邓阿喵 2022-11-03

2022.11.2 in peer review (probably arbitration····· hoping for a good outcome)

蜚声 2022-11-03

My initial assessment was on 5th October 2022. I have been with the editor since 19th October 2022 until now.

pc-co 2022-11-03

The speed is really slow, it has been 20 days since I submitted and it is still with the editor.

XXF0809 2022-11-03

Experience of submission:
2022.10.27 submitted
2022.10.27 checking submission and files
2022.10.28 initial assessment
2022.11.03 with editor
Hope to have a good result!

邓阿喵 2022-11-01

2022.11.1 With editor (It should be the first round of review comments back; I wonder what the outcome is.)

邓阿喵 2022-11-01

2022.10.19 With editor (It should be the first round of review comments coming back, wondering how the result is.)

蜚声 2022-10-31

2022/10/5 initial assessment
2022/10/19 with editor
It has been 13 days until now, and I don't know what the situation is. I'm anxious.

匿名K 2022-10-24

2022. 08. 29 submitting
2022. 08. 30 initial assessment
2022. 09. 07 in peer review
2022. 09. 21 major revision
2022. 10. 08 revision submitted
2022. 10. 12 in peer review
2022. 10. 23 accepted
I feel that JMCA has not seen a decline in quality due to the classification by the Chinese Academy of Sciences. Despite receiving three review comments and requiring a major revision, the article's novelty was appreciated, and the editor carefully reviewed both the article and the response. Consequently, it was accepted quickly.

hign 2022-10-24

2022.09.12 submitting - Submitted on September 12, 2022.
2022.09.13 initial assessment - Initial assessment conducted on September 13, 2022.
2022.09.16 with editor - Under review by the editor since September 16, 2022.
2022.09.17 in peer review - In the peer review process since September 17, 2022.
2022.10.10 major revision - Major revision required on October 10, 2022.
2022.10.20 revision submitted - Revised version submitted on October 20, 2022.
2022.10.24 accepted - Accepted on October 24, 2022.

kobe123456 2022-10-24

Experience of submission:
2022.09.15 Submitting
2022.09.16 Initial assessment
2022.09.16 With editor
2022.09.17 In peer review
2022.09.27 Major Revision
2022.10.13 Revision submitted
2022.10.23 Accepted
Wishing everything goes smoothly in the future!

邓阿喵 2022-10-22

2022.10.22 In peer review

邓阿喵 2022-10-21

2022.10.21 with editor translates to "October 21, 2022 with editor" in English.

邓阿喵 2022-10-20

2022.10.20 avec éditeur translates to "2022.10.20 with editor" in English.

邓阿喵 2022-10-19

2022.10.19 Con el Editor (Spanish) translates to "2022.10.19 With Editor" in English.

邓阿喵 2022-10-18

Submission Experience:
2022.10.14 Checking submission and files
2022.10.15 Initial assessment
2022.10.18 Initial assessment
Hope to proceed to the next step as soon as possible.

皮蛋瘦肉周周 2022-10-13

Has the original poster got any results?

Yuki丷 2022-10-12

2022.02.07 submitted (投的是review) - Submitted for review on February 7, 2022.
2022.03.25 major revision (两个小修，编辑给大修) - Major revision on March 25, 2022, with two minor revisions suggested by the editor.
2022.04.01 revision submitted - Revision submitted on April 1, 2022.
2022.04.04 accept （大概两周过后proof） - Accepted on April 4, 2022, with the proof expected in approximately two weeks.

皮蛋瘦肉周周 2022-10-12

I also submitted my work on the 10th of June. There has been no progress in the initial evaluation. Have you received any results for yours?

Siend 2022-10-11

Posted on September 29th, it has been with the editor for several days.

丹青 2022-10-10

Mine was also submitted on September 30th. There haven't been any changes yet, it has been in initial assessment all this time.

xiaotangT 2022-10-09

How long does your initial assessment take?

xiaotangT 2022-10-09

Mine is also in the initial review stage since I submitted it on October 6th.

小时候很萌 2022-10-07

Posted on 2022-09-30, there has been no change in the initial evaluation until now, so slow! ? Feeling anxious.

koy12366 2022-09-26

PS: If arbitration occurs, the revised manuscript should only be sent to the arbitrator, and the reviewer who rejected it will no longer consider their opinion.

koy12366 2022-09-26

The text "09.26 accept" is already in English and does not require translation.

1020205022 2022-09-25

9.21 submission;
9.21 initial assessment;
9.25 initial assessment;
Too slow.

小年 2022-09-22

AM was rejected after being transferred to Small Methods for review, ACS Nano rejected, CM rejected, CEJ was rejected after being submitted for review.
Submitted on 7.11
Major revision on 8.15
Returned on 9.2
Accepted on 9.13
Thank you JMCA for accepting.

光头大魔王 2022-09-21

The submission process before JMCA (NC directly rejected, AM directly rejected and transferred to Small without review, ACS Nano rejected, Nano Energy one revision and one rejection by the editor)
7.22 Submission
8.01 First review
8.17 First review completed, minor revision and major revision by two reviewers, editor requested major revision
9.13 Response to R1
9.21 Acceptance
The editor is Ghim Wei Ho.

koy12366 2022-09-21

09.21 in peer review translates to "September 21st in peer review" in English.

koy12366 2022-09-20

08.26 Major Revision. (2 positives, 1 negative)
09.18 Submit. (Hoping for a good outcome)