ZJU-L 2023-08-08

8.7 Required reviews completed means that all the necessary evaluations or assessments have been finished.

8.8 Decision in process indicates that a decision is currently being made or considered.

Matttt 2023-08-07

8.5 submitted means that something has been submitted or turned in.
8.7 with editor means that something is currently being reviewed or worked on by an editor.

C 2023-07-31

7.31 submitted to journal: This means that on July 31st, a manuscript or article was submitted to a journal for publication consideration.
7.31 with editor: This indicates that on July 31st, the manuscript or article is currently being reviewed or processed by the editor of the journal.

ZJU-L 2023-07-27

How many reviewers did LZ send?

ZJU-L 2023-07-27

Did you receive the result in just two weeks? I don't know if it's not ideal, sigh!

ZJU-L 2023-07-27

A result came back, not sure if the result after two weeks is not too ideal, sigh!

jijianyi 2023-07-27

After the first trial, does the status go directly to RRC or does it change to DIP after RRC?

交大德布劳内 2023-07-26

2.26 Submission
3.07 Under review
6.06 Review process completed, major revisions (given one month)
7.01 Revised
7.23 Second review completed
7.24 Accepted
7.26 Proofreading

ZJULAM 2023-07-26

6.30 Submitted to journal
7.02 With editor
7.11 Under review
7.24 Under review

Translation:

6.30 Submitted to journal
7.02 With editor
7.11 Under review
7.24 Under review

Top_paper 2023-07-26

Did you receive any feedback, OP? I have also been waiting for required reviews to be completed for about ten days. Can you please make a modification for me?

chuannanxiong 2023-07-26

Received any feedback? I have also been waiting for required reviews to be completed for about ten days, please help me with the modifications.

学术之光就是我 2023-07-21

Shrunk to 34 pages, can't shrink any further, doesn't matter anymore.

学术之光就是我 2023-07-21

I'm fed up with the limit on the number of pages, they're forcing me to condense it to 30 pages before submitting.

ssssssaaa 2023-07-21

It has been 20 days since RRC, and the efficiency is really too low!

ssssssaaa 2023-07-09

7.2rrc; 7.6rrc; 10 days Required Reviews Completed, no news. What's the situation?

ssssssaaa 2023-07-03

7.2 Required Reviews Completed. Just need a major overhaul!!!! Please, please, please.

xxxt 2023-07-02

6.28 Submission
6.29 with editor
7.1 Under Review

Matttt 2023-06-24

Overall, the editing process was very timely, with decisions being made within a week after the RRC. However, modifications after the first review took nearly two months (with a three-week delay in the application), resulting in a slightly longer overall time.

yiweiyihang666 2023-06-23

The second paper was rejected on 6.23. It lacked originality and the comparison with other methods was insufficient. There were also some issues with the writing of the paper. It's better to continue learning more.

cm 2023-06-20

It should be that the reviewer did not reply in time, so after the review deadline expired, the editor will contact new reviewers again.

yiweiyihang666 2023-06-20

I am under review with a score of 3.9, and it is still under review until now. Perhaps this is the unpredictability of the world. Is it possible that the reviewer did not recommend it well?

cm 2023-06-05

Here is the revised timeline:
2023 3.6 Submitted to journal
2023 3.7 With editor
2023 3.12 Under review
2023 4.12 Required reviews completed
2023 4.16 Major revise
2023 5.13 Resubmit
2023 6.03 Required reviews completed
2023 6.03 Accept
2023 6.05 Rights & Access form, Colour order form, Offprint order form
2023 6.06 Submit forms to the journal
2023 6.06 Proof
2023 6.08 Submit proof to the journal
2023 6.10 Online
The editor is very responsible, efficient in handling manuscripts, and the reviewers are also very professional.
Wishing ENGINEERING STRUCTURES continued success, and hoping it will be upgraded to a first-tier journal by the Chinese Academy of Sciences next year.

ssssssaaa 2023-06-05

6.4 Under Review; Waiting for modification!

ssssssaaa 2023-06-04

6.2 With Editor, the time has been updated once! Waiting for an external review opportunity! Praying!

ssssssaaa 2023-06-01

It has been 6 days and it's still not submitted for review. If you want to reject it, please do it quickly!

Nixi 2023-05-31

Does the es always have a dip stage after the rrc?

ssssssaaa 2023-05-30

5.26 Submission
5.28 With Editor
Continued updates to follow

Nixi 2023-05-28

May I ask if there will definitely be a dip process after the rrc in this journal, es?

Nixi 2023-05-28

May I ask if there will definitely be a dip process after this journal, "es," and the RRC?

Nixi 2023-05-28

Is there a DIP stage after RRC in ES?