Braaandy 2023-07-12

I am also this editor. After returning for revision, I sent it to the reviewer, and it has been in the status of "1 reviewer report received" for several days now. I don't know when the results will be available.

莫问 2023-07-05

After the editing of the article is done, it needs to be reviewed and approved by the chief editor. So, it might be stuck with the chief editor.

upup恺恺 2023-06-09

This editor is from Germany, a big shot in the ILs field. Last time they rejected me, but their speed is still good, quite fast.
Recently, the submission for cellulose is a bit slow. It has been a week and the editing is still being assigned.

ylin 2023-05-31

My paper has been with the editor for over a month, and I haven't asked about the progress. Now I really want to withdraw it.

crazy Thursday vivo 50 2023-05-29

I have also reached the stage of editor evaluating revision. I hope I don't have to wait for a month again. Previously, I had to wait for two months for the review comments.

YXT-H 2023-05-28

2023.5.28 accept Finally...

YXT-H 2023-05-26

Sharing my bizarre and infuriating submission experience:

Submitted on September 16, 2022.
Received reviewer feedback after more than 4 months on January 27, 2023. There were two reviewers, and one of them provided incorrect feedback (seems like they mistakenly attached feedback meant for another submission, as it didn't match at all). Contacted the editor, who promised to handle it promptly, but then began a long wait. In the meantime, the editor sent an email saying they would expedite the process, but it was of no use.
Received feedback from one reviewer on April 12, 2023, with a two-week revision period.
Submitted the revised version on April 14, 2023.
Since April 17, 2023, the editor has been evaluating the revision (deciding whether to send it back to the reviewers). During this period, I reminded them once again, expressing my urgency. The editorial department promptly notified me whenever there was an update (which felt like nonsense). It's becoming unbearable to wait any longer...

To all my fellow students who are eager to graduate and need results, please avoid submitting to this journal. I've never seen anything slower!

Additional note: The editor is Thomas Heinze, this "lightning-fast" individual.

wjxc 2023-05-13

I'm fed up. On March 30th, it showed that I received 1 reviewer report, but until now, there's still no news. I've been submitting since September 16th, 2023, and it's been so long that I feel like a fool.

木易1 2023-05-08

I searched for a long time to find the Endnote format for references. It took two months to submit and another two months for the whole process. For those in need of reference formatting, we can help each other on QQ, at eight one four five eight nine two six zero.

crazy Thursday vivo 50 2023-04-18

Hello, I wanted to ask how things have been going for you recently?

wjxc 2023-04-13

My pregnancy has already been 7 months, from September 16th, 2022, when I submitted the application until now, I'm almost fed up.

lcm050711 2023-04-11

Submitted the manuscript in October last year, it is still under review until now, it is really too slow.

Durian Pizza 2023-04-04

I have been submitting for over 4 months, it took only 2 weeks to revise the format. I submitted in early December and had major revisions in mid-February. A few days later, it was sent back for further revisions. It took 2 weeks at the editor's office to finally become "under peer review." On March 21st, I received the reviewer reports, and now, two weeks later, it is still "Ready for editor's decision." I will never submit to this journal again... I thought it would be quick, but I was deceived and ended up in tears.

QYGCN 2023-03-27

Review of the submission, the editor has strict requirements for the format and details, and made 5-6 revisions. Although it took a bit long, it was ultimately accepted. Thank you.

ss0313 2023-02-24

The magazine has high requirements for the format. The reviewers requested two revisions for the format and charts of the manuscript. However, after the modifications, it was finally accepted. Thank you.

Zoen 2023-02-22

You shouldn't ask under someone else's comment. I guess they wouldn't even know you asked a question.

zhaodf 2023-02-22

Are you the original poster who works with polyimide film? Is the submission process for minor revisions or major revisions? Do you have any specific experiences?

小玉米 2023-02-22

12.28 Submission
2.21 Reception

asdwguo 2023-02-02

11.20 Manuscript status "1 Reviewer report received"
1.13 After more than a month, the status remains unchanged. Sent an email to inquire about the progress with the editor. The editor asked to wait.
Currently, it is still in this status.
Is there still hope?

upup恺恺 2023-01-21

9.25 Submission
10.1 Assistant Editor requests revision
10.18 Editor-in-chief requests revision
11.24 Major revision based on external review comments
12.9 Minor revision by additional reviewer
Around 1.6 Acceptance

erchen125 2023-01-13

Seeking advice, what does "Reviewers received" mean? I haven't seen it before. Does it refer to reviewers receiving the manuscript, or does it mean that some reviewers have already submitted their comments?

SCI期刊审稿人 2022-12-21

The text translates to: "After two months of review, it was still rejected."

letoubhhhs 2022-12-03

May I ask what is your result? I also receive approvals very quickly.

askqsp 2022-11-30

Not yet submitted for review, the editor has already requested two revisions, taking one month. Currently on the second submission, being reviewed by the editor. The first time, the editor took 17 days to evaluate the revision, so I sent an email to urge them, and the reply was normal. It's really... so slow! I'm in a hurry to publish the paper, but it seems far from being cheap!

The one 2022-11-27

Say my review process is normal, and there is one reviewer who hasn't responded. It has been six months already, and I don't know what the situation is. Can't we remind them?

yaoyuan 2022-11-18

Has the submission system been changed? I don't understand the process of changing the submission system for cellulose. The previous submission interface did not have a submission option, so I directly submitted on the homepage. It showed "editor appointed" for over half a month, and suddenly I received an email saying that an editor has been assigned and introduced several journals to choose from. It didn't mention anything about cellulose rejecting the submission. Can someone please help me understand what this means? I hope I didn't encounter an intermediary...

YXT-H 2022-11-13

My submission has been three months, the review process has been two months, and there is still no news now.

Zoen 2022-11-11

Which step are you stuck at? I have been stuck at inviting reviewers for three months. The editor's response is also asking me to wait without providing any useful information.

The one 2022-11-11

I have also submitted for 5 months.

The one 2022-11-11

The submission has been 5 months already. I have sent reminders several times, and the editor replied that everything is normal and asked me to wait.