Jack 2023-02-03

The speed is still quite slow. After undergoing two major repairs, it was submitted on June 22, 2022, and accepted on February 3, 2023. Overall, as long as you carefully revise and respond, there should be no problem.

四夕99 2022-07-11

2022.07.10: Required Reviews Completed

liuyaya 2022-07-11

My today is under review.

tomatoxiao666 2022-07-09

May I ask, what is the ranking of this journal when applying for Sunbet? I saw that the latest ranking for 2022 is Zone 1. I find it hard to believe.

柚子99 2022-07-07

Brother, have you made any progress?

liuyaya 2022-06-28

May I ask what is your current status? I submitted my work around the same time as you, but I have been "with editor" all this time.

四夕99 2022-06-10

2022.06.10 under review translates to "Under review as of June 10, 2022" in English.

四夕99 2022-06-09

2022.06.08 with editor

May good luck be with you.

MCCREEZ 2021-12-03

9.16 Post
10.25 Minor Repair
11.13 Return
11.20 Receive
The speed is very fast, just in time for the Ph.D. registration.

yangketong 2021-10-20

The first submission was rejected without specifying the reason for rejection, so I wrote a letter to the editor-in-chief. The editor-in-chief stated that the theme is about ecological protection, and the paper's topic is unrelated to it.
Then I revised the introduction and cover letter and resubmitted.
There were a total of 4 reviewers, with 3 of them providing opinions ranging from 10 to 15 points, and 1 reviewer providing only 1 opinion. After making minor revisions, the paper was accepted.
It took 2 months from submission to acceptance, and the publication was made 1 month after acceptance.

liueb 2021-09-26

After the major renovation, the required reviews have been completed. It has been half a month and there is still no news. I don't know what the situation is.

liueb 2021-09-26

It has been half a month and still no news, I wonder what the situation is?

大海无垠 2021-08-11

Just been hired, may I ask how to pay the layout fee?

大海无垠 2021-08-11

Two reviewers, quite fast, but the fees are quite high.

wuyinzhang 2021-07-08

The work efficiency is very high. The submission was under review on the second day. The first review took 30 days, followed by major revisions. The second review took 20 days, followed by minor revisions. After the revisions were completed, the submission was accepted the next day. From the initial submission to acceptance, including the time spent on personal revisions, it took a total of 3 months. The reviewers provided valuable suggestions that greatly improved the article. The article has just been published, and the impact factor has increased to 3.38. Haha, I hope it continues to improve. Best wishes!

双人鱼 2021-07-06

Submitted to journal on 2020/11/11.
Major revision on 2021/4/07.
Accepted on 2021/7/05.
The editing efficiency is high. The second reviewer may not have a particularly strong interest in this article, as their comments were relatively simple. However, the first reviewer had a detailed review and provided many specific modifications. It was a pleasant submission experience.

赶路的人 2021-06-25

May I ask if all authors need to confirm their submission through email before it is considered successful?

赶路的人 2021-06-25

May I ask, do all authors need to confirm submission success through the sent software?

lihu8918 2021-04-22

The editor's work efficiency is very high, and the comments provided by the reviewers are very detailed and insightful. After making serious revisions, the paper was accepted for publication. I hope the journal will continue to develop better and have a pleasant submission experience.

shinelma 2021-04-10

The first review was quick, just in time for about a month and a half before Christmas. The suggestions given by the editor were very specific, so I made a major revision and thought there would still be minor changes required. However, unexpectedly, it was accepted directly. I need to respond to the reviewer's comments seriously.

yunzhang 2021-02-09

I would like to consult about my article. It says "minor revision," but I didn't see any reviewer comments in the email or the view letter, and there is no attachment on the left side. Where did you find the reviewer comments?

yunzhang 2021-02-09

Excuse me, my article was mentioned to be given minor revision, but I did not see any comments in the email or view letter, nor did I see any attachments on the left side. Where did you find your review comments?

kjmooo 2021-01-18

I am on the 11th floor. Submitted on July 27th, accepted on January 18th. It went through major revisions, minor revisions, and the reviewers are truly rigorous!