Dr.Chen、 2023-08-02

I submitted an article in 2021, but it stayed in the hands of the editor for a full two months without being sent for review. I emailed once in the meantime, but received no response. Then, in the third month, I couldn't bear it any longer and withdrew the submission myself. When withdrawing, it was still "with editor". I don't know how the speed is now.

靓仔.. 2023-07-21

Submitted on March 6th, accepted on June 29th, the process was quite fast. The comments provided by both reviewers were very insightful. It can be considered a good journal within the second tier.

草 2023-04-27

The final acceptance of the submission took more than 9 months.

草 2023-04-17

4.5 Submit for repair
4.17 Under review

草 2023-04-04

2023.4.3 Minor maintenance

Flandre021 2023-03-23

Posted on 22.09, the first reviewer completed the review within two months and replied, but there were no further comments afterwards.
On 22.12, an email was sent to the editor, stating that they were unable to find a suitable reviewer.
On 23.01, another email was sent, but they still did not receive enough feedback to make a decision.
On 23.02, minor revisions were finally requested.
On 23.03, the revisions were made and resubmitted for a second review, and half a month later, it was accepted.

lab106 2023-03-21

Some, after the first trial, I replied with opinions and was rejected.

Annie Liu 2023-03-13

May I ask if it is still possible to be rejected during the review stage?

草 2023-03-12

2023-3-1 Submit for repair
2023-3-6 Send for review

弱小 2023-03-08

Mine too, and I haven't been able to find the responsible editor. There has been no progress for several months. I withdrew the manuscript.

zqx 2023-01-29

The manuscript received some comments after more than two months of submission. The revisions were minor, with three reviewers providing feedback. Two reviewers pointed out a few language issues, while one suggested conducting an additional experiment, which was explained as currently impossible to conduct. After revising, it took more than twenty days to receive acceptance. The entire process from submission to acceptance took approximately four months.

Annie Liu 2023-01-18

Once you're blacklisted, the review process is extremely slow. It's already difficult to go through one round of review, and then there's no news from the editor for two months. I can't find the reviewer and they don't even explain anything. Please do not waste your time on this magazine.

wh888 2023-01-04

2023-01-01: Reviewer reports received / Ready for editor's decision

wh888 2022-12-22

Return the repair back to the editor for evaluating the revision, hoping for a good outcome.

wh888 2022-12-09

How long does it take for the reviewer reports to be received / Ready for editor's decision?

草 2022-10-24

90 days after submission, the Editorial Assessment will be changed to "under review."
After 100 days of review, it will be changed to "major revision."

accept D 2022-10-13

How many reviewers are usually invited for external review?

accept D 2022-10-13

May I ask how long it takes to invite reviewers? I have been waiting for over two months, and my submission is currently in the "editor appointed" status.

accept D 2022-10-13

May I ask how long it usually takes to invite reviewers after editors are appointed?

ZL93 2022-09-19

The speed is faster than before, and the requirements for quality and details are quite strict. It went through a total of three reviews back and forth. The questions raised were also very pertinent. After one week of the third review, it was accepted, and the whole process took a total of three months.

我自己 2022-09-12

Did you reject the revision after the major repair?

benc 2022-07-01

I have been reviewing this format for almost a month, and it has been ten days since Editors were invited. I don't know what the situation is.

rainy0804 2022-06-21

Yes, mine is too. It's quite fast. Submitted on 2022/04/24, immediately assigned to an editor after quality control, reviewed after one week, received feedback after three weeks, revised for two weeks, and accepted on 2022/06/21.

猪猪侠111222 2022-06-07

So fast. It took less than 2 months from submission to acceptance.

ZL93 2022-06-05

Excuse me, may I ask how many experts are generally invited for the first external review? Mine only shows that one person has accepted the manuscript for review.

玫瑰牙齿 2022-05-26

It has been 40 days since I submitted, and it is still "Editors invited". Should I remind or not?

羊岸上的旗 2022-04-20

My age is a little over five months. It takes my senior brother a whole year to accept. Please invest cautiously.

羊岸上的旗 2022-04-20

From submission to rejection, it took five months.

yahong123 2022-04-10

Hello, may I ask, "Please provide Funding in the Declaration section." What does this mean? Does it mean to pay?

booooooom 2022-03-05

It has been over 3 months since I submitted it. After the format review, I have been continuously invited by editors. Now it is still "Editors invited". I am convinced.