Verified Reviews - Materials
Note: Verified reviews are sourced from across review platforms and social media globally.

dain 2023-03-14

How long does it usually take for "under review" status? It's been two weeks already. I submitted it at the end of last month and I'm very anxious.

小胡的南宫霸天 2023-03-09

Not as easy as others say, the reviewers are also responsible. Open source mainly focuses on speed.

光脚开车 2023-03-09

Thank you, after submitting the email, there has been no response, I don't know if I should switch to a different publication.

伸懒猫 2023-03-09

What do you use this concluding topic for in your project? It helps you with the conclusion, but you turn around and criticize others. Why don't you reflect on why your own project is still struggling with concluding? Is it because your skills are too weak? It's laughable.

伸懒猫 2023-03-09

Please directly contact the assistant editor if there is any issue, and it will eventually be included in WOS (Web of Science). Keep an eye on those papers that were published at the same time as yours but have not been included in WOS. If all the papers from that period have been included except yours (which is rare), you can contact the assistant editor and have them report the situation to WOS, and the problem will be resolved.

岩土小白 2023-03-04

The processing speed may have slowed down. I originally submitted a special issue, but this journal is usually very fast. It has been 20 days already, so your paper's DOI number should be searchable on Google Scholar.

求→锦鲤 2023-03-04

I was published on February 14th, and it has not been indexed on WOS yet. Are you saying it can be indexed after about 10 days of publication?

潇洒哥 2023-03-04

The editorial board or guest editor can publish one article for free.

岩土小白 2023-03-04

Can be on WOS within 10 days.

求→锦鲤 2023-03-03

The review speed of this journal is very fast, with submissions being sent for review within two days and receiving the first-round results in less than half a month. Three expert reviewers provided nearly 20 suggestions, and after making revisions according to each suggestion, the quality of the article significantly improved, leading to acceptance by the editorial department. The journal is excellent, but the only downside is the slightly expensive price. Overall, it has a high level and influence in the industry. Additionally, I have a small doubt: how long does it take for the journal to be searchable after publication?

无所谓惧怕 2023-03-01

To get coupons, please chat privately.

dain 2023-02-28

Who has this journal discount coupon?

白开水 2023-02-24

I submitted an article, which was completely different from what everyone was saying. It was very mediocre and could have been published by anyone. I had four reviewers, three minor revisions, totaling 14 questions. There was one major revision with 12 questions, and it was evident that the reviewer was an expert in the field. My work was interdisciplinary, and this reviewer was well aware of the progress and technological trends in both areas, asking sharp questions.

The editor gave me ten days, and I applied for a one-week extension. In the end, I submitted an 18-page revised response.

Overall, I feel that the journal has high standards (probably due to my personal submission experience, as some may have received fewer review comments), but the process is fast, which is suitable for those in a hurry.

After another round of minor revisions, it was finally accepted for publication.

伸懒猫 2023-02-23

Just saw that English submissions are accepted. The review process takes about 3 months, but this is only for reference. The publication usually starts in July each year, with a new issue every two months. This is for your reference.

小虫子帅 2023-02-21

Who has coupons for this journal? Can I purchase them through private chat?

Explore秦 2023-02-17

Surprisingly, it is possible to waive the manuscript fee. My heart is tempted to chat.

小虫子帅 2023-02-17

Where did you get the free coupon? Can we add each other as friends?

光脚开车 2023-02-14

Hello, I saw that you reviewed a materials science journal in Ukraine. I would like to ask you a question: I submitted an article by email, but I have not received a response. Can I submit it in English only? How long does it usually take to receive a reply? How long is the review process and publication time? Thank you.
I look forward to your reply, thank you!

陈涵 2023-02-09

Hello everyone, materials special issue call for papers, Advanced Non-destructive Testing Techniques on Materials. Contact me to enjoy a discount of 10% to 30%. Everyone is welcome to inquire (202021002092@smail.xtu.edu.cn).

不知道 2023-01-18

Which one is the free coupon, please?

不知道 2023-01-18

Can I invest in materials without hanging the fund? Will it be accepted? I haven't invested yet.

元宝守护者 2022-12-25

There are also free vouchers.

潇洒哥 2022-12-19

Two reviewers. I didn't consider submitting to Materials because of the waived publication fee (100% discount) and the quick process, so let's just go with this.

我勒那个去 2022-12-19

The editor is very incompetent. After the reviewer completed the review, it took them 3-5 days to provide a result. Submitted on 11/23, major revisions on 12/05, revised on 12/07, pending editor decision on 12/09, minor revisions on 12/14, returned on 12/14, pending editor decision on 12/15, and four more days have passed. I originally submitted it in order to get a quick response, but I didn't expect the efficiency to be so low!

糊里糊涂QX 2022-12-19

12/1 submitted
12/3 under consideration
12/9 major revision
12/11 resubmitted
12/13 Ask for additional reviewer

12/29 minor revisions
1/3 accept

The reviewing and approval process was fast, and the editor was also responsible. Highly recommended!

伸懒猫 2022-12-15

My personal feeling is that the quality of this publication has been getting higher and higher. This year, I published a paper in it and received nearly 40 comments from three reviewers, who were very professional. After that, I had to make a second revision because one of the reviewers was not satisfied with my modifications. Finally, it went through another review by two academic editors before being published. However, this process was efficient, taking just over a month in total. The time given for major revisions was only 7 days. Overall, OA journals are mainly for saving time, and the reviewers for this materials journal are very diligent and responsible. This is just my personal feeling, so please refrain from criticizing and take it as a reference only.

伸懒猫 2022-12-15

There is no warning at all for 2022.

Plottttttt 2022-12-05

received date: 1st November 2022
revised date: 7th November 2022
accepted date: 26th November 2022

The garbage OA water journal under Mdpi has an extremely fast acceptance speed.

Suitable for a large amount of spamming.

岩土小白 2022-11-26

There is no warning in 2022.

就这吧 2022-11-26

Open Source Warning
More than 15,000 R
Invest with caution!

Publish scientific posters with Peeref

Peeref publishes scientific posters from all research disciplines. Our Diamond Open Access policy means free access to content and no publication fees for authors.

Learn More

Create your own webinar

Interested in hosting your own webinar? Check the schedule and propose your idea to the Peeref Content Team.

Create Now