Bernice 2023-07-25

It has been more than ten days, and then awaiting referee assignment, how long does this status take? Has it just been sent for external review or has the external review already been completed?

nie35786 2023-05-06

I'm here to comment!

Submitted at the end of October in the 22nd year, received review comments in early December, major revisions, the review comments were very pertinent!!! It greatly helped us modify the paper. After three months of modifications, it was sent for re-review by the original three reviewers, and it has recently been accepted~~

The first paper in my life that is classified as a top-tier journal!

低碳苼活 2022-12-14

Top journal in ecology, such a good magazine but no one is evaluating it, probably because the experts are too busy.

We submitted the paper in early October and received review comments in mid-November. One reviewer had no major comments, but the other reviewer stated that our research lacked novelty, which directly led to a death sentence. ELE has very high requirements for the originality and novelty of research.

It has to be said that the reviewers of ELE are very professional. They pointed out all the potential flaws that we thought might exist before submitting the paper.