CaitliaChen 2023-07-07

With the help of collaborators in the early stage, we spent half a year revising it. After one month of submission and minor revisions, it was directly accepted.

CYCLONEON 2023-07-01

January 4th submission
February 16th: Reject and Resubmit, given two months. Three reviewers: one said the methods were unclear, one said the results analysis needed to be supplemented, and the last one gave positive feedback and provided additional analysis suggestions.
April 17th resubmission: added a lot of analysis and content
June 5th: Minor revisions
June 30th: Revisions returned, accepted directly

Hope this helps everyone.

acel 2023-05-09

Sharing the submission process:
Submitted for review for half a month
Reviewed for 2 months
Minor revisions, sent back after half a month
Accepted in three days

goodlea 2023-03-01

I submitted my work the day before Christmas, it was reviewed 17 days later, and then I received feedback 33 days later. They rejected my submission and gave me two months to resubmit. I'm not sure if this is considered a major revision, but is the chance of acceptance high?

passion_43 2023-02-28

This journal may really be unfriendly towards Chinese people. My paper was under review for 2 months, and in the end, the editorial department rejected it claiming that they couldn't find any reviewers. During the process, they even contacted us to add reviewers, but it was just insincere.

zhuyinong 2023-02-25

Two weeks later for review.

zhuyinong 2023-02-21

I have also been 12 days, may I ask what is your current condition?

zhuyinong 2023-02-15

Already rejected.

On February 10th, 2023, another article was submitted and is currently undergoing initial checking.

zhuyinong 2023-02-15

How is the manuscript now?

passion_43 2023-01-04

The status of the submission after 17 years has been updated to "Under Review."

passion_43 2022-12-29

One week before Christmas, I submitted the application, and now half a month has passed, but it is still undergoing initial checking. It is much slower than expected, and I wonder if it is because of Christmas.

zhuyinong 2022-12-16

Submitted on December 14, 2022, rejected by NEE and NC, hoping GCB can review.

积极努力-科研顺利 2022-11-10

Just submitted
This manuscript has gone through a lot, hoping GCB can review it, send it back for revisions, or accept it. Please bless me!

Jhonny Zuo 2022-10-31

May I ask if "Under review" means that the paper has been sent for review directly, or could it also mean that the editor is still conducting a preliminary evaluation?

Leon 2022-10-13

Submitted in late May.
Received reviewer comments in early August, with one recommending major revisions and the other recommending minor revisions. The editor ultimately opted for major revisions (45 days).
Revised and resubmitted in September.
Accepted directly in early October.

The current policy of the journal does not allow for a second round of major revisions; otherwise, the paper will be rejected outright.

KXE 2022-04-21

What is the current status?

Dogontheleft 2022-04-09

If I don't ask for a resubmission, it seems like I won't be given another chance. I also submitted my work for review and was rejected. I sent an email asking if I could resubmit, but I was still rejected.

kjmg 2022-04-02

How should I write a letter for resubmission after rejection? There was no invitation to resubmit in my email, so can I submit it again after making the necessary revisions based on the feedback?

jqj713 2022-01-23

May I ask how many days does the "Undergoing initial checking" status usually last for everyone? It has been 12 days for me and there has been no change. Previously, my submission was rejected within 5 days.

Dogontheleft 2022-01-19

May I ask if your "Under Review" status has been assigned an editor? Does the "Under Review" stage of this journal include both editorial review and external review?

YancyPKU 2021-11-03

Posted on July 1st, feedback received on August 16th, rejected and asked to resubmit. Revised on October 13th, accepted on November 1st.

机械师 2021-08-18

Excuse me, do I need to pay a page fee for this journal?

ww-geo 2021-03-03

Hello, how long have you been in this state? Is it possible that it has been a long time and you might be rejected?

xuangood 2021-02-18

May I ask how long this state will last, OP?
In this state, does it include scientific review in addition to formatting review?
THX