君子慎独 2022-11-13

Posted on 10.12, not reviewed until 10.20, and now still dragging on with the rejection, wasting so much time...

半缘y 2022-11-12

This is too unfair. They have been dragging the rejection for so long.

七星光芒剑 2022-11-12

It is said that there is a system malfunction, and the modification suggestions have been stuck in the editing system.

blockbuster 2022-11-12

Ah, it seems like waiting for a long time for DIP (Decision in Principle) results in nothing in the end... Such a disappointment! Why do they take so long to reject a submission...

七星光芒剑 2022-11-12

On the fiftieth day, it was rejected.

半缘y 2022-11-11

25 days, no news.

七星光芒剑 2022-11-11

It's already the seventh week of DIP. Does anyone have any news?

圣嘉然庇佑 2022-11-09

Submission Experience
Submitted at the end of June.
First revision completed in early September, entered "decision in process" on the same day, returned for major revisions the next day.
Submitted revised manuscript in early October, review completed in November, entered "decision in process" on the same day, accepted notification received the same evening.
Submission Feelings
My first scientific publication took four months from submission to acceptance. The journal's processing speed and approach were good, and the opinions of the reviewers and editors were also fair. Overall, it was a very good experience.

半缘y 2022-11-07

I have been in the "decision in process" status since 10.16 until now...

chenxiaoyu123 2022-11-07

There was no decision process involved, and the initial comments were given directly. There were five reviewers, and the editor also provided some suggestions. In the midst of painful revisions, I will send the initial comments back this weekend.

七星光芒剑 2022-11-07

Keep up the good work, everyone, and please be patient. I submitted on 6-23, but there is still no first-round review result as of 9-23.

jywang 2022-11-07

My 10.19 application is still "decision in process" until now...

JialePeng 2022-11-07

ATE submission process
Submitted to the journal on 7-18
With editor on 7.21
Took one month for review
Under review on 8.24
Increased from two to four reviewers in the process
Required review complete on 10.9
Took almost a month from review completion to decision
Decision in process on 11.3
It has been almost four months and I still haven't received the review comments
Hoping for good news (someone who submitted at the same time as me has already had their article published)

jywang 2022-11-06

Could it be Dip's article? Did the editors all read it themselves?

blockbuster 2022-11-05

Has the senior brother upstairs dipped? How many times did the upstairs review take so long?

发Sci发到手抽筋 2022-11-05

I thought the editor was unable to process the manuscript due to some issues, but it turns out that my senior's first review comments came back today... and they require significant revisions.

Khalleesi 2022-11-05

My decision has been in process for over a month...

半缘y 2022-11-04

Refused and immediately said, so I can find another job. It has been more than 20 days of unclear situation.

blockbuster 2022-11-04

Has the decision-making process occurred? It seems that the return for repair is quite fast, the one that has been in DIP is probably going to fail...

chenxiaoyu123 2022-11-03

The first round of review comments were received on October 16th, and there were five reviewers with major revisions.

Qishiwu 2022-11-03

I have also made a decision for 40 days...

fangcan365 2022-11-03

I don't know what the editor is doing. I want to submit directly to others instead. Does this count as multiple submissions?

Hc DENG 2022-11-03

I have also been making decisions for almost a month.

blockbuster 2022-11-02

What's going on here... If anyone has any updates, please share them here...

七星光芒剑 2022-11-02

I have sent the email, but I have only received an official reply asking me to wait.

发Sci发到手抽筋 2022-11-02

Brother, have you sent the email?

七星光芒剑 2022-11-01

It has been over 40 days since the decision was made, 233333.

发Sci发到手抽筋 2022-11-01

I have been in the decision-making process for half a month as well...

jywang 2022-11-01

I have also been in the decision in process for half a month, and still no result. I don't know what the editor-in-chief is doing...

blockbuster 2022-10-31

It will be twenty days soon and still no news. Are the original poster and a few others upstairs still without any news?