Gu Bethune 2023-06-28

After submission, there is no requirement to upload the original data.

hulu1 2023-06-14

Finally accepted at the end of March, not easy! The reviewers and editors of the magazine were very serious and meticulous, and I learned a lot.

hulu1 2023-03-31

Accept on 3.29, provide proof on 3.30.

hulu1 2023-02-27

23.2.7 Return after major revision, 2.14 under review, 2.24 Second round of comments from two reviewers received, 2.27 conduct additional experiments for major revision.

hulu1 2022-12-11

Submission status: Submitted on 10.23, under review on 11.11, under review on 11.14, received two comments on 11.28, decision in process on 12.9, major revision requested on 12.10. The review process seems quite fast, considering this is a classic and reputable journal. The review comments are quite professional and address the key points. Some of them are indeed challenging to answer, but having these comments can indeed improve the quality of the manuscript. Hopefully, after carefully revising the manuscript, it will be accepted.

TinBaoBao 2022-03-27

Hello, I would like to ask if this magazine requires WB raw data to be provided?

sunny1973-2 2021-12-24

A good magazine with professional peer review comments.

幸运1991325 2021-03-01

Original text: 楼主，请问你是大修还是小修？返修后多久时间通知消息呢?我已经返修差不多两个月了

Translation: OP, may I ask if you are referring to a major repair or a minor repair? How long does it usually take to receive notification after a repair? It has been almost two months since I sent my item for repair.

不落雄鹰 2021-02-22

It is still a good magazine. After revising the manuscript, it was directly accepted.