wu..you 2023-07-26

May I ask, does "Under Review" mean that it has already been reviewed externally?

llllqwe 2023-07-25

Subsequent updates.
Submitted on 7.17.
Format issues for rework on 7.19.
Under review on 7.19.

azhe12 2023-06-02

A minor formatting issue, repeatedly sent back for revision, if rejected again, I won't submit it anymore.

phz 2023-04-23

How long has your submission been under review?

Wan~ 2023-04-16

May I ask what does "Under Review" mean for the submission status? Does it mean that it has already been sent for external review? It has been a month and it has been in this status all along.

Wan~ 2023-04-16

May I ask what does "Under Review" mean for the submission status? Does it mean that it has already been sent for external review?

ChrisMa 2023-04-07

April 4, 2023, online.

即将有人鱼线 2023-03-30

After submission, they said my similarity rate was too high and even attached a plagiarism report. When I opened it, to my surprise, they checked the similarity of my reference list as well. How could the similarity rate not be high then? They asked me to revise and resubmit, but can I really change the references of 40 articles? I am speechless. What does this journal mean?

ChrisMa 2023-03-26

On December 5, 2022, submitted.
On December 7, 2022, edited and sent back, requesting that the cover letter clearly state the keywords of the paper.
On December 8, 2022, resubmitted.
On January 31, 2023, major revision (two reviewers, extended deadline until May).
On February 13, 2023, revised major revision.
On February 14, 2023, edited and sent back (the teacher insisted on adding a personal statement by the author, and the editor requested a submission of an author change explanation).
On February 17, 2023, resubmitted major revision and explanation document.
On February 22, 2023, edited and sent back (stated that the reasons for adding the author were not sufficient, exchanged emails and discussed with the editor...).
On February 24, 2023, resubmitted major revision and explanation document.
On March 23, 2023, accepted.

Today, the 26th, the copyright statement was submitted, entering the proof stage.

毛毛虫虫子 2023-03-06

There is no template, when submitting, it is mentioned freedom of form.

Wan~ 2023-02-24

What should I do if the official website of the journal does not provide a template?

毛毛虫虫子 2023-01-26

Filed on April 22nd, returned to initial review exactly two months later (June 22nd), and the second review took just over a month.

apoorman 2023-01-05

The editor rejected it twice and directly rejected it on the third submission without any reason? Damn!

apoorman 2022-12-15

How long does it take to allocate an ID number!

中二也要做科研 2022-12-12

After editing and reviewing for a month, the submission was rejected, stating that the manuscript needs further polishing, and even after polishing, there is no guarantee of acceptance. It has been resubmitted to another publication.

apoorman 2022-12-08

How long after submission does the review process start? I hope to get everyone's answer!

apoorman 2022-12-03

Can you please mention the timeline?

apoorman 2022-11-15

What about the time node?

apoorman 2022-11-15

Is there any news about the article?

毛毛虫虫子 2022-11-12

There was a slight issue in the middle, but the second review was actually quite fast. It took less than 2 months and it has been accepted. The editor is really good! They responded promptly and patiently despite being disturbed multiple times.

中二也要做科研 2022-10-10

How often does this journal with an editor come out?

毛毛虫虫子 2022-08-30

It's quite fast. The first review took two months, and the reviewer's comments were very helpful. In the second review, I hope they can accept it.

zhaoyy 2022-04-22

Submission---------- July 14, 2021
First revision---- October 14, 2021
Second revision (actually minor revision)---- January 23, 2022
Acceptance----- February 23, 2022
Online retrieval----- March 4, 2022