wqh1999 2023-07-09

1 Reviewer report received——7.9

This means that a reviewer's report has been received with a score of 7.9.

赶紧毕业吧！ 2023-06-28

May I ask what field you are in? Can I add you as a friend?

不浊 2023-06-25

Only one reviewer accepted the invitation and it has been three months without any progress.

Chris PENG 2023-06-13

May I ask if this journal can be resubmitted after being rejected for the first time, with revisions made?

wqh1999 2023-06-05

Submission received——6.1
Submission passed technical check——6.2
Submission under peer review——6.2 (Editor appointed when not clicked)
[Will continue to share, looking forward to the following]

你好你好你好 2023-05-22

Hello, may I ask how many reviewers provided comments in the first round? Why did I only receive comments from one reviewer?

Jason_C 2023-05-22

It took approximately 9 months from submission received (12 Aug 2022) to submission accepted (06 May 2023). There were two rounds of revisions during this period, and the reviewers were generally fair in their assessments.

oogou11 2023-05-07

The journal's feedback is very comprehensive.

feizhang 2023-05-04

I submitted a paper in the 21st year and it took 8 months for the review process. I had to remind them several times in the middle. Finally, I received the result, which required major revisions. However, when I saw the reviewer's comments, they were clearly unrelated to my paper. I asked the editor to verify if there was a mistake, but the editor said there was no mistake and asked me to respond to the reviewer's comments or resubmit the paper. I was speechless and couldn't afford to wait any longer, so I had to withdraw my submission.

爱你的笑1987 2023-04-04

1.2022.7.12 Submission
2.2022.12.27 Minor revision
3.2023.1.4 Editorial assessment, lasted for 3 months
4.2023.4.3 Re-invite different reviewers from before, send for external review

It has been 9 months now, the minor revision took three months for editorial assessment, and surprisingly they still need to re-invite reviewers, which is equivalent to starting the review process again. Friends who are impatient should be cautious!

PG_CSL 2023-03-09

Hello, may I ask approximately how long the Technical check in progress status will last?

ChaoJ 2022-12-27

Everyone is different, some are fast and some are slow. Here is my approximate submission timeline:

1. Submitted at the end of June.
2. Received revision comments at the end of August (sent a reminder once during this period).
3. Received feedback at the beginning of September.
4. Received second round of revisions at the end of November (sent two reminders during this period).
5. Received feedback in early December.
6. Finally received acceptance notification at the end of December without any reminders.

Overall, this journal seems to have certain requirements for the innovation of the paper. They assigned multiple reviewers (at least 7 in total) who were very responsible. However, it seems that they recently changed their submission system, resulting in a particularly long review period. If you feel that the process is taking too long, you can politely send an email to the assistant, who usually responds within a day. I hope this information can help you.

ZHEN11 2022-12-27

Hello, I would like to ask, how long does it take to be approved?

ChaoJ 2022-12-27

Thank you, OP. Finally, on the 27th today, I was hired. After receiving feedback in September and making the first round of revisions, I was asked for a second round of revisions at the end of November. I provided feedback in early December, and today I finally received the acceptance notice! It's just a bit strange that the editor has invited a new reviewer to ask questions. I'm not sure if I need to make further revisions?!

Jinhansome 2022-10-17

Yes, there will still be a second review, and we will still find another reviewer. Your first review will still be done quickly.

ChaoJ 2022-10-17

Hello, host. Please help me analyze. I submitted my work at the end of June and received major revisions by the end of August. I was given 14 days to make the revisions, and I replied in early September. Now I am still waiting for a response. Will the second review be handed over to someone new, or will the original reviewer take a look?

Jinhansome 2022-10-13

On September 29th, I received feedback for revision, and finally on October 13th at 5:32, I received a job offer.

Jinhansome 2022-10-06

Return the draft within 7-14 days for the second round of review, and then receive the second review comments between 9-18 days. This time, an additional reviewer has been added, so the review time has been extended. Make minor revisions in 10 places and clearly indicate acceptance after the modifications.

Jinhansome 2022-07-06

First, after submitting on 3.6, it changed to "under review." Then, on May 19th, the status changed again.

Jinhansome 2022-07-06

The review speed of this journal may have become faster now, or it may be that the more popular articles are reviewed more quickly. After four months of the first review, a minor revision was requested.
3-4 with editor
5-19 under review
7-4 minor revision

Jinhansome 2022-05-17

I carefully checked the review cycle of this journal and it seems to be quite long. After I submitted my paper on March 4th, there was a delay in the title page for a few days. On March 6th, it changed to "under review." Now, it has been two months, and on May 16th, the date was updated and there was a change. I am not sure if they just found the reviewers or if the reviewers' agreement caused the change in status.

Jinhansome 2022-03-04

Hello author, how should this title page be done? It says to add a contribution and ethics statement, how should this be added?

就问你六不六 2021-07-30

2021.2.15 Submission
2021.6.9 Major revision
2021.6.29 Rework
2021.7.30 Acceptance
Submitting is troublesome, various declarations are required, initially unable to handle the Title Page, back and forth with manuscript rejections, delaying two weeks.

亲爱的小李 2021-07-09

Yes, Indians don't know what's going on now. They ask everywhere to quote their articles, but if you do quote them, even though they may agree, they can be very annoying.