z-12 2023-04-11

The author's status is rarely shown, and the journal is very slow. It takes two months for the first review, so we have to wait patiently. Requesting for updates may result in direct rejection. The journal follows a high-quality route, only accepting around a hundred articles each year. Most articles are rejected during the pre-check stage, so those that make it to the peer review stage are considered lucky.

杰拉德 2023-03-09

15 days after submission, it shows "Under consideration" and I have received the email for review. However, the status of reviewer zip has not been displayed. I feel like there are too few people submitting to this journal, and there is not enough information for everyone to reference.
--
It was faster than expected. The questions raised by the reviewers were also very helpful in improving the quality of the article.
March 18, 2023 - Major revision
June 6, 2023 - Minor revision
June 13, 2023 - Expected acceptance

qqlaykin 2022-09-19

Excuse me, has your article started being reviewed? How long have you been waiting so far?

paper+1 2022-08-22

Excuse me, is this journal by invitation only or open for submission?

earthresearch 2022-07-23

Check if there is a Reviewer Zip File in Manuscript Items. If there is, it means it is ready for review.

Julia_Zhu 2022-07-22

May I ask if the status "manuscript under consideration" means that the paper has been sent for review? It has been 51 days since my manuscript has been under consideration... Does this mean it has been sent for review?

nmg 2022-04-20

The submission has been almost a month, and so far it is still under consideration. Is this magazine always this slow?