淅沥沥 2023-05-12

10.22 submission
10.22 with editor, reminded once after 2 months
01.23 under review, minor revisions, returned in two weeks
02.23 reject, no reasons given. Truly a divine publication.

luting 2023-05-04

After the third minor repair, acceptance.

luting 2023-03-15

2022.05 Submission
2022.09 Major revision
2022.11 Minor revision, completed in two weeks and returned
2022.12 Reviewer's comments returned, but status still under review
2023.03 Still under review, which means the editor hasn't looked at it for such a long time
What should I do? Should I remind them?

jackjjay 2023-02-25

What's happening now? It's been three months with my editor.

jackjjay 2023-02-25

What is the current outcome? Is it still with the editor?

good1 2022-11-12

May I ask how many reviewers are you?

liuyang0495 2022-11-10

I had a smooth submission. The reviewers only asked for modifications in terms of formatting and captions, there were no other issues.

loafer 2022-11-05

Really amazing magazine. After submitting, it has been with the editor all along. I have followed up twice, but there hasn't been much progress. After 6 months, they rejected it directly, saying it doesn't fit within the journal's scope. I'm just speechless.

Tank q 2022-09-27

It has been three and a half months with the editor, too slow.

苏苏 2022-09-14

After 7 months, I finally accepted it.

苏苏 2022-08-05

I have been back from my study abroad for almost three months now, and there is still no news about the next step. I'm getting really anxious.

屮人屮 2022-05-27

It has been a month and a half with no news.

jnas 2022-04-27

How is it now, mine too. It has been with the editor for over a month.

南翼维意 2022-04-22

2022.04.12 Submission with editor
4 days after 2022.04.14 Under review
2022.04.18 Current status changed to with editor (but status date remains the same)
What does this situation mean? Confused

Cell King 2022-04-20

It has been one and a half months with the editor. Mentally exhausted.

苏苏 2022-03-22

3.22 Finally submitted for review today, waited for 8 weeks.

苏苏 2022-03-20

It has been almost two months and still with the editor. If there is no news next week, I will withdraw the submission directly.

jnas 2022-03-16

How are things? Any news?

苏苏 2022-02-27

How long is this going to take? CCR transferred over here, it has already been a month, and it's still with the editor. I'm getting frustrated.

DundeeKang 2022-02-22

I have not received any news since I submitted it a month ago... This journal is quite slow.

fengye008 2022-02-20

This journal is very magical, it's hard to evaluate. I had a smooth submission process, although it was a bit slow, and it feels different from most people's experiences!

oolili 2021-02-21

After one month with the editor, the manuscript was rejected for not fitting within the scope of the journal. It is suggested to use Elsevier's SCIFinder to find relevant journals... I actually used that and found this journal. It's fine if it's slow, but it's a bit frustrating!

狂风暴雨 2021-02-18

One month after submission, it is still "with editor". After urging for progress, it was rejected immediately. The reason: it is not within the scope of the journal. Be cautious when submitting to this journal.

oolili 2021-02-08

Really slow,,, be cautious before submitting!!! I found this journal by searching on the SCIFinder website from Elsevier, and after submitting, it has been stuck at "With editor" for a long time. It's really frustrating.