小毛驴Y 2021-09-27

End, throw flowers, submitted on April 29th, first review took 2 and a half months, 20 days for revisions, second review took one and a half months, finally accepted after five months. Wishing everyone success and an early graduation.

shuoshuo子 2021-09-26

When revising, should the charts be placed after the references? Is this the case for both versions?

小毛驴Y 2021-09-25

There is no final admission, I dare not say this, but I also wish you success in exams!

shuoshuo子 2021-09-24

Awesome, bro! Congratulations, congratulations!

小毛驴Y 2021-09-24

After two and a half months of review, I returned and was given a minor repair.

小毛驴Y 2021-09-22

My three reviewers, in the beginning, provided overall comments on the article. The conclusion of the comments was given at the end, perhaps varying among individuals. It has been a month and a half since the revision, and I am still waiting, hoping for the best.

小毛驴Y 2021-09-22

I have two reviewers who said there is innovation in the paper and suggested publication after revisions. However, the third reviewer stated that there is no innovation and recommended against publication. My reviewers are quite direct.

shuoshuo子 2021-09-22

If we look at the summary comments, none of my four reviewers provided any summary comments. Only one of them wrote some comments, but also mentioned that there was not enough innovation while the conclusion was good. The remaining four reviewers directly listed their comments one by one.

jiamaolee 2021-09-21

Excuse me, what is the current status? I submitted on the 10th of this month, and it is still "Submitted to Journal". It has been 10 days and no one has processed the manuscript yet. This journal is so slow.

小毛驴Y 2021-09-20

Look at the summary comments made by the reviewer at the very front, there will generally be a rough conclusion.

shuoshuo子 2021-09-19

Why didn't my review comments say reject or accept?

mhyashc 2021-09-14

Posted on 8.27, still submitted to journal until now. Does anyone know what's going on? Anxious.

吴妮妮 2021-07-22

Although it took a bit of time, it was finally accepted, and the editor was very responsible.
3.19 Submit
3.22 Editor invited
3.27 Under review
4.25 Under review
5.11 Decision in Process
5.13 Significant revisions
5.18 Resubmit
5.19 Under review
6.14 Required review completed
6.22 Decision in Process
6.23 Significant revisions
6.28 Resubmit
6.30 Under review
7.22 Accept

小毛驴Y 2021-07-21

Submitted in May, received feedback. 2 agreed, 1 rejected. 2 mentioned innovation, while the rejected one claimed lack of innovation. Major revisions were given, currently being modified. Hoping for a positive outcome.

罗布虫 2021-07-14

It has been two months since the major renovation was completed, I am exhausted.

zavia 2021-06-30

Excuse me, do you have the status of "required reviews completed"? How long does it usually take?

zavia 2021-06-30

Is there any result?

xiaoxianging 2021-06-14

The revised manuscript for the WM Journal needs to be submitted with a clean copy and a marked copy. Figures and tables should be placed after the references. I submitted it accordingly, but received feedback saying that the format is still incorrect.

xiaoxianging 2021-06-14

WM journal revised manuscript requires the submission of a clean copy and a marked copy with edits. Figures and tables should be placed after the reference section. I submitted it accordingly, but received feedback stating that my formatting is still incorrect. May I ask if this is the correct way to submit a revised manuscript?

hahaheihei 2021-06-07

The journal is too slow, it has been over 8 months.

环境工程 2021-06-05

Following up on the 47th floor, May 14th, required reviews completed. On June 1st, required reviews completed. The status remains unchanged, only the dates have changed. It's the first time it took such a long time for the required reviews to be completed, I don't know what the situation is. Is waste management always taking this long now?

青苹果1889 2021-05-27

Continuing from the previous:
4.2 Revision submitted to the journal
4.2 With editor
4.3 Editor invited
4.3 Under review
4.17 Under review
5.1 Decision in process
5.2 With editor
5.3 Minor Revision
5.3 Revision submitted to the journal
5.3 With editor
5.3 Editor invited
5.4 Under review
5.25 Decision in process
5.26 Accept

青苹果1889 2021-05-27

For reference:

9.25 Submitted to the journal
9.26 With editor
9.27 Editor invited
9.28 Under review
10.11 Under review
11.05 Under review
11.08 Under review
12.07 Under review
12.21 Under review
1.26 Under review
2.17 Under review
2.24 Under review
2.28 Under review
3.1 Under review
3.12 Under review
3.18 Decision in process
3.19 Significant Revise

zavia 2021-05-25

I have been reviewing for half a year, but only the time has changed, and there has been no progress. Is this journal always this slow?

zavia 2021-05-25

So slow! It's been half a year since the manuscript was submitted, and it's still under review. The only thing that has changed is the time, with no progress or updates. The longer it takes, the less I dare to push for a response. I make a wish, please grant me a major revision, minor revision, or rejection, and give me a result quickly, okay?

环境工程 2021-05-13

Are there any recent submissions to this journal? Can someone share the review process?
I submitted on April 9th and it was sent back for formatting changes. I resubmitted and it went through "with editor", "editor invited", "with editor", and is now "under review".
As of now, it is still "under review". For those who have recently submitted to this journal, how many reviewers are usually assigned and how long does the review process typically take? Let's share and exchange experiences. Good luck to everyone.

小毛驴Y 2021-05-08

I have been with the editor for 4 days and still don't know when it will be done.

花儿小九九 2021-04-29

Do not exceed, if you really can't delete it, you can put some less important parts in the Supplementary materials.

青苹果1889 2021-04-07

I submitted it in September last year, and only received feedback in mid-March this year. During the process, the "under review" dates changed 12 times. Now it has been sent back for revisions and I am waiting for the results...

Yanmei Liu 2021-04-04

Submission Date: Dec 06, 2020
Under Review: Apr 04, 2021
It has been nearly 4 months since the external review process started, and the "under review" date has changed 4-5 times during this period. Does this mean that the chances of success are low?