XP_Wang 2022-04-22

2022.4.22 Submission

zeke 2022-04-15

Bro, I saw you before when I invested in JCSR, and now I see you again when investing in Thinwalled.

liuh 2022-04-12

It's a good journal, and the speed of peer review is decent. I will continue to keep an eye on this publication.

伊人夕岸 2022-04-06

2020.11.13 submitted
2020.11.17 under review
2020.12.27 required reviews completed
2020.12.28 under review
2021.03.04 required reviews completed
2021.03.08 major revision
2021.05.05 resubmission
2021.06.03 accepted

thomasyang 2022-03-06

February 7th - major review
February 27th - submitted
March 2nd - under review
March 3rd - required reviews completed
March 4th - accepted

thomasyang 2022-02-03

Post submitted on October 20, 2021
Major revision on December 2, 2021
Returned for revisions on December 24, 2021
Required reviews completed on January 27, 2022

范德萨 2022-02-03

It feels really slow. It has been three weeks since submission to the journal. So, what is the current status, OP?

樱桃九熟 2022-01-11

01.10 under review - This phrase means that something is currently being examined or evaluated.

樱桃九熟 2021-12-24

12.23 submitted to journal translates to "Submitted to journal on December 23rd."

科研民工 2021-12-18

Does this journal have a template for formatting? I'm getting ready to submit.

科研民工 2021-12-18

Is there a template for typesetting for the first submission of this journal?

建坤 2021-12-14

Three weeks have passed since it was submitted to the journal. Then, it was rejected by the editor after one day because it did not align with the direction. It has delayed nearly a month of time... It's a bit frustrating.

-x_xiao 2021-12-12

My journal is also two weeks.

Jianence 2021-12-04

Found, ENGINEERING STRUCTURES

Jianence 2021-12-04

May I ask which journal you are referring to when you mention "es"?

bie123 2021-10-20

Why does it feel like the processing speed of Thin-walled structures editing has become very slow? It has been almost half a month since submission, and it is still at the "submit to journal" stage without being assigned an editor. Is everyone experiencing the same situation?

Xu Han 2021-10-05

Record key milestones of my submission:
2021.04.15 - Submitted manuscript
2021.07.15 - Received revision comments (Major Revisions), a total of 13 comments from 2 reviewers.
2021.08.15 - Submitted revised manuscript
2021.09.26 - Accepted.
The entire process took 5 months and 10 days. Additionally, another manuscript is currently in the second round of review, hoping for good luck.

TK-MIX 2021-09-16

Already hired. I remember updating my status before, but it might have been deleted. It took about four months from submission to being hired, and it feels like the review time is a bit longer compared to ES. Generally, ES would provide comments within a month, while TWS might take around two months, but it also depends on luck.

ddppp 2021-09-16

How long does it take to be employed after general retirement?

大表哥 2021-09-15

Does ES need to be faster than this? Does the OP have experience?

加油文章人 2021-09-14

Boss, I have been submitting continuously this week, but they didn't provide the journal number. Did you also not provide the journal number at that time?

荆棘鸟的绝唱 2021-09-10

Two major revisions and one minor revision were conducted. The second reviewer was an expert from Iran. In fact, his review was invalid, which made it impossible for me to cite his paper. Overall, the expert's opinions were quite professional, and the editing attitude was very good. I wish the journal continued to improve.

燕飞BJUT 2021-09-09

Three major renovations, lasting eight months, finally hired

牛13科研D 2021-09-02

Just reviewed an article, it was really poorly written. I don't know how it got submitted for review. Is the editor a professional? It's a waste of the reviewer's time.

spear 2021-08-30

The manuscript was returned with major revisions after two months of review, with over 20 comments from three reviewers. We carefully addressed and responded to each comment within 20 days and notified acceptance nearly a month after the major revisions. This is the seventh paper on thin-walled structures, and I would like to express gratitude for the constructive feedback from the reviewers. I wish the journal continued success!

reepsone 2021-08-24

Excuse me, big boss, after one week of submission, if it shows "under review", does this status mean that the paper is still in the hands of the editor, or does it mean that it has been sent for external review?

reepsone 2021-08-21

After one week of submission, it shows "Under Review". Does this status mean that the paper is still in the editor's hands?

guyue062 2021-08-12

This journal is optional. When submitting an article, you can choose whether it is open access (OA) or not. It does not affect acceptance.

guyue062 2021-08-12

Finally received it today. Recorded all the important milestones for reference to my buddies.
2021.04.27 Submitted
2021.05.27 Under review
2021.07.06 Major revision
2021.07.23 Revision submitted
2021.08.11 Accepted
Overall, it was quite fast.

guyue062 2021-07-18

2021.04.27 post
2021.05.27 under review
2021.07.06 converted to major revision