hehe2333323 2023-08-09

The opinions of the two reviewers have come back. One suggests minor revisions, while the other suggests moderate revisions. The editor rejected the manuscript directly as it did not meet the journal's scope.

辣条哥 2023-08-08

Nick, have you finished reviewing it? How many reviewers have responded with their comments?

Nick 2023-08-03

Original: 楼主，你的审完了吗？
Translation: OP, have you finished reviewing?

正在烤红薯 2023-07-26

How many reviewers have been assigned? I can only see "under review".

hehe2333323 2023-07-11

2023-7-11 Display a reviewer's feedback.

辣条哥 2023-07-05

My document was submitted for review the day before yesterday.

辣条哥 2023-07-03

Have you submitted it for review, Nick?

Nick 2023-06-30

It is quite slow. My work has been with the editor for half a month already.

辣条哥 2023-06-29

I have also been with the editor for two consecutive days, trying to ride on the wave of the host's good fortune, hoping to also be reviewed!

Wangxinyi 2023-06-29

Doctor, it seems like I made a mistake, who is Teacher Feng referring to?

辣条哥 2023-06-27

This magazine is really slow.

hehe2333323 2023-06-24

After submission, the corresponding author will receive a link in their email containing all the submission information.

夏天 2023-06-24

May I ask, how do you see the number of invited reviewers and the status of accepted reviews, sir?

hehe2333323 2023-06-19

2023-06-14: Invitation to review sent to 3 people, but no one accepted the review.
2023-06-18: Invitation to review sent to 4 people, invited an additional person.
2023-06-19: Invitation to review accepted by 2 people.

hehe2333323 2023-06-19

2023-06-14: Invitation to review sent to 3 people, but no one accepted the review.

2023-06-18: Invitation to review sent to 4 people, invited one more.

2023-06-19: 2 reviewers accepted the review invitation.

hehe2333323 2023-06-18

There are currently no three reviewers invited and no review acceptance yet.

辣条哥 2023-06-18

Excuse me, sir, have you received experts for review now?

辣条哥 2023-06-18

Geoderma is so slow, it's been half a month and still no one has accepted the review.

hehe2333323 2023-06-14

Unknown result. Just sharing the status and communicating with everyone.
2023-6-8 Suggested transfer to a different journal (Personally, I think such a transfer is meaningless and does not increase the chances of acceptance, it's just for convenience).
2023-6-9 Requested revisions, revised that evening.
2023-6-10 With editor.
2023-6-11 With editor.
2023-6-13 With editor (The "with editor" status changed many times in between, and we don't know why).
2023-6-13 Under review.

辣条哥 2023-06-12

Is AFM not related to forestry? Does it also accept articles on models?

dragonlord 2023-06-10

If we talk about soil science, geoderma is better, and for models, AMF is better.

辣条哥 2023-06-10

Excuse me, which one of these magazines, AGRICULTURAL AND FOREST METEOROLOGY or this one, has higher recognition among experts?

白色纪念 2023-05-28

First time voting, I was also not very clear about the differences. My feeling was that it went quite fast, and after the intermediate revision, it was directly accepted. I thought there would still be another round of review.

辣条哥 2023-05-26

If I'm not mistaken, the "big shot" should be from Professor Feng's group. May I ask if the "big shot" is a master's student, a doctoral student, or a postdoctoral fellow?

辣条哥 2023-05-12

Excuse me, boss, what will be different about OA in the future?

白色纪念 2023-05-09

2023.01.09 Submitted to Journal
2023.01.12 Resubmit
2023.01.13 With editor
2023.01.27 Under review
2023.03.03 Required Reviews Complete
2023.03.13 Required Reviews Complete
2023.03.25 Moderate Revision
2023.05.05 Resubmit
2023.05.08 Accepted

Translated:
2023.01.09 Submitted to Journal
2023.01.12 Resubmit
2023.01.13 With editor
2023.01.27 Under review
2023.03.03 Required Reviews Complete
2023.03.13 Required Reviews Complete
2023.03.25 Moderate Revision
2023.05.05 Resubmit
2023.05.08 Accepted

混子G 2023-04-16

Why isn't anyone commenting? Is it because it's an OA and there are fewer people participating?

Wangxinyi 2023-03-27

Gave Xiao Xiu some advice, and now he is working hard to make the necessary repairs.

Wangxinyi 2023-03-24

Rejection and Resubmission with Editorial Suggestions

sy2022 2023-03-24

Hello, may I ask if resubmitting after rejection is something that the journal suggests you to do? Or is it only a rejection notice and then you can choose to resubmit on your own?