不知何去何从 2023-08-05

2023.1.12 First submission - (Initial review 39 days) - 2.21 Received initial review comments, major revisions were requested, mainly related to literature review and results analysis.
2023.3.12 Resubmission - (Second review 70 days) - 5.22 Received second review comments, major revisions were requested on a few minor points.
2023.5.23 Third submission - (Third review 68 days) - 7.30 Accepted!!!
Total time taken: 6 months and 18 days.
Average review cycle per submission: 2 months.

xuhaorannn 2023-07-19

Just submitted the revised manuscript, the status instantly changed to "with editor".

爱祖国 2023-07-18

Is it that they couldn't find a reviewer for the first review, or that they couldn't find a reviewer for the second review?

又被拒稿啦！ 2023-07-18

I submitted it since August last year, but still haven't found a reviewer until now. I have already sent four reminders.

xuhaorannn 2023-07-14

Deputy Editor Kerstin Eriksson

爱祖国 2023-07-03

May I ask which editor handled it?

xuhaorannn 2023-07-03

On the afternoon of July 2nd, while in a meeting, I suddenly received an email with the subject "Major Revision". I opened it and looked at the comments from the two reviewers, which were both very positive. Reviewer 1 hardly made any suggestions and approved all the work. Reviewer 2 provided some suggestions regarding the introduction and outlook sections, which were very helpful. The rest were just grammar and expression issues. I feel fortunate to have encountered two excellent reviewers. It was a great experience for my first English submission.

爱祖国 2023-06-20

Tomorrow will be exactly eight months, it's so slow. Please give the child an acceptance. We followed up on it the week before last, but there hasn't been any response. Sigh.

xuhaorannn 2023-06-19

I just logged into the system and checked. The date has been updated to June 18th, but the status is still "under review". Maybe the editor is still considering the reviewer's comments...

xuhaorannn 2023-06-15

April 27th: submitted to journal
April 28th: with editor
May 14th: under review
Currently, the review tracking link shows that two reviewers have completed the review, and we are still waiting...

睡觉小动物 2023-06-15

2023-5-11 Posted
2023-5-18 Under Editing
2023-6-15 Still Under Editing (Waiting and waiting and waiting)

HNU_GD 2023-06-03

It has been a week since I started with the editor. During this time, the time with the editor has changed once, but it is still with the editor.

爱祖国 2023-06-01

May I ask how many months have you been urging for the manuscript? I haven't received any updates for 3 months now. Can I urge for the manuscript?

佛系小赵 2023-05-05

2023.2.8 major revision - 2023.4.7 return

进击的学术者 2023-04-20

During this period, despite numerous reminders, it was of no use.

进击的学术者 2023-04-20

2022-06-12 Posted
2022-08-01 Under review
2023-01-03 Major revision
2023-02-07 Returned for revisions to the journal
2023-03-22 Minor revision
2023-03-27 Returned for revisions to the journal
2023-04-18 Accepted

爱祖国 2023-04-08

May I ask which editor handled it?

ysll 2023-04-08

City Flooding,
Submitted on April 15, 2022.
Major renovation in September 2022.
Returned for revision on November 19, 2022.
Under review since November 24, 2022.

没头发的小男孩 2023-04-07

Ali Asgary

爱祖国 2023-04-05

Brother, you have submitted another article.

爱祖国 2023-04-05

May I ask, which editor are you?

吃鱼 2023-04-01

May I ask how long it took for your manuscript to go from "under review" with the editor?

没头发的小男孩 2023-04-01

09.13 with editor - This indicates that the text was reviewed by an editor on September 13th.
01.13 Major revision - This means that a significant change or update was made on January 13th.
03.23 Minor revision - This suggests that a small modification or adjustment was made on March 23rd.
03.28 accept - This signifies that the text was accepted or approved on March 28th.

chenhao112 2023-03-30

03.24 submitted to journal - This means that a document or article was sent to a journal for consideration or publication on March 24th.
03.25 with editor - This indicates that the document or article is currently being reviewed or processed by the editor as of March 25th.
03.29 with editor - This indicates that the document or article is still being reviewed or processed by the editor as of March 29th.

吃鱼 2023-03-23

It seems that no recommendation reviewer has been filled in.

chenhao112 2023-03-23

Hello, may I ask if you have the option of filling in the recommended reviewer for your submission?

吃鱼 2023-03-23

2023.03.23 Still with editor

Erin_Cloud 2023-03-21

The submission system has recently encountered some issues. It takes at least twenty minutes to generate a PDF.

爱祖国 2023-03-20

Normal, the time has changed for the deputy editor.

吃鱼 2023-03-10

Hello, congratulations on the acceptance! I would like to ask how long it usually takes for "under review." Currently, the status is "with editor" for twelve days. I'm not sure if they are still looking for reviewers or if the editor hasn't reviewed it yet.