攀峰计划A1 2022-08-24

Is there no "with editor" after submission? Does it mean that it was sent for external review on the same day? What was the result?

zui清风 2022-08-10

02/04/2022 submission
09/08/2022 rejection
The intermediate dates changed many times, the speed is very slow, and the review period is too long.

XP_Wang 2022-08-08

2022.08.08 under review translates to "Under review on August 8, 2022" in English.

XP_Wang 2022-08-03

2022.7.5: Major revision
2022.8.1: Revision Submitted to Journal

MIM 2022-07-11

There are two issues with the minor revision: formatting and adding a graphic. Please edit and review, and do not return it to the reviewer.

范德萨 2022-07-11

Did you return after just one day of minor repairs? Was it some formatting issue? Did the editor send it to the reviewer for review? Thank you.

MIM 2022-07-04

4.27 Submission
5.2 With Editor
5.4 Under Review
5.17 Required Reviews Completed (The middle date has been changed more than three times)
5.23 Major Revision
6.10 Under Review
6.24 Required Reviews Completed (The middle date has been changed more than three times)
7.3 Minor Revision
7.4 Accept

可期 2022-06-27

Direct rejection, no opportunity for revision.

MIM 2022-06-25

Is there an opportunity for major repairs?

xxxt 2022-06-21

6.21 decision in process
Not reviewed, most likely rejected

xxxt 2022-06-19

Does Tws have a trial run review tracking feature? Have you received an email for the recently submitted communication?

爱汪汪wang 2022-06-18

I don't know the result of the submission yet. I have been rejected once before, and I hope I won't be rejected again.

xxxt 2022-06-18

"5.17 con editor" translates to "5.17 with editor" in English.

hhh- 2022-06-16

Vaguely remember submitted on 23rd December 2021, without "with editor" status, it seems to be under review on 27th January 2022.

xxxt 2022-06-16

6.14 submitted.

可期 2022-06-15

2021.10.20 Submitted to Journal
2021.11.02 Under Review
2021.11.03 Under Review
2022.01.26 Under Review
2022.04.01 Required reviews completed
2022.04.05 Decision in process
2022.04.06 Reject
Three reviewers, two recommend major revisions and one recommends rejection. I regret to inform you that one of the reviewers, who is a globally renowned expert, has advised against publishing your manuscript while the other reviewer suggested major revisions.

xxxt 2022-06-14

May I ask how long does it take for the submission with the editor to be reviewed?

hhh- 2022-06-12

No confirmation is needed, they will send a message to the communication over there stating that they have received your submission.

hhh- 2022-06-12

I had been working on it for about a month and a half, and after the repair, it took another month and a half.

MIM 2022-06-07

May I ask if the host has a submission guide for TWS? I beg for a copy.

asfa 2022-06-05

Do all authors need to confirm by email after submission?

范德萨 2022-06-05

How long did you wait for the results after the major repair? I have been waiting for half a month and still haven't received any news. The system time has not changed.

hhh- 2022-06-02

2021.12.23 Submission
2022.3.4 Major renovation
2022.6.2 Acceptance

MIM 2022-05-23

Return the review comments of 5.22. Five reviewers, nearly 70 review comments... feeling not very positive.

zeke 2022-05-20

I submitted my article on April 13th, and then on May 17th, it changed to "required reviews complete." On May 18th, it changed to "under review." On May 19th, it changed again to "required reviews completed."

MIM 2022-05-20

No, this journal probably takes four to five months. The date was updated on May 18th, but the status remains unchanged. It's just very frustrating.

zeke 2022-05-20

Friend, I am in a similar situation as you. What is your current situation? Have you been hired?

MIM 2022-05-17

4.27 submission
5.2 with editor
5.4 under review
5.17 Required Reviews Completed (The date changed three times during the RCC stage, I don't understand)

XP_Wang 2022-04-28

2022.4.28 with editor

WY1397 2022-04-28

A teacher from a domestic university reviewed it and suggested two journals to submit to. The process was quite fast. The quality is relatively high, so consider submitting again next time if there is a chance.