被拒稿的心路历程 2023-08-07

It is possible that a senior editor assigns the task to a junior editor in the field, and the junior editor then seeks reviewers to review your manuscript.

jian2021 2023-08-05

Aug 05, 2023 With Editor
Is this another change of editor?

jayodyssey 2023-08-03

2023.03.06 Submit
2023.05.03 Major Revision, 30 days' time limit for modifications
2023.06.01 Resubmit
2023.08.02 Accept

Elsevier's submission process for public observations provides the review process of several reviewers, with positive feedback.

被拒稿的心路历程 2023-08-02

Posted on May 30th, reviewed by editor on June 2nd, and today is August 2nd. It has been a full two months and it is still with the editor. This journal is incredibly slow (previously, it has never taken more than two months, or even longer, to review). My friend said it used to be quite fast, but I don't know what happened recently. Even getting it reviewed is difficult.

中中中666 2023-07-24

I submitted at the same time as you, and it is still "with editor" with no updates. Urgent!

谢谢515 2023-07-23

2023-5-29 with the editor, no area editor has been assigned until now. Reminded but no reply received.

被拒稿的心路历程 2023-07-19

Mine too. Submitted on June 2nd, with editor on June 5th. Today is already July 19th, and the status is still "with editor" and has not changed.

JudyHop 2023-07-17

2023.05.26 submitted to journal
2023.05.27 with editor
2023.06.14 Sent an email to urge the editor, received a positive response from the editor
(No news until now)

jian2021 2023-07-17

Jun 24, 2023 Submitted to Journal
Jun 27, 2023 With Editor
Aug 05, 2023 With Editor
Has the editor been changed again?

wyfhdlw 2023-07-16

This is probably the fastest one I've invested in. I feel like everyone can give it a try.

wyfhdlw 2023-07-16

The overall speed is considered quite fast, and the timeline is as follows:
March 21, 2023: Submission of the initial draft
May 19, 2023: Moderate revision (requested to be returned within one month)
June 1, 2023: Submission of the revised manuscript
July 14, 2023: Acceptance
On average, each review process takes less than two months. The reviewers' opinions are quite professional, and I believe they have significantly improved the article.

阿路qq 2023-06-09

2023-03 Submitted to Journal
2023-04 Under Review
2023-06 Required Reviews Completed

Translation:
2023-03: Submitted to Journal
2023-04: Under Review
2023-06: Required Reviews Completed

jayodyssey 2023-03-27

Original: 楼主，CN with editor已经20天了，还没有under review，这个正常不

Translation: OP, it has been 20 days since CN with editor, and it still hasn't been under review. Is this normal?

大璐璐 2023-02-24

Is it convenient for the original poster to share the specific timeframe for "require review complete"? I have received good feedback in the first round, and it has been three months since the second review. Now the reviewers have replied and entered the "require review complete" stage, but there has been no progress for several days. I am anxious to graduate and in a hurry.

ZHW_HN 2023-02-12

Network Security Direction
2022.10.26 submit
2022.12.20 major revision
2023.01.05 resubmit revised draft
2023.02.12 accept

A well-established journal in the field of computer networks, with a stable influence and quality. It has a good reputation and is classified as a CCF-B class journal and JCR Q1 journal.

哈哈哈哈 2022-11-21

I haven't encountered such a slow situation before.

泉水 2022-11-07

I would like to ask the original poster, today I am preparing to submit an article, but the submission page seems really slow. Have you encountered this situation?

泉水 2022-11-07

Excuse me, how do I submit the link? It's going so slow. I've been trying since the afternoon until midnight, and it still feels very slow. This isn't normal, right?

ncnsdhca 2022-10-26

2022.04 Submission, under review after one week
2022.06 Required reviewers completed
2022.07 Major Revision, 2 reviewers, with a time limit of 1 month
2022.08 Resubmitted after major revision, under review on the second day
2022.09 Minor Revision, 3 reviewers, with a time limit of 2 weeks
2022.09 Resubmitted after two weeks of revision
2022.10 Accepted

哈哈哈哈 2022-10-22

Although the editor delayed me for a month, the first review only took 20 days. Currently, the major revision has been returned for 12 days. I hope for a good outcome.

xxxxwy 2022-09-20

First instance seven months, second instance two months, it is not surprising that cryptography review is slow. In the first instance, only two reviewers had comments, with one of them being extremely responsible. In terms of journal quality, it is quite good with rigorous review and sincere and in-depth opinions. If you are not too concerned about time, friends in the field of cryptography can give it a try.

Link 2022-09-02

Posted in early January 2022, accepted in early July after a duration of 6 months. Went through 2 major revisions during the process. There were 4 reviewers, overall they were very professional and responsible! There were certain requirements for innovation, making it a very good journal in the field of network systems.

墨风儿 2022-08-30

The journal is quite good. Submitted on June 2nd, received major revisions from five reviewers on June 29th. One of the reviewers had a rather bad attitude. Revised on July 29th, accepted on August 25th.

Charles_chen 2022-07-25

May I ask how much is the submission fee?

laker 2022-06-14

CCF B is an established journal. I have submitted several papers, and one of them went through major revisions in the first round and was rejected in the second round, which left a deep impression on me. In the most recent submission, the paper went through major revisions in the first round and was accepted in the second round. Based on my experiences with multiple submissions, the reviewers are quite professional and expect the papers to be innovative and substantial in terms of workload.

五二一五 2022-05-30

After one day, the status changed back to "Under Review" from "Required Reviews Completed". Is it going to arbitration? Looks like it's not looking good.

五二一五 2022-05-18

May I ask how long the second review process of this journal usually takes?

sd22 2022-05-07

It depends on the quality of your paper. This is a CCF B-level journal, slightly lower than Trans.

五二一五 2022-04-25

Excuse me, does this journal mean that once an article is submitted, even if it receives a major revision during the first round of review, it will not be rejected?

黄金泽 2021-11-07

Excuse me, how much is the layout fee for this?