Double L 2023-05-18

It has been 24 days with the Editor, is it normal?

halyyy 2023-05-18

3.28投 - Submitted on March 28th
5.16修回 - Revised on May 16th
但是只有一个审稿人的意见 - However, there is only one reviewer's opinion
期刊发邮件要求两天内co-author每个人都要确认，否则退稿 - The journal sent an email requesting confirmation from each co-author within two days, otherwise the paper will be rejected
这是真的吗 - Is this true?

jay 2023-05-17

The questions raised by the reviewer are very professional, and the editing efficiency is high. It is not as slow as mentioned online, but rather very fast.

jay 2023-05-17

This journal is much more efficient than before, as mentioned by recent online feedback. The review process is extremely fast, with the first review completed within half a month. The reviewers' opinions are particularly professional, and acceptance can be expected within about two months. The quality of the articles is getting higher and higher. Friends who want to submit their work should hurry up. Feel free to leave a message for any questions or discussions. Wishing ASS journal continued success.

Gppdd 2023-05-17

2023.01.26 1 am submission
2023.01.26 5 am notification sent to editor for processing and review
2023.03.23 Received two minor revisions, the first one requires additional experiment, and the second one has only one suggestion. Editor requests a two-week revision deadline, but due to the delay in writing a major thesis application, the revision is completed after a month.
2023.04.25 Revised manuscript
2023.04.26 Under review
2023.05.09 Accepted
2023.05.14 Published online
The editor is Dr. Rie Makiura, who handled the submission at lightning speed. It was the smoothest submission experience, highly praised.

哟有 2023-05-16

I hope to be employed and fulfill my promise after being employed.

哟有 2023-05-16

4.13 submitted to journal
4.15 with editor
4.28 under review
5.16 currently still under review status, the editor has only found one reviewer.

Niuniu_Li 2023-05-16

Come here and feel the European vibes!

哟有 2023-05-16

Was it posted by the Applied Surface Science account?

冬至 2023-05-16

After submission, the editor will send the corresponding author a real-time status link of the manuscript, where they can track the progress of the peer-review process.

哟有 2023-05-16

How can we tell if the reviewer has completed the review?

哟有 2023-05-16

How do you know if the reviewer has completed the review?

铁拳男人 2023-05-16

Dear experts, I would like to inquire why there was no link sent to the communication email after the paper went under review. Previously, when one of my papers was accepted, a link was sent. I am wondering if this situation could be a fake review. Thank you.

冬至 2023-05-13

2023-3-27 Submitted to journal;
3-28 With editor; Nini Pryds, PhD
3-29 Under review;
4-7 Reviewer 1 agrees to review;
4-9 Reviewer 1 completes review;
4-10 Reviewer 2 agrees to review;
4-11 Reviewer 2 completes review;
4-11 Required reviews completed;
4-15 Major revision;
5-3 Revision submitted to journal;
5-4 With editor;
5-5 Under review;
5-5 Required reviews completed;
5-12 Accept.
The first review was quick, with both reviewers completing their assessments in just one day. Initially, it seemed like the manuscript might be rejected, but ultimately the editor requested major revisions. The second round of reviews from both reviewers was also prompt, with feedback provided on the same day. However, the editor may have been busy, causing a slight delay. Overall, the process was fast, and I wish the journal continued success. I also hope that everyone will have their submissions accepted!

ssai 2023-05-12

The review is very professional and fast.

Double L 2023-05-11

How is editor Jeff Terry? It has been 20 days and he is still with the editor.

chengfu 2023-05-11

Elsevier's journals will send an article status tracking email to the corresponding email address.

木燚 2023-05-06

How to check if the nth reviewer has completed the review?

chengfu 2023-05-05

Submission Experience:
2023.01.16 Submitted
2023.01.21 Under review
2023.01.30 First reviewer completed review
2023.02.02 Second reviewer agreed to review
2023.03.04 Second reviewer completed review
2023.03.07-03.12 Reviewer comments, all major revisions accepted, editor decides for major revision, 3 weeks given: return revisions before April 1st
2023.03.29 Revised
2023.04.03 Under review
2023.04.04 First reviewer completed review
2023.04.12 Second reviewer completed review
2023.04.14 Accepted
2023.04.18 Proofreading
2023.04.20 Online
Second SCI article during the Ph.D. period!!!
Impression: Mainly delayed by the second reviewer for most of the time, but the editor was quite efficient. Thanks to editor FATIMA MONTEMOR, and best wishes for Applied Surface Science's continuous success!!!

木燚 2023-05-02

I forgot which one it was, but there was one review that wasn't very good.

杰行天下 2023-05-02

Excuse me, how is Marta Alves as an editor? Is she fast in reviewing?

jay 2023-04-29

Which editor are you? It has been 10 days since I returned for repairs, but it hasn't been reviewed yet.

jay 2023-04-29

How are the suggestions given by the reviewer?

木燚 2023-04-29

4.26. Reply draft uploaded
4.27. Submitted for review again
Is there a chance to win?

jay 2023-04-28

How long have you submitted?

上交学者 2023-04-26

There are more people submitting, and the journal is becoming more voluminous. The editors are very slow, but I hope to be able to have one article accepted.

聪匆那年 2023-04-15

2023.04.14 Article received, I'm truly fed up.

聪匆那年 2023-04-13

2022.12.05 Submission
2022.12.15 Under review
2023.02.14 Reviewer comments received, 4 reviewers, 3 accept, 1 major revision, editor requests major revision
2023.03.04 Reply to reviewer comments
2023.04.05 Editor reminded once
2023.04.13 Still under review, frustrated...

青牛煮酒 2023-04-09

2023-2-13: Submit to journal
2023-2-14: With editor
2023-3-6: Under review
2023-3-16: Major revised
2023-4-8: Accept

木燚 2023-04-06

Did you receive it in the end?