Verified Reviews - GENE
Note: Verified reviews are sourced from across review platforms and social media globally.

JCK 2023-07-27

You can choose not to pay for the layout fee.

懒洋洋2 2023-07-25

May I ask if there is a page fee for the article you submitted?

JCK 2023-07-06

After more than three months of experience, acceptance. This old magazine, if not in a hurry, you can try submitting and hope to be promoted in the future.

黄旭熙的圈外女友 2023-06-02

How to write a cover letter?

gggggggyyyyyyy 2023-05-17

2023-2-24 Submission
2023-2-25 With Editor
2023-3-13 Reviewer invited
2023-3-13 Under Review
2023-3-25 Required Reviews Completed
2023-4-1 Decision in Process
2023-4-3 Revise (Extensive modifications)
2023-4-9 Submitted
2023-4-9 With Editor
2023-4-27 Under Review
2023-4-30 Required Reviews Completed
2023-5-3 Decision in Process
2023-5-10 Accept

From submission to receiving reviewer comments took about a month, which was very fast. A total of 4 reviewers provided feedback, all of which were fairly positive and constructive. Their suggestions greatly helped improve the quality of the manuscript. After revisions were made, the editor promptly sent it for review. The review process concluded with acceptance of the manuscript.

gggggggyyyyyyy 2023-04-01

Excuse me, how many days does the "Required Reviews Completed" status usually last before getting results? It has been one week for me with this status, and there was one update in between.

商先生 2023-03-14

When will the manuscript be published?

gggggggyyyyyyy 2023-03-14

After waiting for more than ten days, it finally went under review. Wish myself good luck!

gggggggyyyyyyy 2023-03-01

2023-2-24 Submission
2023-2-25 With Editor
2023-2-27 With Editor
2023-2-28 With Editor
No change in status, is it a date change without rejection?

JUST 2022-09-28

8.25 submitted 8.27 editor invited
9.1-9.13 under review
9.14-9.18 editor invited
9.19-9.26 under review
9.27 received email: complete reject
The editor invited a total of three reviewers. Each reviewer provided 4-6 comments, which were mostly fair and reasonable. Although there were one or two comments that seemed to take things out of context, the rest of the comments can be appropriately considered. Hopefully, after making the necessary revisions, the next submission will be accepted.

chaoyuny 2021-09-20

Little brother, if it's not an OA (Online Access) display, why are you still charging money?

内向小木偶 2021-09-18

Posted on May 18, 2021, received revision comments half a month later, accepted and searchable on sci-hub on August 4, 2021 after two revisions. The publication fee is 18,650 RMB. Overall, the first submission to SCI went smoothly. IF: 3.688, everyone keep up the good work.

chaoyuny 2021-08-29

Submitted on July 15th, revised on the 25th of this month.
Reviewer 1 had no comments and suggested publishing according to the manuscript.
Reviewer 2 suggested referencing a few other articles.
These were minor issues.
I revised it overnight, around August 18th, and it was accepted on August 28th. Overall, it was very fast.
It was so fast that it made me suspect if it was a low-quality journal.

Discover Peeref hubs

Discuss science. Find collaborators. Network.

Join a conversation

Add your recorded webinar

Do you already have a recorded webinar? Grow your audience and get more views by easily listing your recording on Peeref.

Upload Now