X所长 2023-08-07

Two reviewers, two minor revisions received in a few days. However, the review process was lengthy mainly due to the fact that one of the invited reviewers did not accept the review invitation. It took a month to invite the second reviewer. So currently, it feels difficult to find reviewers for CES. When submitting the next article to Fuel, three reviewers accepted the review within three days. If there is no rush, you can submit to CES, but if it is urgent, it is recommended to choose another journal. Currently, CES is not considered difficult.

JTLove 2023-08-07

It is a relatively well-established chemical engineering journal, with high recognition abroad. It is not only based on the journal ranking and impact factor. Speaking of ranking, AIChE is already in the third tier. However, it is highly recognized, especially among foreign researchers in the field.

eternity永恒 2023-08-07

20230606 Submission
20230714 Received reviewer comments from four reviewers, with three suggesting revisions and one rejecting the manuscript (though not strongly). The editor has given a 30-day revision period.
20230804 Submitted revised manuscript.
20230807 Accepted.
The review and acceptance process was quite fast. Hopefully, the impact factor of CES can be improved.

叶小乐 2023-08-03

Reply to JTLove: Does "三大刊" refer to high level publications? I know Aiche is very impressive, but why is CES still ranked as JCR 2nd zone CAS 2nd zone?

JTLove 2023-07-28

No, the three major publications in the field of chemical engineering are AIChE, CES, and IECR.

Plasticsnow 2023-07-26

Later, I contacted Elsevier customer service to withdraw the manuscript.

Xin_X 2023-07-25

4.28 Submission
5.8 Under review
6.5 Feedback from one reviewer with 7 comments, editor provided 2 comments, 60-day review period
7.18 Revision of comments
7.23 Acceptance
The comments from the first reviewer came back in 10 days, and we have been waiting for the second reviewer's comments. We even invited two other reviewers again. We sent two reminder emails, thankfully they were not rejected. Good luck to everyone!

叶小乐 2023-07-24

What are the three major journals in chemical engineering, CEJ, CES, and CERD?

勤火燎原 2023-07-21

Submitted on 20230516,
After 0520, it has been with the editor all along.
On 0705, it changed to under review.
Today, 0721, one person has completed the review comments, while the other reviewer is still reviewing.
I hope there can be minor revisions, thank goodness.
Although the impact factor is not high, it is still one of the top three journals in chemical engineering. So, I need to be prepared for other top-tier journals as well.

环境人何时站起来 2023-07-18

What is the current situation? I also didn't send it for review and directly dipped.

环境人何时站起来 2023-07-18

How are things going now?

环境人何时站起来 2023-07-18

How are you now?

Plasticsnow 2023-06-28

It has been over three months since I applied for the DIP, and I have sent five emails but have not received any replies. I would like to ask if anyone has any suggestions on what to do in this situation?

制球 2023-06-21

Did only two reviewers provide comments on your paper? I thought "under review" meant that there were comments from the reviewers.

制球 2023-06-21

My "under review" status has also changed four times and it has been two months already. Could it be that there are no reviewers willing to review it?

邓阿喵 2023-06-21

On June 20th, transfer pending (two reviewers suggested major revisions, but in the end, the editorial department rejected it).

悦悦皮卡丘 2023-06-20

It's been a month with editor, why has it taken so long?

邓阿喵 2023-06-19

June 19th, Required Reviews Completed.

Plasticsnow 2023-06-15

It has been two and a half months since DIP.

邓阿喵 2023-06-08

June 7th, under review--

邓阿喵 2023-06-08

June 7th, under review.

wang...1234 2023-05-12

Hello, I would like to ask how many reviewers are there?

xuzelin 2023-05-07

My "Under review" status has changed 4 times as well. I'm afraid of being rejected. I hope we both have good luck.

xuzelin 2023-05-07

May 7, 2023 Under review

邓阿喵 2023-05-04

May 4th, under review.

xuzelin 2023-05-01

April 11th - Submit to Journal
April 12th - With Editor
April 17th - Under Review
April 23rd - Under Review
April 30th - Under Review

邓阿喵 2023-04-26

On April 25th, under review.

邓阿喵 2023-04-19

April 18th, under review

Plasticsnow 2023-04-17

The text translates to: "It has been three weeks since the submission for DIP was not sent for review on March 27th, and the status date has not changed until now..."

Plasticsnow 2023-04-17

The following text translates to English as: "Since March 27th, it has been three weeks since the review was not submitted and it has not been updated till now."