KEYYYYY 2023-08-02

It has been nearly a month since submission. It changed from under review back to initial assessment and then changed back to under review again. Praying for good luck.

酷拉皮卡丘 2023-07-31

5 days for review, 23 days for rejection.

酷拉皮卡丘 2023-07-15

Okay, okay, thank you.

recovering 2023-07-15

Hahaha, the proposal was submitted by the corresponding author, so I'm not very sure either.

酷拉皮卡丘 2023-07-14

Friend, I would like to ask if sending a proposal for review means "in peer review." How many days did it take you to submit it for review?

recovering 2023-07-14

Very soon, at the latest within a month or so, I replied in just half a month.

recovering 2023-07-14

7.14 Received
Proposal submitted in August
9.8 Received a reply to the proposal stating that the journal could accept articles of this type. The journal provided three months to write the manuscript, but as it was written by a student, there were two extensions, and it was finally completed in May.
5.6 Submitted
5.28 Very major revision
7.11 Revised
7.14 Accepted
From the start of writing the proposal to acceptance, it took over a year. Eighty percent of the time was spent on writing the manuscript. The journal's speed felt very fast, so as long as the proposal was approved, as long as the manuscript was written diligently, there shouldn't be any problems.

KEYYYYY 2023-07-13

Thank you! I see that my status is "Under Review" now, hoping for some good luck!

recovering 2023-07-12

It's been about a little over a month. The review process was quite fast. I submitted it on May 6th, and I received the review comments on the 28th.

KEYYYYY 2023-07-12

I would like to know how long it will take to receive news after everyone submits their proposals.

shawn loong 2023-03-06

What is the current status now?

牛123 2022-11-07

2022 11 02 Submit proposal
2022 11 07 Review with editor

Siatwo 2022-11-04

3.18 Proposal Submitted
5.16 Accept
7.19 Review Manuscript Submitted
8.19 Major Revision
9.24 Revision Submitted
10.14 Minor Revision
10.17 Revision Submitted
11.3 Accept

Translation:
3.18 Proposal Submitted
5.16 Accept
7.19 Review Manuscript Submitted
8.19 Major Revision
9.24 Revision Submitted
10.14 Minor Revision
10.17 Revision Submitted
11.3 Accept

Galileo 2022-01-05

May I ask if the proposal needs to be approved by the boss or the first author? Does it have requirements for all authors (authoritative in this field)?

飞翔小猪 2021-11-12

May I ask what does the status "under review" mean? Does it mean the proposal has been submitted for review? Or is the editor still considering it?

longzu1984 2021-06-17

From receiving the proposal in September of last year, to submitting it in November, making revisions in early February, and finally accepting it in March, it took quite a bit of time to get the page numbers sorted out. Overall, it feels like the editors have a lot of decision-making power, while the reviewers often aren't as strict. If the editors are willing to accept it, there is a 70% chance of success!

longzu1984 2021-03-01

This review article has undergone three months of external review, with major revisions and ten days of editing. The revised manuscript has been submitted and is expected to receive a positive outcome on the same day of the external review.

飞翔369 2021-01-23

The proposal review takes 50 days, the review of the synthesis takes about 50 days, and the acceptance after modification takes 23 days.

longzu1984 2021-01-15

The opinion is quite good. Was the review process so long because the reviewers were very meticulous? We also submitted an article to this journal, and it has been under review for almost 2 months. We are getting anxious.