Verified Reviews - Frontiers in Physics
Note: Verified reviews are sourced from across review platforms and social media globally.

向子轩 2023-05-15

Posted on May 2nd;
On May 3rd, the editing tasks were assigned;
As of May 15th, it is still in the hands of the editor and has not been assigned to a reviewer. The efficiency is not very high, and it feels like it will affect graduation.

keyanjiayou888 2023-04-30

What's the matter with not updating in April?

howfar 2023-04-27

Hired in March, but suddenly in April the system stopped accepting submissions, causing fear and trembling.

论文算个屁 2022-09-24

Traducción al inglés:

Received: July 20, 2021
Accepted: August 17, 2021
Published: September 3, 2021

syjjsy 2022-07-26

The speed is fast, and the reviewers are very professional.

yangzihuizi 2022-04-10

The article submitted on April 1st is still in the hands of the editor on April 10th, and I am feeling very anxious.

yangzihuizi 2022-04-10

Posted on April 1st, still editing on April 10th, anxious.

josieyjs 2022-01-20

May I ask how you are doing now? After my three reviewers have all agreed, I have been waiting for ten days, and I am feeling very anxious...

乃涛 2022-01-18

There were a total of five reviewers, with a total of more than 20 comments. Overall, the review comments were relatively mild, indicating that the reviewers may have felt that the journal's standards were not high. However, it is indeed challenging to reply to 20 comments from five reviewers within seven days. I hope the journal will continue to improve and increase its impact factor.

乃涛 2022-01-12

2021.12.31 Submission
2022.1.07 Reviewer 1 Review Report
2022.1.08 Reviewer 2 Review Report
2022.1.12 Reviewer 3 Review Report

This is too fast. The questions raised are manageable, and only Reviewer 2 feels that the novelty is not very good, but still supports publication.
Currently, all three review comments have been received, but the system still requires all review comments to be returned in order to modify the article. Do we need more reviewers?

caicai6 2022-01-05

The reviewer is very professional, probably an expert. The questions raised are somewhat tricky, but the fee for the short article is acceptable.

微信用户 2021-12-25

The speed is fast, and after one month of submission, it was modified and accepted.

Publish scientific posters with Peeref

Peeref publishes scientific posters from all research disciplines. Our Diamond Open Access policy means free access to content and no publication fees for authors.

Learn More

Become a Peeref-certified reviewer

The Peeref Institute provides free reviewer training that teaches the core competencies of the academic peer review process.

Get Started