尽快投稿 2022-12-14

22.8.22 Submission
22.9.18 Minor revisions by first reviewer
22.9.27 Rejected by second reviewer, delayed for two months, always an independent review
11.26 Sent an email to inquire
11.28 Received a reply stating that a third reviewer was found
22.12.7 Rejected by third reviewer, editorial suggestion to withdraw the submission.

绿禾 2022-12-14

How long did it take you to find a reviewer?

Arlin 2022-12-06

Submitted at the end of August, hired at the end of November, published this month. It is estimated that the number of submissions this year will be around 5000 articles.

ChauncL 2022-12-06

The current page fee for the magazine is already 3225 USD.
Received date: 17 Nov 2022
Editorial assignment start date: 17 Nov 2022
Independent review start date: 23 Nov 2022
Review finalized date: 02 Dec 2022
Final validation date: 05 Dec 2022
Article accepted date: 05 Dec 2022
A fast and fortunate submission, wishing the magazine continuous improvement.

Cathy 2022-11-23

Received within one month, come and fulfill the vow, thank you, thank you, and wish you all the best!

夏夏夏十六 2022-11-10

Posted on September 27th, I received the review comments from two reviewers on October 1st and 4th. On October 6th, I received the review comments from the associate editor. A total of nearly 30 review comments were provided. I submitted the revised manuscript on October 8th. One reviewer agreed to publish on the same day, while the other reviewer provided a second round of review comments on October 10th. After completing the revisions on the same day, I submitted the manuscript. It was accepted on October 25th, and after paying the page charges, typesetting began on October 29th. I submitted the proofreading certificate on November 10th, and it was formally published. The overall submission process went relatively smoothly, except that the page charges increased to $3225.

又又胖了 2022-10-26

26 Oct 2022
Article accepted for publication.

24 Oct 2022
Review of Review Editor 1 finalized.

21 Oct 2022
Re-submitted manuscript.

15 Oct 2022
Re-submitted manuscript.

06 Oct 2022
Associate Editor Dipesh Dhakal posted new comments in the Editor tab.
Interactive review forum activated automatically.

03 Oct 2022
Review of Reviewer 2 is finalized.

09 Sep 2022
Corresponding Author Zhiyang Feng submitted manuscript.

嗯、你说 2022-10-02

28 Sep 2022
Article accepted for publication.

19 Sep 2022
Review of Review Editor 1 finalized.

10 Sep 2022
Review of Review Editor 2 finalized.

09 Sep 2022
Submitting Author XXX re-submitted manuscript.

27 Aug 2022
Interactive review forum activated automatically.

11 Jul 2022
Submitting Author XXX submitted manuscript.

海绵宝宝抱 2022-09-24

22 Sep 2022
Article accepted for publication.
21 Sep 2022
Review of Review Editor 3 finalized.
19 Sep 2022
Submitting Author re-submitted manuscript.
06 Sep 2022
Review of Review Editor 2 finalized.
01 Sep 2022
Submitting Author re-submitted manuscript.
21 Aug 2022
Interactive review forum activated.
26 Jul 2022
Submitting Author submitted manuscript.

安然1991 2022-09-21

Posted on August 15th.
Received comments from the first reviewer on August 25th, and received comments from the second reviewer on September 5th.
Revised and resubmitted on September 19th, and accepted on September 20th.
The editor handled it quickly. I hope the journal continues to improve.

goodluckQ 2022-09-09

19 May 2022 Submission, Review Article for General Review
Today is 9 Sep 2022, and we are currently stuck at the Independent Review stage. The journal has asked us to recommend reviewers ourselves, and we have already initiated three rounds of recommendations but have not yet found suitable reviewers.

jmxlqy 2022-09-02

04 Aug 2022
Article accepted for publication.

02 Aug 2022
Submitting Author posted new comments in the Editor tab.

27 Jul 2022
Interactive review forum activated automatically.

18 Jul 2022
Review of Reviewer 3 is finalized.

29 May 2022
Submitted manuscript

youyouyouyou 2022-08-29

Can be modified.

youyouyouyou 2022-08-10

Can I ask, can the statement about the author's contribution at the end of the article still be modified after it is published?

zn 2022-08-05

You must upload data, including various sequencing data such as Rna-seq.

strollrabbit 2022-08-05

Good journal, top in Zone 2, the peer review is very professional, and the manuscript processing is extremely fast, taking only 26 days from submission to acceptance.

JWbb 2022-08-01

Do I have to upload sequencing data? I also have this question.

石小峥 2022-07-26

The key point is that I did not include any of the references he mentioned, and this reviewer rejected it outright without raising any concerns related to the quality of the content in the article.

石小峥 2022-07-26

First, let me share my submission process.

Submitted on June 23, 2022.

Assigned editor and external review on June 27, 2022. The editor is Jayesh Jagannath Ahire. I would like to thank him for his fairness, which will be mentioned later.

Reviewer 2's comments received on July 1, 2022. First review agreed to publish with 3 minor formatting issues mentioned.

Reviewer 3's comments received on July 7, 2022. First review agreed to publish with some minor discussion issues mentioned.

Reviewer 1's comments received on July 12, 2022. The key point here is that I want to expose the name of this reviewer, Assar Ali Shah, so that everyone knows about this person and can be cautious in the future. This reviewer provided me with a list of 10 of their own references, without mentioning anything substantial about my article in the review comments. It was just a sentence, suggesting to refer to the following papers for rewriting the introduction and discussion. Isn't this a disguised way of forcing the author to cite their own work? Moreover, I searched for some of the papers that he reviewed for Frontiers in Microbiology, and they all included the references he listed. However, the citations of his references in the papers and the context were not very appropriate, and they were not closely related to the whole paper. Fortunately, Jayesh, the editor, noticed this issue in time and sent me an email specifically stating that there was no need to cite any references suggested by the reviewers. This strengthened my determination and I chose to trust the editor, who did not let me down and made revisions on the same day.

Accepted on July 25, 2022.

小熊爱葡萄 2022-07-22

May I ask, how long did it take from receiving to publication?

安然123 2022-07-08

Hello, I would like to ask where can I reply to the reviewer? Is it the dialogue box below the editor?

哈哈哈哈哈哈哈 2022-07-07

Fast speed, high impact factor.

pupupupupu 2022-07-01

I won't say anything more. This is the first time I've had such a satisfying submission experience. I'm lucky. I will continue to work hard!!!

30 Jun 2022
Article accepted for publication.

26 Jun 2022
Corresponding Author re-submitted manuscript.
Corresponding Author posted new comments in the Editor tab.

24 Jun 2022
Corresponding/Submitting Author is automatically requested to revise and resubmit the manuscript.
Review of Reviewer 1 is finalized.

15 Jun 2022
Review of Reviewer 2 is finalized.

08 Jun 2022
Corresponding Author submitted manuscript.

水处理小菜鸡 2022-06-24

I want to ask everyone, how long does it take to accept and publish? I have been waiting for over a month with no progress.

努力发NCS 2022-06-20

Just today, a certain academician from the Chinese Academy of Sciences said that all journals under Frontiers are low-quality journals. In the future, students who publish papers under Frontiers may not be able to graduate! This has dealt a blow to all the hard work put into writing papers, going through the review process with dozens of pages of reviewer comments, and making multiple revisions before finally getting accepted. I can only say that this is one person's opinion!

hui 2022-06-06

Excuse me everyone, it has been 3 weeks since I submitted my article, but it still hasn't been assigned an editor. What should I do? I also sent an email to the editorial department but haven't received any response.

安然123 2022-06-04

What stage is your manuscript currently at?

hui 2022-06-04

I'm not familiar with this journal either, it's my first submission.

安然123 2022-06-04

Hello, I would like to ask if I need to wait for all reviewers' comments before replying to this journal. Currently, I have received comments from one reviewer.

hui 2022-05-26

After I submitted my article, I have been waiting for the editor assignment for 8 days. Is this situation normal? I am anxious.