薛点点 2023-07-06

After submission, the first month had one reviewer who provided feedback. I continued to wait for responses from other reviewers. In the meantime, the journal asked me to recommend reviewers, and I did. After three months passed without finding a reviewer, they rejected my submission, claiming it did not meet the requirements. It's truly absurd that they couldn't find a reviewer for such a long time and instead claimed my article didn't meet the submission requirements. They should have stated that it didn't meet the requirements from the beginning. They wasted four months of my time, which is very irresponsible. I advise being cautious when submitting articles.

渢 2023-05-19

How long after the article is published online can it be seen in print?

十年后的我gxy 2023-04-06

1. Posted on December 1st; Interactive review opened on March 2nd; Only Reviewer 1 provided comments when it was opened on March 2nd. It took two weeks to reply to Reviewer 1, addressing very detailed issues including grammar problems in writing and some research mechanism aspects.
2. On March 19th, Reviewer 2 submitted comments regarding some statistical methods issues. It took one week for major revisions.
3. On March 20th, Reviewer 3 submitted comments with a lower score but addressing some issues related to the research design itself.
After one round of revisions, all reviewers agreed to accept the paper. The editor was very fast in their work, constantly urging for the manuscript and was very responsible. Acceptance was received on April 5th.

荷兰翘摇 2023-03-20

Revisions will only be made after three months of submission.
Three reviewers: one major revision, one approval, one rejection.
Following the reviewers' suggestions, a positive control and in vivo experiment were conducted. Even the suggestions made by the reviewer who rejected it were fully addressed and additional experiments were conducted as requested.
In the end, the paper was directly rejected, stating that it did not comply with the journal's guidelines.
All the time and effort spent in the five months turned out to be in vain.

药房民工 2023-01-28

May I ask if WB needs to provide the unedited original images?

IF>5 2022-12-14

Submitted on October 23rd;
Reviewed and submitted on November 2nd;
Reviewer 2 returned with comments on November 9th, requiring major revisions before publication;
Reviewer 1 returned with comments on November 18th, requiring minor revisions before direct publication. (Both reviewers provided feedback)
Modified manuscript uploaded on November 28th;
Received acceptance email notification on December 6th.
Overall, individuals nearing graduation or with a need to meet award evaluation requirements can give it a try. However, if the sole purpose is to publish in a reputable journal, careful consideration is advised.

IF>5 2022-12-02

May I ask how long it usually takes for the editor to process the revised manuscript after submission? It has been a week since I submitted my revised manuscript, and there has been no response from the editor.

TaoTao1998 2022-11-30

What district is it? Chinese Academy of Sciences is only in the second district, and even the subcategories are in the third district. I feel that the quality is not consistent. Unless necessary, I will not submit articles to Frontier magazine.

IF>5 2022-11-04

May I ask how long it usually takes for the independent review to be completed? How many reviewers are involved? Thank you.

Lei.Wo 2022-09-29

After submitting, I received an immediate response.
After a public discussion and review, both reviewers are professors from top universities and very professional.
One reviewer approved directly, while the other provided many reviews.
After making two revisions, it was approved the next day.

源源 2022-08-24

I would like to inquire about some information regarding your submission.

如圭如璋 2022-08-05

The speed is fast, and the two reviewers are particularly professional.
One major revision and one minor revision went smoothly.
It has become a district.

石头 2022-05-12

First review took two months, major repair took one month, minor repair took one month, and the equipment was accepted after 5 days of minor repair.

孟 2022-03-15

My submission has two reviewers.

626955357 2022-03-13

How many reviewers are there in total? Thank you.

Dr. wangm 2022-03-06

The review comments did not come back at the same time, it took about a month in between.

626955357 2022-03-04

May I ask how long does it usually take for the Independent Review to finish after it starts? How many reviewers are there? Thank you.

626955357 2022-03-04

May I ask how long does it generally take for the review to be completed after the Independent Review has started?

Dr. wangm 2022-03-03

Fast speed, short cycle, more reviewers.

听时光飞舞 2022-02-27

Posted on August 14th, major revision on November 26th, accepted on December 13th, the process was fast, and it felt okay. However, the quality of the article needs to be improved.

黑色creation 2022-01-24

Typically, there are three reviewers. If they do not respond promptly, you can send a message to the editor to remind them.

大月 2022-01-20

It has been over half a month since submission, why is there no news? Should I write an email to the editor to inquire?

super辉 2021-12-25

Where can I upload the response to the reviewer's comments?

super辉 2021-12-25

Where can I upload my response to the reviewer's comments, please?

super辉 2021-12-25

Where should I upload the response to the reviewer's comments? There is no place to upload the response to the reviewer's comments in the area where I uploaded the revised manuscript.

阿Ye 2021-12-22

I would like to know how many reviewers were involved in the review process at the time and how long it took from submission to acceptance.

阿烨烨 2021-12-21

Buddy, I want to ask you about the process of submitting this. How many months does it take for major revisions and how many months for minor revisions? I submitted it four months ago and just finished major revisions when suddenly another reviewer was added. I'm a bit worried as it has been more than a month with no news.

黑色creation 2021-12-20

It has become District 1, really fragrant.

deng 2021-11-19

May I ask how much is the layout fee?

cpucnd 2021-09-27

The speed is quite fast, but the cost is too expensive, a bit unbearable.