心心安安 2023-07-26

Basking in the host's good fortune.

coconutt 2023-07-07

March submission
May major overhaul
July acceptance

心心安安 2023-07-06

Come and share the joy with the host.

xtdqe 2023-07-01

First submission, the editor held it for 52 days and rejected it without review. Second submission, it has been with the editor for 24 days. Are all domestic journals like this? Is it just for the entertainment of the Chinese people? I really won't consider it in the future, I'm not afraid of rejection, I'm really afraid of dragging it out!

lvw 2023-06-24

After the first round of revisions, the article was accepted. The whole process took about a month, and this submission went very smoothly! Wishing PR Magazine continued success!

lvw 2023-06-10

Peer Review: May 25, 2023
Assign Editor: May 25, 2023
Editor Assigned: May 25, 2023
Editorial Review: May 24, 2023
Editorial Review Approved: May 25, 2023
Quality Check: May 23, 2023
Quality Check Passed: May 24, 2023

xtdqe 2023-06-08

I vomited. Submitted on May 4th, it is now June 8th and still in the editorial review stage. Why is there such a big gap?

Harkoon 2023-06-07

Why does your editorial review only take one day?

cchengg 2023-06-07

Rereview Decision 21 July 2023 21 July 2023 Manuscript Accepted
Rereview 17 July 2023 21 July 2023 Rereview Complete
Final Manuscript Decision 16 July 2023 17 July 2023 Repeat Review
Author Revision 03 July 2023 16 July 2023 Author Revisions Complete
Preproduction Review 30 June 2023 03 July 2023 Author Revisiond
First Manuscript Decision 30 June 2023 30 June 2023 Major Revisions Required
Peer Review 01 June 2023 30 June 2023 Peer Review Complete
Editorial Review 01 June 2023 01 June 2023 Editorial Review Approved

Harkoon 2023-06-01

How long does the Editorial Review take? It has been 21 days already.

coconutt 2023-05-18

I feel it's difficult by two orders of magnitude. The difference between Zone 1 and Zone 2 is qualitative.

噜噜噜1 2023-04-06

The editor has added another reviewer and is already in the review process.

zhenysu 2023-04-04

I am in the same situation too.

噜噜噜1 2023-03-30

Does anyone know what to do if the reviewer has not agreed to review the manuscript after entering Peer Review? Reviewer 1 and 2 have been in the "Waiting" status for a long time, and the time has also exceeded the due date.

雷乐 2022-12-29

Don't worry, the Chinese Academy of Sciences' division can be nominated.

CQUCYL 2022-12-21

Editorial Review 7 days, first review 17 days, revisions 10 days, editor acceptance after 4 days of resubmission. This is the smoothest submission so far, lucky enough to have an editor who is a big name in the field, and the reviewers encountered are also experts in the same field. They clearly pointed out the innovativeness of the research work and the shortcomings in the organization of the manuscript, providing very constructive feedback that truly helped improve the quality of the article.

Jxiaoqi 2022-10-24

After being rejected by the editor for over 6 weeks without being sent for review, I have decided to switch to OE, which no longer accepts journals under OSA. All OSA journals are now out of the picture, so those in a hurry to submit should choose carefully. Consider carefully before submitting to OSA journals such as OE and OL.

NJ120 2022-10-13

About a month? Look at the comments below.
What is the current status of the original poster?

ALon 2022-10-12

Hello, may I ask if it is still in the editorial review? I would like to know how long it will take to proceed to the next step.

NJ120 2022-10-11

How much is the page fee needed?

xrzh 2022-09-26

It has been nearly a month at the editorial review, and there hasn't been any news. Should I send an email to inquire, or should I continue waiting? Can anyone give me some advice?

liuweibboy 2022-09-23

Sincerely ask, how many levels harder is PR compared to OL?

niu 2022-07-10

With the emergence of new domestic journals, Shanghai Institute of Optics and Fine Mechanics' flagship journal AP, West Lake University's Photonix, and Chengdu Institute of Optics and Electronics' OEA, it is estimated that new optical journals will be established in the future. Will this lead to a downgrade to the second tier of the Chinese Academy of Sciences?

sosophia 2022-07-05

submit Manuscript 2022/0411 - Submitted manuscript on April 11, 2022
Quality Check 2022/04/14 - Quality check completed on April 14, 2022
Editorial Review 2022/04/14-2022/05/05 - Editorial review conducted from April 14 to May 5, 2022
Assign Editor 2022/05/05 - Editor assigned on May 5, 2022
Peer Review 2022/05/05-2022/06/01 - Peer review conducted from May 5 to June 1, 2022
First Manuscript Decision 20220601 Major Revision - Initial decision on the manuscript made on June 1, 2022, requiring major revisions
Rereview 20220614-2022-06-29 - Re-review conducted from June 14 to June 29, 2022
Final Preproduction Review 2022-06-29 Production - Final preproduction review conducted on June 29, 2022, ready for production.

光学大白 2022-07-05

The first review took 2 months, the editorial review time is so long... There were three reviewers, and after the response, the second review was accepted within a week.

恒河沙粒 2022-06-14

Classmate, I would like to ask how long the editorial review status will last before it can be submitted for review?

恒河沙粒 2022-06-14

Classmate, I would like to ask how long the editorial review status usually lasts. It has been in this state continuously.

PHYS 2022-06-13

The review process is too slow, the reviewers' expertise is also average, and the suggested comments are not very professional. No wonder it is said to be a domestic journal of self-entertainment in the field of optics, with low international recognition and far less reputation than OL and OE. However, it is at least considered a first-tier journal.

恒河沙粒 2022-06-09

Just want to ask everyone, how long does the Editorial Review usually take to yield results? It has been over a week and there has been no change.

tiantina 2021-10-02

I am planning to submit a paper related to sensors. May I ask which section of this journal you are submitting to?