小年哥哥 2023-08-09

Classmate, how long did it take you from submission to the journal to being with the editor? Did it take four months for the manuscript to be reviewed after submission?

小年哥哥 2023-08-09

Until today, it is still in this state, really slow...

小年哥哥 2023-08-03

Just a record, submitted to the journal on July 24th, and currently the status is still "submitted to journal".

xuweixuwei 2023-08-03

The whole process went through five months of recruitment and four reviewers. The reviewing process was actually quite fast. The first round of review by the editor took a month, and the second round of review was also held for a month. It seems that on the second of each month, the editor handles the manuscripts, so everyone doesn't need to worry.

Alfred lee 2023-07-23

Brother, how can I know how many reviewers have replied to the comments?

Alfred lee 2023-07-23

Brother, how do you know how many reviewers have responded with their comments?

珊瑚树 2023-07-20

Hello, may I ask how long it took for you to submit the revised manuscript for review after the major revision? It has been 2 months since I submitted the revised version in the system, and it still shows "Revision Submitted to Journal." Should I continue to wait?

asweetboy 2023-07-19

Submitted in March, the review process took nearly 4 months, and received minor revisions. After submitting the revised manuscript, it was accepted within 10 days.

科研混世魔王 2023-07-14

Submitted for review, very slow.

wanghuadong0123 2023-07-12

4.17 submitted
4.24 under review
6.13 minor revision
7.1 revised
7.10 accepted

科研混世魔王 2023-07-07

It takes more than a month for any changes to occur.

clcdsimeon 2023-07-01

I am also in this situation. I submitted in January and received a comment in April, but there has been no result so far. Can this at least indicate that the comment returned was not a rejection? Otherwise, if the first comment was not good, there would be no need to wait for other reviewers, right?

左耳朵进水 2023-06-26

Don't worry, my revised draft has been in the same state as yours, waiting for half a year... Including the time for the first review, it has been over a year.

Justin 2023-06-25

3.31 Submission
4.9 Under review
I have consulted with multiple experts, a total of two reviewers. One reviewer submitted their comments in April, while the other has not submitted yet. I have sent two reminder emails during this period, but it hasn't been effective. I am worried.

Justin 2023-06-25

Same as the original poster, I have also been waiting for about three months. However, I have sent two reminder emails but there has been no response.

AKHAKH 2023-06-25

Are you the reviewer's comments that came after four months?

AKHAKH 2023-06-25

The speed is too slow, 4.8 submission, and there is still no review opinion until today... I saw on the ESWEIR public account that there are three reviewers, one of them submitted opinions in May, but the other two have been silent. I don't know if I should remind them...

xuweixuwei 2023-06-19

The speed of manuscript review depends on which editor it comes from, mainly from the Double First-Class Initiative of the Chinese Academy of Sciences. The requirements for the quality of manuscripts from Chinese authors are generally higher than those from foreign authors.

公渡 2023-06-16

Hello, how long have you been in the "With Editor" status?

Hongze Du 2023-06-15

6.14 Evening Submission
6.15 Morning Rejection

笑看这世界 2023-06-13

4.10 Submission
4.16 Review
5.28 Minor Revision
6.2 Revised
6.13 Accepted

人间无事人 2023-06-03

"24th for review"

造纸厂工人 2023-06-03

Original: 楼主，你的稿件送审了吗？我这都一个月了还是with editor
Translation: Original poster, did you submit your manuscript for review? It has been a month for me and it is still with the editor.

造纸厂工人 2023-06-03

Classmate, have you submitted your paper for review? Mine has been for a month and it's still with the editor.

Xiaoxuan 2023-05-18

5.16 rejected, reason being the theme does not match.

Asir 2023-05-18

Is the review process of this journal slow? It has been two weeks since submission and there is still no response from the editor. When will it be reviewed?

Janrous 2023-05-17

5.5 submission, 5.17 still Submitted to Journal

Xiaoxuan 2023-05-15

5.4 Submission
On the 15th, it was still submitted to the journal, a bit slow.

an junfang 2023-05-14

I want to submit to this journal, but encountered a slight problem during the process. When I reached the final step and clicked on "I accepted," there was no option to fill in. I don't know what to do now. Can someone knowledgeable help me figure it out?

人间无事人 2023-05-13

"Still in submitted status."