gkjsl 2023-07-07

A self-indulgent open-source journal, with over 20,000, so the editors are working hard to promote and make money.

JS-UH 2023-06-28

Dozens of articles in a year, can they be called journals? Just playing with IF values? It's better to just publish one article and find a hundred people to apply it, then it will be a hundred, hilarious.

高山流水与 2023-06-24

I also switched my investment, and I need to upload a table of contents. What is this?

是豆豆啊 2023-06-21

Regarding the value of IF (Impact Factor) and the influence it holds, not many people have heard of it. You can take a look at the article above, most of the citations are from reviews, and the research citations are generally below 5. Basically, it is just those few people who keep investing.

gkjsl 2023-06-20

Does he worth 3000 dollars?

是豆豆啊 2023-05-13

4 reviewers, 2 minor revisions, 1 major revision, 1 rejection. The reviewer who rejected it probably didn't read the article carefully and just raised a few simple questions before rejecting it. It's probably someone with a grudge. The editor decided to reject it. I'm too lazy to appeal.

是豆豆啊 2023-05-11

I still don't know, still reviewing.

zjrzjrzjr 2023-05-11

Transfer to AFM, the direction is not very relevant either. How is the review result now, did you get it?

是豆豆啊 2023-05-11

4.19 pending decision and under review coexist until 5.9 when under review disappears, leaving only PD.

是豆豆啊 2023-04-17

Is it really this slow? I've been in the hands of the editor for a week already, and they still haven't made a decision quickly.

是豆豆啊 2023-04-07

I transferred from AFM and when I clicked on it, it turned out to be an invited manuscript. It's a bit strange because it doesn't align with the scope of this journal. I don't know why they asked for this transfer.

yangkls 2022-10-10

I submitted it on July 10th and it has been pending decision and under review... Is it normal to wait for three months?

拉粑粑小魔仙 2022-09-19

Two reviewers, one gave high praise, stating that my work is novel and interesting, and recommended acceptance. The other reviewer believed that my work lacks innovation and listed several papers that had been done before. However, the papers listed were not in the same application area as mine, and the materials were different. Only the methods were slightly similar. I can only say that I'm unlucky. I feel nauseous and upset about being rejected...

笑忘书 2022-09-07

This journal will soon be published as Open Access in January 2023. Starting from August 2022, manuscript submissions will require an Article Processing Charge if they are accepted and published in the journal. For more details on the fees, please click here.

崽崽今天中Nature了么？ 2022-08-16

After experiencing rejections from Angew, EES, and Nanoletters, my advisor decided to try submitting to this journal.
6.9 submitted
7.25 received feedback with two reviewers, one provided 6 comments and the other requested language and grammar optimization, the editor made minor revisions.
7.31 spent 5 days revising and submitting responses to the feedback.
8.01 paper accepted, requested high-resolution images and submitted formal acceptance.
This work started submitting in October 2021 and went through rejections from Angew and EES, and after answering 38 questions from 5 reviewers for Nanoletters, it was rejected. After multiple revisions, it was finally smoothly accepted by EEM. I thought I would be excited when it was accepted, but in reality, I didn't feel any emotions. This work has been tormenting me for over two years, and it finally went out. I originally planned that if EEM rejected it, I would continue conducting experiments, supplementing the experiments, and rewriting this article. Therefore, I only felt a sense of relief in my heart, without any joy.
This is the first article with an impact factor greater than 10 from our group, without any background connections. My advisor said that our work is definitely worthy of better opportunities, but some things cannot be forced. I hope we can strive to produce better work in the future!

小千 2022-08-16

After thinking for a long time, I decided to post the rejection reasons, to help everyone avoid similar mistakes.

Reason: The responses to the questions were good, but the article's topic does not match the theme of this issue of the journal, so I am sorry.

小千 2022-08-11

On August 11, 2022, the second trial lasted for a month, and I waited anxiously. Finally, today, on a plain and ordinary morning, I received the final result, a rejection. It took five months, and I feel saddened.

小千 2022-07-26

Under review... However, it is indeed a bit slow. It takes about a month, so please be patient.

171 2022-07-20

Post submitted on 28th May 2022.
A few days later, it became pending decision.
It has been ongoing until now, almost two months without any progress. Are there any others in a similar situation? o(╥﹏╥)o

xxm1995 2022-07-18

2022.5.22 Submitted
Approximately one week later, it shows "Under review" and "Pending decision" at the same time (not sure why it's like this...). EIC: Silva, S. Ravi P. ADM: Editorial Office, EEM. This status remains until the decision is made.
2022.6.16 Major revision (I had to remind them twice due to the strange submission status, but didn't receive any reply)
2022.6.27 Re-submitted (Reviewer's comments were good, only minor issues, so I submitted quickly)
Approximately one week later, it shows "Under review" and "Pending decision" again.
2022.7.18 Accepted

I have been working on a new direction for a long time, and it has been a year full of ups and downs in the submission process. I can only express my gratitude to EEM and hope it continues to thrive.

小千 2022-07-15

2022.3.8 Submission
Approximately within a week, under review, I can't remember clearly.
2022.4.6 First round of comments returned, extensive revisions, given 2 months. There was an outbreak in between, which extended it by 2 months.
2022.7.9 Revised.
2022.7.13 Under review (changed to editor-in-chief's review)

I'm a bit anxious, does this situation mean that it needs to be sent for a second review by the reviewers?

Tianyi Gao 2022-06-22

Last month, the manuscript I submitted to AFM was rejected, and it was suggested to submit it to this journal instead. We agreed and went ahead. However, upon checking, we found that the status was "invited manuscript." One week later, it was rejected.

LiuWu0603 2022-06-08

Is there any supporting information in the proof generated after submission? I didn't see it after generating it.

Reborn 2022-05-28

2022-03-10 Submission
After about a week, the system showed "under review."
2022-04-06 Editor returned with reviewer's comments, both minor revisions. Editor provided two months for revisions.
2022-05-01 Submitted revised manuscript.
2022-05-13 Official acceptance.
Background of submission: The first author and corresponding author are not renowned experts, and their institution is not a prestigious platform like 985 or 211. This is the first time submitting to EEM.
Initially, this article was submitted to AFM, but it was rejected on the same day, possibly due to the platform not being well-regarded. Then, I decided to try EEM, and unexpectedly, it was sent for review.
Dr. Xu Kang, the associate editor handling my manuscript, is a renowned expert in my field. The chosen reviewers were also very professional. I appreciate the hard work of the associate editor and reviewers.

ZZZZZR 2022-05-22

2022.2.18 submitted
2022.2.22 under review
2022.3.27 major revision
2022.4.30 resubmitted
2022.5.19 accepted

ke_long 2022-05-17

Same question, do we need a layout fee?

123456789112 2022-05-14

The neighboring group's submission one also did not pass the review and was rejected after a week, still requiring 15%. Haha. They are trying their luck by submitting to AFM, it's ridiculous.

123456789112 2022-05-14

The submission is not reviewed and rejected after 8 days, as long as 15% haha, the relationship-oriented articles are casually submitted, it's okay to stop, never submit again, once the impact factor exceeds 10 in the first year, it will be popular, and it will exceed 10 again in the third year.

ZZZZZR 2022-05-13

Hello, may I ask how long it takes to receive news after submitting a revised manuscript? Looking forward to your reply. Thank you very much.

chong10啊 2022-05-13

Is there a page fee?