几多愁 2023-07-30

Hello, has the OP's status changed? I also transferred from ASS and just entered the "with editor" status.

辰光微凉 2023-07-05

May I ask what is the current status?

辰光微凉 2023-07-05

May I ask, what is the current status?

ocean欧 2023-06-10

My paper has also been reassigned, so I'm wondering if yours has been accepted?

gaga121 2023-05-20

2023.05.18 submitted to journal
2023.05.20 with editor

一叶周周 2023-05-19

Jul 22, 2022投 - Invest on July 22, 2022
May 19, 2023录 - Record on May 19, 2023
不会再投 - Will not invest again

yellowvase 2023-05-08

Maybe it is because the topic I am researching is relatively niche, the editor spent a lot of time finding reviewers. The questions raised by the reviewers were quite professional, and when I first saw them, I was almost overwhelmed. After calming down for a few days, I started to work on the revisions and discovered that the professional reviewers were indeed looking at the problem from the perspective of improving the paper. The recommended reference materials also broadened my horizons. After I revised the paper on time, the editor accepted it directly within 2 days! Once again, I would like to thank Editor Mircea Chipara.

名扬天下 2023-05-03

On May 3rd, 2023, still in contact with the editor, planning to withdraw the manuscript.

糖糖糖123456 2023-04-25

Posted in December 2021, it took 1 year and 5 months, and finally accepted on April 25, 2023. I probably won't consider this journal again in the future, it's just too slow.

名扬天下 2023-04-19

Hello, may I ask how long did it take for you to submit for review with the editor? I transferred my ass, and it has been over a month with the editor. It's too slow.

名扬天下 2023-04-19

Hello, may I ask how long ago did you submit your paper to the editor for review? I transferred to this journal and it has been over a month with the editor. I want to withdraw my submission now, as it is too slow.

Strive! 2023-04-19

I have also been waiting for 9 months. Xiao Xiu returned 3 months ago and started looking for reviewers again. Speechless.

糖糖糖123456 2023-04-18

In December 2021, submission was made.
On February 28, 2023, there was a major revision, and there were 2 or 3 reminders during this period.
Returned on March 5, 2023.
On April 18, 2023, there was no response, so due to the urgency of graduation, it is planned to send a reminder.

名扬天下 2023-04-10

What is the current situation?

名扬天下 2023-04-10

2023.3.16 switched to ass,
2023.3.17 with editor
2023.4.10 still with editor

Strive 2023-01-28

I have also been in the initial review for nearly half a year. I have reminded them once every three months, and they said they have assigned 10 reviewers. After another three months, I reminded them again, and the editor said they would handle it immediately. However, only one reviewer's opinion was received, and in the end, there was only minor revision. It was also a surprise.

磁电子小组 2023-01-21

I helped review manuscripts for this journal because it only provides reviewers with a 14-day review period, which is quite fast! After all, I have reviewed more than 20 different journals, and it is not common for them to have a 14-day review period. So I submitted an article as well, but it has been five months and I still haven't received the first review. I sent a reminder halfway through, and they only replied that some of the review comments have not yet been returned, and only one review comment has been received so far. I am extremely frustrated... Does it really take half a year for the first review to come back? Based on others' comments, the speed of the first review for this journal varies. For those who value speed, I advise taking a detour...

tyhtyh 2023-01-19

Submit quickly! Finally going to graduate!

小菜青虫 2023-01-07

What happened to the author of the post later on?

Justin123 2023-01-05

10, shocked.

小菜青虫 2022-12-28

Hello, may I ask what happened afterwards? Was the manuscript withdrawn?

阿里山 2022-12-20

Received at Editorial Office: 7th June 2022
Under Review: 8th July 2022
Article revised: 7th December 2022
Article accepted for publication: 19th December 2022
This journal is relatively slow, but be patient and there will be good results. Good luck to everyone!

Strive 2022-12-12

On the same day of application, it is still under review as of December 12, 2022. It's too slow.

中环古天乐 2022-12-02

May I ask if it has been received now?

中环古天乐 2022-12-02

The submission has been under review for over three months, and I'm not sure if I should remind them about it.

向ss 2022-11-24

The first submission took three hours to be received. The speed was not fast, but it was acceptable.
The second submission was reviewed in less than a month for the first review, which was fast. However, it has been five months since the second review, and there was one reminder sent during this time, stating that one reviewer's comments had returned but they were still waiting for another reviewer. Many online comments mention the slow speed, which indeed seems to depend on the speed of the reviewers. I am curious as to why this journal has chosen slow reviewers, as reviewers for other journals are usually fast. What could be the problem?

Strive 2022-11-05

Oct 29, 2022 under review - The first review is too slow. It has been over three months already. I sent an email to urge them, and they replied saying they have assigned it to 10 reviewers. Can't believe it.

Strive 2022-11-05

Oct 29, 2022 Under Review The first review is too slow, it has been over three months. I sent an email to urge them, and they replied saying that they have sent it to 10 reviewers. It's frustrating.

Fiona 2022-10-19

Experience of Submission:
22.06.06 submitted
22.08.13 major revision
22.08.30 accept

张同学要发Nature 2022-10-15

22.08.18 submitted
22.08.20 with editor
22.08.22 under review
22.09.16 major revision
22.09.30 accept

Translation:
22.08.18 submitted
22.08.20 with editor
22.08.22 under review
22.09.16 major revision
22.09.30 accept