学术小阳 2023-03-08

Accept

学术小阳 2023-03-03

Am I talking to myself again? Indeed, doing scientific research requires a balance between work and rest. Otherwise, being mentally strained every day, the state cannot be sustained.

学术小阳 2023-03-03

Submit the minor revisions next week, hoping for an acceptance. The editor and reviewer are both excellent, especially the editor who is very fast at editing.

学术小阳 2023-03-03

What's the situation now? Have you accepted it?

学术小阳 2023-03-03

20221206 submit
20221208 under review
20221217 under review
20230101 under review
20230108 required reviews complete
20230114 review complete
20230116 major revision, 3 reviewers
20230214 1st revision submit
20230216 under review
20230220 required reviews complete
20230228 review complete
20230301 minor revision, 1 question from reviewer 3, others accept.

handong123 2023-02-19

Hello, how long does this journal usually give reviewers to review?

UURSELF 2023-02-18

Reviewer number 2 has provided numerous whimsical opinions for many days, and even on the last day of the review period, hastily glanced over and wrote nonsensical comments. Especially the fourth time was extremely outrageous, to the point that it could be considered asking me to rewrite the entire paper. For instance, asking me to simulate and evaluate the application of my object in space and deep sea using ABAQUS, with an error margin of less than 5%. Anything above 5% is considered incorrect and unacceptable. The editor did not even review it, but simply submitted it. It took two months just dealing with this one person, and the article has been completely altered. Can I please have a fair treatment?

UURSELF 2023-02-18

20221003 submit - Submitted on October 3, 2022
20221018 review complete - Review completed on October 18, 2022
20221028 Reviews completed，5 reviewers, 40 questions, 2nd reviewer with 18 questions.
20221124 1st revision submit - First revision submitted on November 24, 2022
20221211 Reviews completed, major revision, 2nd reviewer with 8 questions, others accepted.
20221221 2nd revision submit - Second revision submitted on December 21, 2022
20230105 Reviews completed, major revision, 2nd reviewer with 3 questions.
20230128 3rd revision submit - Third revision submitted on January 28, 2023
20230213 Reviews completed, major revision, 2nd reviewer with 1 question.
20230217 4th revision submit - Fourth revision submitted on February 17, 2023
20230218 under review - Currently under review
It has been over four months.

Jack W 2023-02-12

The speed is very fast, from submission to acceptance, it took exactly three months. Thanks to the editor Sun, I will share the timeline:

2022.11.13 Submitted to journal
2022.11.14 Under Review
2022.11.28 Required Reviews Completed
2022.12.19 Required Reviews Completed
2022.12.29 Major revision
2023.1.24 Returned - under review
2023.2.8 Required Reviews Completed
2023.2.11 Required Reviews Completed
2023.2.11 Accepted

handong123 2023-01-31

First review, two reviewers.

大表哥 2023-01-29

May I ask how many reviewers are there for your article?

Zion_95 2023-01-25

Received in the tenth month

Zion_95 2023-01-12

The major repair was given in the eighth month, it took half a month for rework, and now it has been under review for another month and a half.

糯米种子饭 2023-01-10

Two and a half months after submission, it underwent major revisions.
After the revisions, it was given minor edits two months later.
Another two months passed and it was rejected.

changlijun0814@163.com 2022-12-29

You can urge for the manuscript, and the reviewer should complete it within half a month according to the requirements.

zcz1810727 2022-12-29

It has been seven months, and it's difficult to bear.

handong123 2022-12-21

TWS has been upgraded to Civil Engineering Zone One.

旅行的歌者 2022-12-21

Why has Thin-walled structures become slower this year? The review and re-review process both take a long time. Emails have also not received any replies.

handong123 2022-10-25

Two and a half months have passed since the manuscript review comments were issued, and a major revision is required.

Zion_95 2022-10-24

I have been under review for seven months.

handong123 2022-10-19

The speed is so slow. It has been two and a half months, and it is still under review.

爱汪汪wang 2022-10-07

Finally got it, submitted on July 15th, with 6 reviewers, went through two revisions, accepted on October 5th.

NUAAYLZ 2022-09-27

Very professional journal, and the reviewers are also very responsible. It takes one and a half months to receive comments. It takes half a month to revise, and 10 days to accept.

发发小论文 2022-09-24

How long does it take for the proof to be online after? I invested in April, just like you, and received it on the 13th.

Keviiiiin-8 2022-09-15

22.3.20 submit;
22.7.5 submit the revised form;
22.7.22 accept.
The speed is quite good. The review comments are professional and have improved the overall quality of the paper.

XP_Wang 2022-09-15

Accepted after modification on September 13, 2022.

853007793@qq.com 2022-08-31

6个觉得有新意 translates to "6 ideas that feel innovative" in English.

853007793@qq.com 2022-08-31

I have submitted to this journal several times, and now it is becoming increasingly difficult. The first time, there were seven reviewers for major revisions. Six of them rejected it for being unoriginal, and one rejected it outright. After a month of major revisions, the reviewer who rejected it initially still had suggestions that required further revisions. After three rounds of revisions, it was finally accepted. The submission to acceptance process took a total of six months, which is not bad, but the problem lies in the numerous issues with the reviewers. It is frustrating to make so many changes.

爱汪汪wang 2022-08-31

Please, I feel a little frustrated with the journal. I'm always unsuccessful. Can you give me a chance?

iscca2 2022-08-30

15/05/2022 Submission
14/07/2022 Received