有风度有态度 2023-06-01

Submitted for 2 months, without any review comments, both websites have been stuck at "select reviewer" and "under review" respectively, and finally got rejected. The reason given was that the content does not meet the journal's requirements.

fs77yy 2023-05-28

I am too. I have been submitting for almost 3 months. The status of scholarone manuscripts changed from "Select Reviewers" to "Assign Reviewers". I don't know what the situation is.

有风度有态度 2023-05-08

2 websites, the official website shows "Under Review" for over a month, and the ScholarOne Manuscripts website shows "Select Reviewers" for over a month. Is it undergoing external review? I don't know what the situation is.

opticSu 2023-01-03

I submitted a topic before September 30, 2022, and received feedback in 20 days. After modifying it for a week, it was accepted on the same day by the editor. This magazine is pretty good, and I will submit to it whenever I have a suitable topic.

冲冲冲冲 2022-01-27

Congratulations! I submitted it in mid-August and it is still under external review. It is really super slow, like a snail.

townportal 2022-01-25

5.30 Submission
11.16 Major revision, took nearly 6 months, too slow, completely unable to compete with the current wave of OA journals. There's no choice, this is already the highest ranked and most influential journal in our field.
12.2 Revision
1.2 Second round of major revision, but the feedback has decreased significantly.
1.8 Revision
1.13 Acceptance

Peter！ 2021-11-06

The journal should be good, just too slow. Accepted after major revision.
5.23 Paper submission
6.2 Select reviewers
6.19 Assign reviewers
6.26 Select reviewers
7.6 Assign reviewers
7.7 Awaiting reviewers scores
10.5 Awaiting GE decision
10.7 Major revision
10.19 Manuscript returned
10.20 Awaiting reviewers scores
10.29 Accepted