右手思念 2022-09-19

Hello, may I ask what is your current status? I also encountered the situation of being "With editor" again, 5 days after peer review. It has been two days now without any changes.

右手思念 2022-09-19

Thank you! My paper "With editor" was in peer review the next day. After 5 days, it was "With editor" again. It has been two days already, and I am anxiously waiting, not knowing what the situation is. Unfortunately, due to a power outage during the holiday, we couldn't conduct any experiments.

Jarvis Pro 2022-09-18

9.6 MANUSCRIPT SUBMITTED
9.8 WITH EDITORIAL OFFICE
9.9 WITH EDITOR
9.13 WITH EDITORIAL OFFICE
9.18 No changes so far
What does it mean when the manuscript is returned from the editor to the editorial office? If they want to reject the submission, can't the editor directly reject it?

Adam James 2022-09-16

rechazar sin revisión por pares

Chamsion 2022-09-15

08.02 with editor - The article was sent to the editor for review on August 2nd.
08.09 in peer review - The article was under peer review on August 9th.
09.05 major revision两小修，编辑给大修 - On September 5th, major revisions were requested by the editor.
09.13 submitted - The revised article was submitted on September 13th.
09.14 accept - The article was accepted on September 14th.

米兰的小铁匠 2022-09-14

It seems that I only saw the comments from the reviewer after they came back.

右手思念 2022-09-14

Hello, may I ask how you found out which editor is in charge? I have been waiting for 9 days for my submission, and the current status is "In peer review." However, besides the initial system email, I haven't received any other emails. This is my second submission to JMCa, and I really like this journal, so I'm feeling a bit anxious.

Adam xiao 2022-09-13

9.9 submitted
9.13 with editor

Levanter 2022-09-05

8.2 Two reviewers provided minor revisions, and the editor requested major revisions.
8.18 Submitted revised manuscript.
8.19 In peer review.

Levanter 2022-09-05

8.2 Two editors gave minor revisions, but the editor gave major revisions.
8.18 Submitted revised draft.
8.19 In peer review.

ximi 2022-09-02

8.30 Submission, format check, preliminary review
9.2 Preliminary review
Wishing good luck

abzhoeey 2022-09-01

It has been 26 days, and I am still with the editor. Both articles are like this, one is an A and the other is a C.

we000000 2022-08-30

8.20 with editor,
8.27 in peer review. It should have gone to arbitration.

Accept！！ 2022-08-22

It took two months, and on August 22, 2022, it was accepted! There were a total of two reviewers. They were very professional, and the journal's requirements were very high, even more difficult to submit than CEJ, but the quality was also high.

we000000 2022-08-15

August 13th in peer review.

kangrongkai 2022-08-15

7-22 submitted means that something was submitted on July 22nd.
8-1 in peer review means that something entered the peer review process on August 1st.

尼古拉斯万奇 2022-08-13

6.23 submitted - Submitted
注意投稿系统有文件大小限制（70MB左右），导致PDF生成一直不对。修改文件大小后，才顺利上传。- Note that there is a file size limit (around 70MB) in the submission system, which caused issues with PDF generation. After adjusting the file size, it was successfully uploaded.

6.24 initial assessment - Initial assessment

6.28 with editor - Under review by the editor

7.1 in peer review - In peer review

7.13 a major revision 两个审稿人，都是大修。两位审稿人的意见都非常好。- A major revision requested by two reviewers. Both reviewers' comments were very positive.

7.25 submitted - Submitted

7.26 in peer review 这个阶段时间有点长，当时等的比较恐惧，生怕出现闪失。- In peer review. This stage took a bit long, and at that time, I was anxiously waiting, afraid of any mishaps.

8.09 accept 当天中午收到了接收的消息，太激动了，第一篇上10的文章也算尘埃落定，继续努力。- Accepted. Received the acceptance message at noon that day, I was so excited. The first article with a perfect score of 10 is finally settled. Will continue to work hard.

we000000 2022-08-13

August 1st submission & initial assessment
August 11th with editor
Hope for smooth progress.

北冰洋的夏日 2022-08-13

Posted on July 27th,
With editor on August 5th,
In peer review on August 12th,
Hope everything goes smoothly!

penguin 2022-08-12

I submitted it in mid-April, and now it's mid-August, but I still haven't received any response from the first review. I'm asking if it's reasonable or not. I have sent four reminders in between, starting from the third month, and have been reminding every two weeks. Even if you want to reject it, at least give me a rejection letter.

米兰的小铁匠 2022-08-11

7.14 Submission
7.14 Review (edited by Luo Xiongwen)
7.28 Minor revisions
8.6 Resubmission
8.11 Acceptance (very fast)

djf-xjtu 2022-08-11

Received after major repairs, wishing JMCA to return to District 1 soon.

djf-xjtu 2022-08-11

Received after major repairs.

长庚 2022-08-09

07.25 Checking submission and files
07.25 Initial assessment
07.29 With Editor
08.08 In peer review
Wishing you good luck

koy12366 2022-08-07

Yes, send it to the email of the corresponding author (submission account).

chengfu 2022-08-06

Submission Experience:
1. Submitted manuscript on 2022/05/25.
- Initial assessment on 5.25.
- Reviewed by editor on 5.30.
- In peer review on 6.7.
- Reviewed by editor on 6.13.
- In peer review on 6.14.

2. Major revision on 2022/06/27.
- 3 reviewers provided positive comments, with a total of 15 suggestions mainly focused on supplementary characterization tests (such as SEM and refined XRD) and some experimental data, as well as improving the mechanism analysis section.
- Revision requested on 7.10.
- In peer review on 7.11.

3. Accepted on 2022/07/20.

4. Proofreading on 2022/08/05.

I am very grateful to editor Yusuke Yamauchi for the opportunity to review. Previously, I have submitted to Advanced Functional Materials, Chemical Engineering Journal, Energy Storage Materials, and Nona Energy journals, but none of them provided the opportunity for review. Once again, I would like to thank JMCA Journal for giving me the chance to publish my first paper and gaining confidence. I hope JMCA Journal continues to improve and regain its status as a top-tier journal soon!!!

Chamsion 2022-08-05

I hope the submission goes smoothly.

Chamsion 2022-08-05

May I ask if the manuscript tracker link should be sent to the boss via email?

koy12366 2022-08-03

On August 2nd, three reviewers agreed to review your manuscript. (Another reviewer has been added, presumably due to conflicting opinions from the first two reviewers. It is likely that things will not go well.)

Claire Yuan 2022-08-01

7.14 submitted
7.15 initial assessment
7.22 with editor
8.1 with editor
.......Too slow, do I need to write a letter to urge?