花仙子露 2023-06-14

It has been two months since it's under review and still no news. The only change was the deadline being extended by one month. If it's a rejection, I hope it comes soon.

司令army 2023-05-05

Warning everyone, do not invest, still with the editor after more than a month.

sharkfish 2023-03-11

Unfortunately, Zone 2 has been downgraded to Zone 3.

sharkfish 2023-03-11

2022.10.12 Submission
2022.10.15 With editor
2022.11.21 Under Review
2022.12.27 Major Revise
2023.2.16 Return after major revisions
2023.2.23 With editor
2023.3.10 Accept (No further Under Review after major revisions)
The whole process went smoothly, but the waiting time was just too long. Nevertheless, the outcome is good. Thank you to the reviewers and editors.

GIAO GIAO爱文章 2023-03-01

I haven't received any review comments for my submission in eight months, and they even downgraded my area this year. I'm considering withdrawing my submission!

TANhaoc 2023-02-22

Warning everyone, it has been 60 days, and I have been with the editor all along.

基金求过 2022-12-04

Don't invest, don't invest, don't invest. It has been over five months and there is still no news. I will never invest in this magazine again in my lifetime.

GIAO GIAO爱文章 2022-11-16

From July 21 until now, this journal has been varying in speed, and mine belongs to the slow one.

小白123456 2022-11-16

How long has it been under review?

GIAO GIAO爱文章 2022-11-16

It has been six months since I submitted my application, and I haven't received any response from the first review. Sigh, rejection is not scary, but please don't keep dragging it. It's even slower than Chinese, I'm speechless.

小白123456 2022-11-15

How about yours? It has been half a month since my "under review" date changed for the second time, but there has been no progress.

GIAO GIAO爱文章 2022-11-14

When your manuscript enters under review, an Elsevier manuscript tracking link will be sent to the corresponding author, where you can view it.

小白123456 2022-11-13

Where did you see that there were two review invitations sent?

Luckyyu 2022-11-12

It has been 56 days and still with the editor.

gzhjiayou 2022-10-27

Really slow, always in "with editor" mode.

zseason 2022-09-20

I have been waiting for the review of my submission for over two months now. It has already been six months since the first review. Recently, the Last modified time has changed three times. Does this mean that the result is coming soon?

墨瞳 2022-09-15

It's really too slow.

09112468 2022-08-11

Suddenly I realized that this journal has actually dropped to JCR Q2. It's really a loss.

GIAO GIAO爱文章 2022-07-21

may 28 submission
may 31 resubmission
june 7 with editor
july 21 under review (Review invitations sent: 2)
Good luck! Can't withstand any more disruptions!

X~X 2022-07-15

It has been nearly two months for me. I have sent three emails within the system, two of which were sent to the editor-in-chief, but I have not received any response or seen any changes. I want to know how to withdraw my submission. There is no option for withdrawal within the system, and when I send a withdrawal email through the system, there is no record. I want to switch and submit it quickly.

莫名独具 2022-07-15

My submission on the 12th was reviewed, and a reviewer completed the review on the 13th. Most likely, it didn't go well.

莫名独具 2022-07-12

July 5th with editor, now it's July 11th with editor. This journal is so slow...

X~X 2022-07-11

I feel that you can resubmit, but look at the speed of this journal, I feel it's better to switch to another one.

弗林 2022-07-11

The thing I need to modify is the picture. I cannot send pictures through the submission interface. It has been over a month, and it's urgent. Does anyone know a way to successfully send it to the journal's email?

X~X 2022-07-11

My situation hasn't changed. First, I sent a message to the system, and then I sent two emails to the editor-in-chief, but I haven't received any replies. I am now prepared to withdraw my submission. I can't afford to provoke them. For those who are planning to submit in the future, I suggest being cautious and choosing a different journal. I sincerely do not recommend it. They are too irresponsible.

水煮paper 2022-07-09

I submitted it on the same day as you, but mine has not been assigned an editor, let alone an external review.

Lj20131209 2022-07-08

Response is needed from the submission interface. I have also experienced this. The editor sent an email asking for revisions, but I never received the reply. When I replied from the submission interface, I received a response within three hours, and it was sent for review the next day. Feedback was received in less than a month, and now it has been returned. There were four reviewers, and the problems were considered simple.

Lj20131209 2022-07-08

Need to reply from the submission interface, I have also experienced this. The editor sent an email asking for revisions, but I kept replying and he never received them. When I replied from the submission interface, I received a response within three hours and it was sent for review the next day. It took less than a month to receive feedback, and now it has already been sent for revision.

弗林 2022-07-08

The technical editor said to resend the abstract, but no matter how many times it was sent, the editor still couldn't receive it. It has been delayed for more than a month, and even if it is sent now, there is no response.

GIAO GIAO爱文章 2022-07-08

Not submitted for review yet, nor rejected. Just keeping fish here, it's so agonizing!