牛角泡子 2022-04-03

Second round (Reviewer 1 agrees, Reviewers 2 and 3 raised many professional questions, and the Editor also summarized it, feeling that the NC editor is responsible)
Decision sent to author 2022-01-12
Manuscript under consideration 2022-01-11
Review complete 2022-01-11
All reviewers assigned 2021-12-09
Contacting potential reviewers 2021-12-09
Manuscript under consideration 2021-12-08
Editor assigned 2021-12-07
Manuscript submitted 2021-12-07
Submission in process 2021-12-05

牛角泡子 2022-04-03

First submitted to Cell, but unfortunately the editing was not suitable. Then tried Nature, after some tinkering, it was suggested to transfer to NC. The following is a detailed timeline:

First round (the first round was quite fast, the editor was very responsible and efficient). Combined with the input of three reviewers to supplement the experiments.
Decision sent to author 2021-11-15 (given three months)
Manuscript under consideration 2021-11-14
Review complete 2021-11-15
All Reviewers Assigned 2021-10-15
Manuscript under consideration 2021-10-10
Contacting potential Reviewers 2021-10-08
Manuscript under consideration 2021-12-07
Editor Assigned 2021-10-07
Manuscript submitted 2021-10-06
Submission in process 2021-10-05

liaohu 2022-03-30

How are things going now?

Jacs-bio 2022-03-30

2022-1-14 Submission in process
2022-1-14 Manuscript submitted
2022-1-17 Editor Assigned
2022-1-17 Manuscript under consideration
2022-1-27 Sent for peer review (email sent)
2022-2-01 Contacting Potential Reviewers (5 reviewer(s) invited)
2022-2-10 Manuscript under consideration
2022-2-11 Reviewer #1 agreed
2022-2-14 Reviewer #2 agreed
2022-2-18 Became blank status
2022-2-28 Manuscript under consideration (Review #2 received)
2022-3-04 All Reviewers Assigned (Reviewer #3 agreed)
Currently, the status is still All Reviewers Assigned.

Kuit 2022-03-21

The result of the submission is unknown, even though the submission period is 0 months, it is still recorded as 0 months.

nsc2022 2022-03-17

Round three
Manuscript under consideration 16th March 22
Editor Assigned 16th March 22
Manuscript submitted 16th March 22
Submission in process 15th March 2

nsc2022 2022-03-17

Second round
14th February 22
Manuscript under consideration
14th February 22
Review Complete
14th February 22
All Reviewers Assigned
31st January 22
Manuscript under consideration
26th January 22
Contacting Potential Reviewers
26th January 22
Manuscript under consideration
20th January 22
Editor Assigned
20th January 22
Manuscript submitted
6th January 22
Submission in process
6th January 22

nsc2022 2022-03-17

First round
3rd December 21
Manuscript under consideration
24th November 21
Editor Assigned
24th November 21
Manuscript submitted
22nd November 21
Submission in process
21st November 21
Manuscript Transferred
21st November 21

KerwinLiu 2022-03-16

2.22 Submission
2.25 Decision made to review
But until now, it has been 19 days on 3.16, and there is still no "All reviewers assigned". How long does it usually take for everyone from submission to "All reviewers assigned"?
I think 10 days at most should be enough. Is it because our field of engineering is relatively niche and it is difficult to contact reviewers?

liaohu 2022-03-12

The articles published by NC in the field of microbial ecology are still authoritative.

ustcucbku 2022-03-10

Replying to the questions from several commenters:

1. Have you uploaded the raw data?
Yes, I have uploaded it to the Zenodo online repository, and then I included the DOI in the data availability statement.

2. Is the third round a minor revision? How long did it take?
The third round resulted in acceptance. After the third round of review, the status changed to "under consideration" for 15 days, and on the same day, the editor made the decision. Prior to receiving the comments from the second round of review, the editor also included some editorial comments and made a preliminary decision to accept, so there were no further comments in the third round.

3. Have you used a preprint?
No, I have not.

Tom哥 2022-03-06

Hello, may I ask if you have received and uploaded all the data?

Tom哥 2022-03-06

Hello, may I ask if you have uploaded all the data after receiving it?

Tom哥 2022-03-06

Hello, have you received and uploaded all the raw data after receiving it?

Tom哥 2022-03-06

Hello, may I ask if you have received and uploaded all the data?

emon 2022-02-26

Hello, it took about 3 weeks.

joe888 2022-02-24

Original post, may I ask how long it takes for you to receive the formal acceptance letter after accepting the offer in principle?

二狗蛋 2022-02-22

1. 04 Submission

emon 2022-02-16

Recently, I just received an NC (name of conference), and I want to share the submission process.

August 6, 2021 - Submitted the paper
September 28, 2021 - First round, major revision (two reviewers suggested modifications and both accepted after revisions. A total of 18 questions were asked)
November 3, 2021 - Returned for revisions
December 7, 2021 - Second round, major revision (only the first reviewer had one question, felt our response was not satisfactory, and requested major revisions from the editor)
December 26, 2021 - Returned for revisions
February 7, 2022 - Provisionally accepted, preparing to address the editor's formatting requirements

Overall, the reviewers were very professional and asked very insightful questions. The remaining question from the second round of review was very important, which we had not considered before. After addressing the question and completing the experiment, we found it to be very valuable and provided significant reference for our future work.

The editing team was also very meticulous and cautious in each round.

kkhust 2022-02-10

Hello, may I ask if the first round of review requires major revisions? The editor has provided a lot of suggestions regarding the article format and uploading of raw data. Should these suggestions be included in the revised manuscript? Or should I wait for the editor to confirm acceptance before modifying their suggestions? I noticed that you started on the fourth round, thank you.

一大摞钱 2022-02-03

Round Four: Principle-based reception - Upload all raw data - Modify format, etc.
Manuscript under consideration: 27th January 22
Editor Assigned: 11th December 21
Manuscript submitted: 11th December 21
Submission in process: 11th December 21

一大摞钱 2022-02-03

Round Three: Minor Revision
Manuscript under consideration 29th November 21
Review Complete 29th November 21
All Reviewers Assigned 18th November 21
Manuscript under consideration 19th October 21
Editor Assigned 19th October 21
Manuscript submitted 19th October 21
Submission in process 19th October 21

一大摞钱 2022-02-03

Second round: Minor revisions
Manuscript under consideration: September 6th, 2021
Review complete: September 6th, 2021
All reviewers assigned: August 23rd, 2021
Manuscript under consideration: July 29th, 2021
Editor assigned: July 27th, 2021
Manuscript submitted: July 27th, 2021
Submission in process: July 27th, 2021

一大摞钱 2022-02-03

Recently, our research group just received an NC and I would like to share the timeline. There were a total of 4 reviewers, plus the editor, making it a total of 5 people involved in the revisions. We went through 4 rounds of revisions. From submission to acceptance of the proof, it took exactly 1 year. Overall, the requirements were very high and the editor and reviewers paid great attention to detail.

First round: Major revision
Review Complete: April 15th, 2021
All Reviewers Assigned: April 7th, 2021
Manuscript under consideration: April 7th, 2021
Contacting Potential Reviewers: March 16th, 2021
Manuscript under consideration: March 5th, 2021
Editor Assigned: March 5th, 2021
Manuscript submitted: February 27th, 2021
Submission in process: February 26th, 2021

Eyes on me 2022-01-28

It's okay, it has nothing to do with whether you can accept it or not... You can choose to make it public or not, preprint.

jimmyFan 2022-01-19

Hello, how did you know it was Zhongxiu? Is it because they were given three months to make revisions?

Bin798 2022-01-14

Second Round: Mid-term Revision
Manuscript under consideration: 17th November 2021
Review Complete: 17th November 2021
All Reviewers Assigned: 27th October 2021
Manuscript under consideration: 27th October 2021
Editor Assigned: 25th October 2021
Manuscript submitted: 25th October 2021

Third Round: Principle Acceptance
Manuscript under consideration: 13th December 2021
Editor Assigned: 2nd December 2021
Manuscript submitted: 2nd December 2021
Notification is usually received on Mondays.

Bin798 2022-01-14

First round
Review Complete - 7th October 21
All Reviewers Assigned - 1st September 21
Manuscript under consideration - 20th August 21
Manuscript under consideration - 17th August 21
Manuscript submitted - 16th August 21

微信用户 2022-01-13

Is the third round a minor repair? How long did it take?

Eason9 2022-01-11

Has the editor of NC started working?