Verified Reviews - ACS Sustainable Chemistry & Engineering
Note: Verified reviews are sourced from across review platforms and social media globally.

快乐的自己 2022-09-09

Deputy Editor: Dr. Jeannette Garcia

快乐的自己 2022-09-09

I also just submitted to the journal and got assigned to this editor. It's too slow, my senior brother submitted two papers and both were accepted by another editor. They were sent for external review in about a week. It's really frustrating.

风飞扬 2022-09-08

It went quite smoothly. The initial review took more than 20 days, and all four reviewers were good. The editor requested major revisions. The revised manuscript was returned after more than 10 days. The second review took more than 30 days, and three reviewers agreed. The fourth reviewer did not respond with comments, so it must have been their fault for the slow second review of the paper. Taiwan editor.

涛小涛 2022-09-07

Posted for 4 months, reminded the associate editor, the reviewer made minor revisions, the editor rejected the submission. Please, everyone, do not urge, urging will result in rejection.

Juvy Z 2022-09-07

The second trial is so slow, so slow.

峰景 2022-09-07

2022.9.7 Assigned to the deputy editor (Professor Han Hongxian from Dalian Institute of Chemical Physics).

峰景 2022-09-05

2022.9.3 submission
Assigned to editor Bala Subramaniam

涛小涛 2022-09-01

The editing speed of this person is the slowest I have ever seen. I have been waiting for 3 months, and there has been no change at all. Another person from the same class also submitted their work 3 months ago, and they are still in the same state.

什么时候中一区 2022-08-27

August 22nd Status:
Associate Editor Assigned
Your manuscript has been assigned to an Associate Editor (Dr. Jeannette Garcia) for further evaluation.

I am unsure of the next step and it seems to be progressing slowly.

jackieshark 2022-08-24

May 31: Submitted
July 7: Received reviewer comments; two reviewers requested minor revisions, one reviewer rejected the submission. The final editor requested minor revisions.
July 22: Sent back the revised manuscript according to the reviewer comments.
August 15: Received an email from the editor agreeing to accept the manuscript, with a request for formatting changes.
August 16: Sent back the manuscript with the requested formatting changes and it was accepted on the same day.
August 23: Published online.
I am really happy that my article was accepted for the first time in ACS Sustainable Chemistry & Engineering. I would like to thank Deputy Editor Ryuhei Nakamura and hope that the journal continues to improve. (*^▽^*)

涛小涛 2022-08-22

The same editor, the submission has not made any progress for 3 months.

梅竹1 2022-08-05

It has been 20 days with Liane Rossi, and it has not been submitted for review yet. Can we urge them?

锅子66 2022-08-05

I am also Liane. It has been a week, and I am still under the deputy editor's control.

人好稳 2022-08-04

7.24 to the deputy editor, it has not been submitted for review yet.

梅竹1 2022-08-03

May I ask how long it will take for the review to be completed?

梅竹1 2022-08-03

That is in an unsent state. May I ask how long it took to submit it later?

梅竹1 2022-08-03

Excuse me, are there any pending assignments for iiane rossi? How long does it take for them to be reviewed?

梅竹1 2022-08-02

Can I urge for the submission made on July 15th, which was distributed to editor Liane Marcia Rossi the next day, but has been untouched (not reviewed) for over half a month now?

Dww-JUST 2022-08-01

Is the external review being sent now?

Juvy Z 2022-07-28

Posted on July 4th, it hasn't been reviewed yet. Does anyone know what's going on? The status is still AE.

kdzbqqnl 2022-07-27

Posted on July 18, still not reviewed as of July 27, the editor is from Taiwan.

zsxhebut 2022-07-27

I am also Iiane Rossi. I submitted it on July 16th, and it has not been reviewed yet.

揍他个小舅子 2022-07-24

It has been two weeks since submission, and it has not been reviewed yet. Editor Liane Rossi is a bit slow.

朴小嘻嘻 2022-07-18

I am too, I have been applying for a month now, the status hasn't changed, it's still "under review", and the editor is Jeannette Garcia.

Juvy Z 2022-07-14

Has your status changed? Mine has also been assigned to the editor-in-chief himself.

ZFF-1991 2022-07-11

2022.3.7 Submission
2022.4.22 Major revision
2022.5.22 Revised
2022.7.03 Accepted

Three reviewers, the questions are quite professional!

任高升 2022-07-10

Translate the following text into English: "Editor David Allen."

任高升 2022-07-10

2022.7.8 Post successful
2022.7.10 Status unchanged

10的68次方 2022-07-05

Will the "in peer review" status appear after submission?

lcm050711 2022-06-29

The submission was made on June 16th, and it is still in the hands of the editor. It has not been sent for review yet, and I'm not sure what the situation is.

Discover Peeref hubs

Discuss science. Find collaborators. Network.

Join a conversation

Become a Peeref-certified reviewer

The Peeref Institute provides free reviewer training that teaches the core competencies of the academic peer review process.

Get Started