krad 2021-08-12

Already hit, submitted in September 2020, received major revision after the first review in December 2020 (this journal has a policy of rejecting and resubmitting), resubmitted as R1 in February 2021, received minor revision after the second review in May 2021, resubmitted as R2 in June 2021, accepted in August 2021. I have also experienced the lengthy "Under Review" process and can understand the feelings of authors. If you have any questions, you can direct message me, and I will try my best to answer.

Pangw 2021-08-05

Second submission, after 8 months of waiting. Unfortunately, this time it was assigned to 6 reviewers... However, most of the opinions were quite fair, and I did put a lot of effort into addressing the questions raised by a few reviewers.

家跃 2021-08-01

Classmate, may I ask if this journal only requires a major revision opportunity, does it mean that it is basically unlikely to be rejected?

家跃 2021-08-01

Classmate, may I ask if this journal only requires a major revision opportunity, does it mean that it will basically not be rejected?

家跃 2021-08-01

Classmate, may I ask if your first round of revisions for the article is a major overhaul or a minor one? How long did you spend on the revisions?

家跃 2021-08-01

Classmate, may I ask how long did it take for you to revise and resubmit your article after it was rejected? Does this journal basically not reject submissions as long as there is an opportunity for major revisions?

ryder 2021-07-29

First Submit (Dec-2020)
Reject & Resubmit (May-2021)
Second Submit (May-2021)
Accept (Jul-2021)

Translation:

First submission (December 2020)
Rejected and resubmitted (May 2021)
Second submission (May 2021)
Accepted (July 2021)

zzjjjjzz 2021-07-14

2021.07.02 submit - Submitted on July 2nd, 2021.
2021.07.09 under review - Currently being reviewed as of July 9th, 2021.

krad 2021-07-13

Within 15 pages is fine, additional pages will incur a fee.

RecSys 2021-07-10

I'm sorry, but you haven't provided any text for me to translate. Could you please provide the text you would like me to translate?

七彩 2021-07-10

Yes, ten pages, but mine has ten pages. Extra pages are charged.

sdusrj 2021-07-08

May I ask if there is a limit of 10 pages for the re-submission after major revision?

keci 2021-07-08

xd, have your results come back? It feels like it's been about seven or eight months for you, right?

七彩 2021-06-27

Submit the initial draft in mid-October 2020; resubmit after major revisions in mid-January 2021, given three months. Received positive feedback from the reviewers and addressed the questions well. Submit the revised draft in mid-April 2021, but there were delays due to changing jobs after graduation. Accepted in late June 2021. The journal is good with high recognition, but the reviewing process is average, taking around two to three months for the first and second rounds of review.

krad 2021-06-10

The first trial took two and a half months, and the second trial took exactly three months, with no reminders in between.

ryder 2021-06-07

Received reviews in December 2020, and then submitted the paper in February 2021?

ryder 2021-06-07

Have you done the minor repairs? Has the second round taken more than three months in total? Was the editor reminded in between?

pelysama 2021-06-07

2020 July - first submission
2020 December - reject & resubmission
2021 February - resubmission
2021 May - acceptance

krad 2021-05-31

Second trial, three months notice for minor repairs.

cql98 2021-05-31

Already invested, after three days, EIC and ADM were split.

冲冲冲冲 2021-05-26

Received, thank you for your reply!

Yang99 2021-05-26

It has been about 5 days, and there are now names after EIC and ADM. It has been over a month now, and it is estimated that experts are currently reviewing it.

冲冲冲冲 2021-05-25

May I ask if your status eic: not assigned, adm: not assigned has changed? Mine is also not assigned.

krad 2021-05-18

The first review took two and a half months, and the paper was rejected and resubmitted (which is equivalent to a major revision for this journal). After making the revisions and resubmitting, it has been three months but there is still no outcome.

ryder 2021-05-14

Posted in November 2020,
The system has been showing "Under Review" all along.
It has been over 6 months and no round of results has been released yet.

sk__ 2021-05-01

This is a typical relationship-based journal! It doesn't matter if the submission is delayed for 5 to 6 months, they will eventually reject it!

As for the level of the reviewers! All I can say is "haha," typical "big shot" level, probably far from the front line of scientific research, just making empty promises! They feel like they are "big shots," and without even looking, they give generic feedback and reject it, just because: who is the author? I don't know them!

Researchers on the front line should be cautious with their submissions, while famous experts can do as they please!

wdgdusagdia 2021-04-26

I am also under view.

天天向上的小吴 2021-04-21

Brother, how long have you been investing?

HJ Liu 2021-04-19

Always under review, it seems to be the only status, very torturous.

krad 2021-04-19

You have not experienced the pain of constantly being "Under Review".