paper.

fsdfgrszf 2022-12-14

2022.9.29 Submission
10.4 Assignment of AE
11.15 Received an invitation email from the same AE for review. Accepted on the same day. Review deadline is 12.7.
11.29 Sent a reminder letter for the submission after two months. AE mentioned that the result will be informed by 12.5, but no result was given until 12.7.
12.8 Received a reminder letter for my review. Submitted my review comments on the same day.
12.9 Received a rejection letter.

OceanYu 2022-12-07

What direction did you vote for? I also voted on the 4th, but AE has not been assigned yet.

zhy889 2022-12-07

Do you need to self-cite in a reference paper?

zhy889 2022-12-06

Take a look at the review efficiency.
Submission: 04-Dec-2022
Status: AE - Not Assigned

青木123 2022-12-05

16-Nov-2022 Submitted
28-Nov-2022 Assigned AE
28-Nov-2022 - In Peer Review