赤子之心 2023-08-09

Why can't I see the reviewer's status?

zseason 2023-08-03

How many reviewers have you sent to? I submitted my paper in May and after checking, it was sent to two reviewers. By the end of June, one reviewer returned their comments, but the other reviewer has not accepted the review yet. The status has remained unchanged. Should I keep waiting? Will the decision be made based on one reviewer's opinion? Thank you.

misakaaa 2023-08-03

In Dreamy Love Magazine.

I submitted it in June and waited almost a year for the results. I still feel somewhat confident about it. After two months of review, I only received feedback from one reviewer. The feedback was very sloppy, consisting of only a few sentences. It didn't improve the paper at all, and I even felt like the reviewer didn't understand the content, maybe because they were a student of some influential figure.

The editor rejected the paper solely based on this reviewer's feedback. To be honest, I am really disappointed, mainly because I am not convinced by the reasons for rejection.

It all comes down to luck, whether it's the editor or the reviewer. I will prioritize Computer in the next article.

qian binxiang 2023-08-01

Received, I mistyped it as "accepted", there was a typo.

zseason 2023-08-01

Posted on May 19th, sent to 2 reviewers. On June 28th, the status changed once and it was mentioned that one reviewer's comments have been returned. However, the other reviewer has not responded regarding their approval for the review. Until August 1st, the status has not changed, indicating that one reviewer has not replied regarding their approval for the review. This delay has been too long, should a reminder letter be sent?!

qian binxiang 2023-07-30

4.4: Submit manuscript
4.6: With editor
4.16: Submissions needing revising (formatting changes)
4.19: Submit revised manuscript
4.21: With editor
4.30: Under review
5.1: Review invitations sent: 2+
Review invitations accepted: 2+
5.21: Review completed: 2
6.4: Moderate revision (language and logic changes, clarifying some content)
6.24: With editor
6.30: Under review - review invitations sent: 2
7.7: Under review - review invitations accepted: 2
7.29: Under review - review completed: 2
7.29: Required reviews completed
7.30: Completed - Accept

qian binxiang 2023-07-30

Just received an article from CEA (April 4, 2023 - July 30, 2023). It was accepted directly after revision, taking 4 months. I have recorded the detailed submission and review timeline, hoping it will be helpful to everyone.

haha 2023-07-28

Hello, may I ask what the final result is?

haha 2023-07-28

Hello, may I ask how the final result turned out?

帅涛 2023-07-26

It has been eight days since I completed the required reviews, but there are still no results. What is the current situation with yours?

新安 2023-07-20

Does this journal charge page fees for non-OA publications?

2255 2023-07-19

2021.11.8 Submission
3.22 First review returned, major revision (2 months)
5.9 First review modifications completed and returned
6.12 Second review returned, minor revision, 2 out of 3 reviewers have no issues (2 months)
7.15 Second review submitted
2022.7.24 Accepted

张䶮 2023-07-14

with editor 4.02
under review 5.06
review complete 6.27
minor review
Return for repair: 7.12
Accept: 7.14

赤子之心 2023-07-12

Today, the state date was updated to July 11, 2023. Why is that?

赤子之心 2023-07-11

It has been over a month since the review.

Zhangl006 2023-07-04

2023.7.3 Evening submission record
2023.7.5 with editor
2023.7.13 Under Review
2023.7.25 Under Review

Fighting123 2023-07-01

There is a link within the corresponding author, through which you can view how many reviewers have been invited and how many have agreed to review. Oh, the editor...

zseason 2023-06-30

May I ask how you know the detailed review status? Including the number of reviewers, how many have accepted the review, etc.? Shouldn't the issue of the mismatched theme be raised during the initial review by the editor? Confused~

Fighting123 2023-06-27

2023.2.3 submitted
2023.2.4 with editor
2023.2.6 with editor
2023.3.4 Sent a reminder letter to ask for the status of the article
2023.3.6 under review (Editor invited 5 reviewers, 1 reviewer agreed to review)
2023.3.8 under review (1 reviewer completed the review)
2023.3.23 Sent a reminder letter and recommended reviewers (Agreed to a review period of 2 cycles)
2023.3.30 under review (Invited 4 more reviewers, 2 reviewers agreed to review)
2023.4.20 Sent a reminder letter. The Elsevier customer service informed us that the review should be completed before the 29th of April and did not forward the reminder letter to the editor.
2023.4.27 required reviews completed (2 reviewers completed the review, 1 did not)
2023.4.29 required reviews completed (3 reviewers completed the review)
2023.5.6 decision in process
2023.5.8 decision in process
2023.5.12 Reject
Inquiry revealed that it was rejected due to mismatched theme.

zseason 2023-06-15

I want to ask, how can I see how many reviewers have been assigned to this journal? How do I know if the reviewers have accepted the review? It has been half a month since "Under Review," but the status hasn't changed.

zseason 2023-06-13

Why is it a major revision in August?

ysyysy 2023-06-13

How is it after the dip?

ysyysy 2023-06-13

What is the current status?

ysyysy 2023-06-13

What is the result? Did it get approved or rejected?

小洛洛 2023-06-13

How about you? I made a decision after a few days, but it's been days and there's still no response. I can't submit to any other journals.

stwen 2023-06-10

June 08, 2023 Major Revision Gratitude...

卡夫卡漫步 2023-06-09

Hello, may I ask if the first author of this journal can see the manuscript status information, or is it only visible to the corresponding author?

wyc0317 2023-06-07

June 4th with editor
June 7th directly dip
Is it gone?

zseason 2023-05-30

How to see how many reviewers are there? I can only see the current status, not other situations. I have been under review for ten days after submitting.

MingLiSCI 2023-05-23

2023
1.4 Submitted
1.4 With Editor
1.10 Under Review
1.24 Under Review
2.13 Under Review
3.20 Under Review
3.29 Required Reviews Completed
3.29 Major Revision

4.26 Submitted with Editor
5.04 Under Review
5.22 Required Reviews Completed
5.22 Accept